It seems /comp/ is gone for good but surely there's enough room in /classical/ for our fledgling composers and hobbyists. Post clyps and scores for exercises and compositions here and get feedback. (No "beats" please)
Yes. He stands alone, the GOAT. He beat a bitch, like Chyna did Rob.
Christopher Perry
it sounds like Radiohead
Isaiah Watson
nigga is dat lil Tray Tray? What he doin' wif dat peetsa. yeah. Beethoven is betta lol
Jayden Adams
The way I see it Ravel is the Mozart to Debussy's Haydn.
Colton Flores
In other words, a lesser, more boring version of Beethoven compared to a literally whofag with a giant cock (pic rel8-ed)
Chase Sullivan
Sounds like Thom Spork in a chastity belt with a pussy hat on protesting Drumpf
Lincoln Butler
Beethoven is more like Messiaen. Its not really better, its just something completely alien and sui generis. Its what's required once the idiom has been perfected. But strictly speaking I'd say its more difficult to perfect than it is to invent.
Dylan Walker
>But strictly speaking I'd say its more difficult to perfect than it is to invent. Hmm... idk bout dat
Brandon White
>listening to well-tempered music in equal temperament
basically as soon as you pay attention. Everything I've ever heard by Brahms is a banger.
Mason Adams
fucking kek what is this pic from.
Xavier Miller
>music has 10ths and above in
who here /small hands/ ?
Can’t even reach a 9th ;_;
Jayden Clark
I've been meaning to ask, what is the origin of this image?
Leo Bell
>Rach hands >never learned an instrument
Bentley Long
lol hey everyone look at this handlet
desu i stole it from some user who started a /classical/ thread on here a year or so ago
Samuel Scott
Cello sonata no. 1
Ryder Perry
I do. I never really noticed until someone pointed them out
Landon Smith
Is there something I'm missing with Mendelssohn's quartets?
Aiden Ross
yes, a brain
Thomas Hernandez
Got me.
Tyler Ramirez
yfw
Lincoln Clark
Webern > Schoenberg
Leo Jenkins
Prove it.
Owen Nelson
what's there to prove? Its self evident
Christopher Long
That was my way of asking "where to start with Webern"?
Daniel Morgan
then why did you feel the need to state it?
Eli Martin
Very good chart.
Samuel Thomas
Anybody doing some interesting Theory things
Lincoln Johnson
What do you mean? Like are there any composers developing new theoretical concepts?
Benjamin Thomas
What are the best channels on youtube for learning composition from the ground up.
Brayden Hughes
art of counterpoint for counterpoint. There isn't much in the way of comprehensive "learn composition from the ground up", you're better off reading Schoenberg's Fundamentals of Musical Composition, or studying composition formally.
Aiden Lewis
But I can't read boring old books on internet capable devices user!
Yeah, Ligeti knows what's up. I have no idea why French Horn is such a maligned brass instrment when its the only one that doesn't sound like a fart. Well that is, aside from the even more underappreciated Wagner Tuba.
If that's the case I guess I'm fucked. I'm Lithuanian. The only composer we have is Čiurlionis and he fucking sucks. Whats more is he's more known as a painter.
Do you honestly believe any of these composers are even close to the level of claire boucher ?
Jack Jones
idk user but no one even comes close to your level of trolololololololol
Andrew Hernandez
no like anyone /comp/ doing something interesting with their theory
Ryan Martin
that channel is ok at best, he makes too many mistakes and he is teaching composers bad counterpoint
Jaxon Fisher
>trolololololololol did i go back in time to 2012
Dylan Turner
claire is not a joke!
she's got far more complex music and production than anything you've posted
Benjamin Carter
Thoughts on bernstein?
Alexander Allen
Everything he would learn, from the books already he posesses. Learned nothing new can be, burn the tree we must
Michael Anderson
t Claire is talented because she heard a Dildogard song and coppied what happened. Melisma Melisma Melisma. With your logic fucking Hip Hop is fenous when they use a triplet flow over an uncommon time signature
Eli Brooks
Gay, and trash
Jaxson Ross
a jew
Julian Wright
I know it is exciting when mom lets you use the computer but you are posting in the wrong place
Isaiah Kelly
faggot and a shit conductor. ok as a musical composer
Gabriel Baker
Debussy, Faure, Maurice Emmanuel>>>>>>Ravel
Camden Ramirez
>posts copypasta >calls me underage No he's okay at classical era stuff but romantic and modern I think hes to gay to do. Olus WSS is trash as is age of anxiety and other things hes written
Elijah Baker
This soy boy levels of condescension, may I suggest reddit classical?
Josiah Carter
wrote good books and made good music not a fan of his conducting work
The Unanswered Question is a compelling read but at the same time almost complete speculation
What is the best neoclassical composer and why is it Hindemith?
Jaxson Carter
Absolutely terrible. He's been writing the same tired shit for decades. Should have just thrown in the towel like 30 years ago. Who here actually likes Reich?
David Green
Relative freedom allowed within a country that prized music. Czechs and Hungarians were all part of the Austrian empire for goodness knows how long, and Finns were the most independent part of the European area of the Swedish empire, and later of the Russian empire. This mix of being considerably independent within a larger empire did lead to calls to freedom and a representation of national identity in the Romanticist era while before that rise it allowed them the same tutelage that many others did not - for example, Slovakia, which was part of Hungary then. This is shown in Chopin, Liszt and Dvorak, for example.
Really, it's just history playing a role here. If anything the most surprising thing is the lack of classical music from the Anglos.
