ITT: Unpopular opinions

Although Syd Barrett was an inspiration to the band, Pink Floyd was dogshit when he was still in the band.

Is that an unpopular opinion? As soon as he left they became world famous

U2 is probably the worst band of all time.

>PATGOD
>shit

I'm a big Waters era fan and even I think that's retarded.

But the only album they have with him in it is also their best one.

this is objectively correct

they're just shoegaze for normies

>Overhead the albatross hangs motionless upon the air and deep beneath the rolling waves in labyrinths of coral caves

vs.

>I've got a bike you can ride it if you like

I think that Hendrix's cover of All Along the Watchtower is inferior to the original.

Growing up in a classic rock family, this one basically got me crucified

>Lyrics
>Mattering

Bike is a great song

Not even the lyrics, the instrumentals are shit too.

>Wow it's loud and incoherent and I don't understand it
>It has no structure and it's painful to listen to
>Must mean it's great

Paramore is only now considered patrician-tier because Fantano drew attention to them.

Are you describing Piper at the Gates of Dawn or The Wall?

You know damn well which one, guy.

>For all the time spent in that room
>The doll’s house, darkness, old perfume
>And fairy stories held me high
>On clouds of sunlight floating by
VS
>Money, get away
>Get a good job with more pay and you're okay
>Money, it's a gas
>Grab that cash with both hands and make a stash

Lol

>lyrics alluding to infancy and childhood are worse than longwinded pap

I just think syd is sadly one of the most overrated entities in music period. 1 good album, no cohesive follow up or anything to really justify the heir of mystery surrounding him.

What's truly sad about musicians struggling with mental illness, its not that people aren't ready to hear their music, its that they stop making it. There's not a lot of time to finish your songs or put together a show ready performance once you've actually lost touch with reality.

that distinction is held by maroon5

>insubstantial lyrics with no point and an overreliance on random imagery
Vs
>a song with an actual point and theme

Thanks for proving that Waters is a much more talented lyricist.

Never mind that people romantacise mental illness through his story.

Kanye is a talentless hack.

more unpopular opinions .

kurt was losing his creative edge before he died

antics > turn on the bright lights

I honestly believe this might have been why he killed himself, although that can be blamed on drugs for depriving the brain of dopamine.

This really isn't an unpopular opinion. Most Pink Floyd fans would absolutely agree. On this board that's pretty sacrilegious though. Also it shows you have garbage taste like all the normie floyd fans.

Kanye's vocals ruined this album

not even close, the worst band is Simple Plan

are they really considered patrician tier? i mean, i like after laughter and all, but i've never seen someone on this board call them patrician (in a way that i didn't think was ironic).

DSOTM > WYWH > pipers > Meddle >>>>> rest

(you)

wrong. paramore was always patrician since the first album.

The features ruined the album.

gimme some more sweet sweet slow core like this pls

>insubstantial lyrics with no point and an overreliance on random imagery
you mean like Echoes? I like both Barrett and Waters, but you can't defend that song's lyrics while simultaneously tearing apart the other when they're trying to do the same thing.

lmao @ your post
>seamus(thats the dog)

well i agree, and would have suffered the same fate.

that opinion is only unpopular on Sup Forums

I agree with you. I still I can't stand the harmonica playing though, its so ear piercing it makes it unlistenable for me.

didn't his suicide letter allude to his worries about letting down his fans?

yeah i can tell you haven't been here long.

I used to like psychedelic music but now I think it kind of sucks.

>Find a great obscure 60's garage rock group
>Snarling vocals, stinging fuzz guitars, menacing punk attitude
>1967 rolls around
>They switch to doing boring-ass hippie songs about assigning a colour to each day of the week or something

name?

>>They switch to doing boring-ass hippie songs about assigning a colour to each day of the week or something
But thats a great way to organize your socks

ok user u didnt have to go that far

pink floyd with sb >> pink floyd w/o sb
any other opinion is pleb.

This