Give me your honest, unadulterated opinion of this

Give me your honest, unadulterated opinion of this

10/10, not my favourite but it's up there

10/10. Sloop John B is great, anyone who doesn't like it is a pleb

10/10
it's ok

It's an A-minus to me, the songwriting is great, the whole thing sounds excellent in terms of the little things, and it has several amazing individual songs. But it's not like it doesn't have some pedestrian moments, Here Today for example, and Don't Talk/Caroline No aren't really my thing although they're not bad.

Great stuff, just not top-tier.

Greatest album of all time. Sometimes I honestly can't believe that music this good can exists. the harmonies are simply not of this earth. Brian was touched by a higher power.

I don't hold it up as the epitome of all music. Mostly because I don't want to listen to it when I'm not in that blissful mood it has. But on a road trip or a happy Saturday it's very hard to beat

Almost objectively perfect
Sloop John B is the only track that holds it back, and even then it's still pretty good, just incongruous

10/10

Once there was a girl I thought I loved, but she didn't like Pet Sounds, so I realized she wasn't the one.

Imagine thinking this is better than Disintegration