Sort an artist's discography

post your hot takes

template

Why do people like Abbey Road? It's so boring and is basically a shorter Let It Be. "muh medley!" is not a valid answer.

please please me is their best record

>Beatles for Sale shit

How to spot a Pleb 101

Rubber Soul is such a meme that whenever I see a post praising it as above 6/10 without rigorous explanation I just tune it out. Same with Revolver.
With Sgt. Peppers, Abbey Road, Help!, or A Hard Day's Night I can smell what you're stepping in, but anything outside of that demands some kind of explanation.

>Why do people like Abbey Road?
I have no idea. It's by FAR their worst album imho. I think people only like it to seem cool, and because the world is round, it turns me on.

...

this happens routinely on Sup Forums and i get triggered every time

Definitive ranking

Fixed

Starting with an easy one

Hard Days Night is God tier, Yellow Submarine is between average and poor

...

...

>The Final Cut and Ummagumma shit
>Meddle, Animals and Piper not being god-tier
Pleb

>Piper and Echoes not in God Tier

...

Where's HDN?

...

I love how everyone seems to call meddle echoes. Mastapeece

hey guys i fixed it

>God Tier
Led Zeppelin I
Led Zeppelin IV

>Good
Led Zeppelin II
Physical Graffiti

>Average
Houses of the Holy
Led Zeppelin III

>Bad
Precence
In Through the Out Door

>Shit
Coda

...

Horsey and Cats Drunk on Copper are pretty good.

White album was shit I quit after the B side and didn't bother with side C and D
(I still respect your opinion user, don't let me influence your opinion either)

Surprisingly accurate.

Never been huge on those records 2bh

It has a few good tracks. Here Comes The Sun and Come Together are both pretty great tunes. But lots of poorer tracks. Not top 5 at all

Definitely a contender but I'd give it to Hard Days Night personally

For Swans :

GOD TIER
Children of God
Soundtracks for the Blind
To Be Kind

GOOD
Filth
Cop
Love of Life
The Great Annihilator
The Glowing Man

AVERAGE
Greed
Holy Money
The Seer

POOR
White Light from the Mouth of Infinity
My Father Will Guide Me Up A Rope to the Sky

SHIT
The Burning World

Holy fuck you're actually retarded

Mean Mr. Mustard is better than most bands' best album.

...

post your ranking

Move Piper and Meddle to God tier and this is perfect.

Almost OP, but not perfect

>I better than III and Houses of the Holy

III is literally their best

>Houses of the Holy is a top tier LZ album
one of the worst musical memes that's ever been perpetrated on this board. HotH isn't even close to the level of greatness on LZ I through IV. it's toothless, boring, tries way too hard to be different and ends up sounding like a generic pop rock record. LZ I through IV are classic records that defined rock music. HotH was Led Zeppelin settling down to get on the radio

>Liking Led Zeppelin

Bump Imperium up and this is my exact opinion as well.

Yes i'm a bit contrarian but this is my subjective opinion

>God Tier
Here Comes The Indian
STGTV
Hollindagain
Sung Tongs
>Good
Strawberry Jam
Feels
Campfire Songs
>Average
Danse Manatee
MPP
Centipede Hz
Meeting Of The Waters
>Bad
Painting With

>Shit
N/A

Rubber Soul is so overrated it’s not even funny

I enjoy yeezus but this is the correct ranking

This is objective

They'll let anyone be a tripfag these days, huh?
This is so unbelievably wrong I don't know where to start.

>God Tier: 808s and Heartbreak**

I like Satellite Flight more than it really deserves but other than that I think my ratings here are ok

The other PF ranking is complete trash so here's the correct one

I don't have time for this.

I'd swap out Meddle and Piper for Atom Heart Mother and Animals.

...

swap ok c with in rainbows and hail to the thief with the bends

The Final Cut is like if Bob Dylan lost his 'too cool for you' persona and developed an interest in Broadway show tunes.

nein

...

glad most people agree the wall is "eh" at best and WYWH is their best work

>muh medley is not a valid answer
Only one they have user.

I'm guessing the album cover has something to do with it desu.

Also, it's arguably George's best showing; his contributions absolutely shine.

I Want You is also fairly experimental so the Johnfags like it.

Come Together's bassline is a meme so that probably fuels some praise too? idk.

worst taste

...

>jumping straight from good to god-tier

>Homogenic is shit
Explain this.

A 9/10 for me, but compared to her other albums it is shit. It's one of her most mainstream and least expirimental albums.

>9/10 in the shit section
>Homogenic being more mainstream than Post and Debut
>Being mainstream is automatically a negative

Now I’m just more confused. So your chart isn’t a personal ranking or it is one and the other albums are scored super high?

...

I didn't mean mainstream in the sense of it's mainstream success, I meant it was one of her safest and bland albums in terms of it's production and lyrics. I could have worded that better.

Right but you still said it was a 9/10 and put it in the "shit" section which means either the others are so amazing they had to top it or you just put it in the wrong section.

Are all the others above 9/10? Are you ranking them """objectively"""?

>"muh medley!" is not a valid answer.
muh medley

I ranked them personally from her best records, to worst records. I know i'm a fag but all of her other records (aside from self titled) are a 10/10 for me.

This is what all my normie ass faget friends think. You aren't a normie ass faget are you user?

is correct

>homogenic that low
Kill yourself

...

>Move Queen I to the top row
>Jazz up one row
>Innuendo, The Game, and News of the World down one row

Fixed

Much better

...

...

...

Move HW, PE, and GAG up one, move BV down two and it's perfect.

...

I love Please Please Me. It's before they found their "sound" and were making classic jukebox songs.

...

Probably my least favorite from the 2nd half of their career since it seems a little too dadrock, but it has George's best contributions, its got Because, and Sun King. That's all you need. Other than that, it's the one album that's GOAT for normies.

nope

...

Clockwork angels was average dude and caress of steel isn't that good tbqhwy

die

>Grading on a curve: The image

>Dog's Blood Rising
>Poor

Does it hurt to be this pleb?

you're a fucking idiot

Hot Space and Miracle down that low?

that's how you know why they overrate the album: because they're only thinking of Echoes which by itself is a god-tier song. The album as a whole is appropriately good-tier

>college dropout>late registration

top kek pseudo-oldfag
they equal at best

woah woah woah White Light poor?

swap The Bends with TKOL

Toothpaste suburb gets put on an undeserved pedestal
good experimentation with the wispy, atmospheric beats but flies was just a better version of that

things that happen is monolithic my dude great rankings

...

How does one posses such a terrible taste?

...

>dangerdoom that low
horrible taste