Who was the best musician, overall, in the end?

Who was the best musician, overall, in the end?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=t7fYjSwyodI
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

better musician ? gilmour

better lyricist, singer, and overall artist? waters

waters

Syd

this desu

me

>Waters
>Good singer

trips of truth

Fish vs Horse, the age long question. I'll vote fish this time.

DG is arguably the best guitarist of all time. Most would objectively put him in their top ten. RW is a very good bassist but not particularly world class. Bit of a shit question really OP, or were you aiming for the contrarian demographic?

better than ghoulish gilmour

Better musician and singer? Gilmour

Better Lyricist and song writer? Waters

posting on Sup Forums = aiming for the contrarian demographic

imagine being this big of a pleb, to actually think this

like asking "Whats more important, skeletal system or muscular system"

I like it. Can Rick Wright be the lungs and Nick Mason the heartbeat?

ashes and diamonds
foe and friend
they were all equal in the end

Underrated

This makes so much sense, is Syd the soul?

kidney

Like, an alcoholic's kidney that gave out? That does make more sense.

Syd is definitely the heartbeat you plebs, he's the whole reason they do the bass drum heartbeat thing

yep

Syd here, Rogie was better

The worst part about the wall is the fact waters took it upon himself to sing most of it and left Gilmour sidelined, as talented as he is it's one of the worst decisions he's ever made.

He had a massive bypass allright

Idiot

>be Roger Waters
>wake up after having nightmare of still living in Thatcherian England
>get off bed
>masturbate to your dad's photo, the greatest man that has ever lived
>go take your morning crap on your Maggie Thatcher shaped toilet, paid with all the royalties you made in these last decades
>have breakfast
>wrote some lyrics for your new album about how famel leader of democratic England Maggie Thatcher was in the wrong for not letting the British citizens of Fal- Malvinas being conquered by a military dictatorship ruled by straight, white, old, fascist men
>this is good shit
>have lunchm watch news
>see some band is going to play in neoliberal aparthied Israel
>spend one hour leaving messages on their voicemail not to do it
>time to go to work
>make a new song that features synths and black women choirs
>go smoke some weed
>see your pacifist dad raping thatcher in the war
>then phone prank David telling him it's Syd and that his new album is shit
>have dinner
>raise a glass of wine to Syd and his mental breakdown
>spend rest of night ranting on online forums about how your daddy did not die in ww2 so Maggie Thatcher would steal milk from the children and how living under Hitler would be much better than in a neoliberal regime
>go to sleep
>today was a good day

his voice is perfect for some songs, like Pigs, Sheep and Run Like Hell

kek

Holy shit kek

>Musician
Gilmour
>Singer
Gilmour
>Lyricist/Songwriter
Waters
>Overall artist
Waters

You're all missing the point. Richard Wright was the air that the rest of the band breathed; without him, there was/is nothing.

*blocks your paths*

Richard Wright

What’s L Ron Hubbard got to do with anything?

Makes me wonder how many 60+ English blokes I see were once actually psychedelic schizoids wearing velvet trousers and paisley scarves like our syd

Joe Alessi
Rad bone player
youtube.com/watch?v=t7fYjSwyodI

fpbp
didn't even have to say it

Lmao damn

saved

Beethoven.

Pretty sure it's Beethoven.

>only good when he's singing about hating jews

I unironically think Syd was the better guitarist compard to Gimour. I don't know why, Piper just gets me every time

Let's be real, neither Gilmour nor Waters resembles anything like a pleasing singer, comparing them is a painful exercise.

yep