Choose one

...

Red

>Blue
Heaven or Las Vegas - 8
Loveless - 6
Laughing Stock - 8
If you're feeling Sinister - 9
Homogenic - 5
OKC - 9

>Red
Spiderland - 6
Blue Album - 9
IAOTS - 9
Lonesome Crowded West - 8

Tough call, I'd barely give the edge to blue though.

Not going to choose, but is the left supposed to be more melodic, subtle and dense and the right is more rough, heavy and more guitar-based?

red solely to get rid of ok computer forever

Red by a tiny bit, although I'm heartbroken to see SAW, Loveless, and Stereolab go

It's UK vs USA

Blue easily

Red for sure

it's north america vs rest of the world

>Fishmans
>UK

>Godspeed
>USA

blue
not OP but its UK vs US

even though its a very touch choice i'll have to go with red, it has several of my favorite albums of all time

Left is Europe and Japan, right is US and Canada

Red.
So much soy in blue

>Yo La Tengo
>NMH
>American Football
>GY!BE
>Weezer
>Nirvana
Red by a mile and a half

Blue
So much soy in red

I'll take MBV, Slowdive, Portishead, Massive Attack, Fugazi, Slint, Nirvana Red House Painters, GbV, Low, Yo La Tengo, Elliott Smith, and NMH... so obviously red/North America

Blue by a pretty wide margin

>laughing stock and selected ambient works being soy

How the fuck are Bjork and Sigur Ros UK?

throw spiritualized over oasis on blue and i'd take blue.
in that state it's red by a mile.

Belle and sebastian is the soyest/cuckest thing in the world

>Blue
+Loveless, Laughing Stock, TRNBWA, Dummy, Tri Repetae, OKC, MHTRTC
-Nowhere, Souvlaki, DI Go Pop, Morning Glory
Overall score: 4

>Red
+Spiderland, Nevermind, Millions Now Living, Endtroducing, ITAOTS
-Siamese Dream, Blue, TLCW, Soft Butt, Am I a Ball
Overall score: 0

This is pretty tough. The both have albums I love and other albums I hate. Probably blue though.

It's obviously old world vs new world you fucking brainlets

blue because its less depressing in quantity.
Also where Laughing Stock and Agaetis Bryjun make me feel emotions, GYBE tries and fails to do so.

>Blue
Heaven or Las Vegas - 6
Nowhere - 7
Loveless - 10
Laughing Stock - 8
Souvlaki - 8
Dummy - 8
Morning Glory - 6
If You're Feeling Sinister - 5
Homogenic - 8
OK Computer - 10

>Red
Repeater - 9
Spiderland - 10
Down Colorful Hill - 6
Weezer - 6
I Could Live In Hope - 6
The Lonesome Crowded West - 8
Perfect From Now On - 9
ITAOTS - 9
69 Love Song - 3
American Football - 8

Pretty close, but I fucking hate 69 Love Songs so blue edges it

i totally agree, almost every song on that album is filler to try to get it to the number 69. haha xD epic joke

Blue:

6 6 7 7 8
6 4 5 8 4
7 2 5 4 7
8 5 6 7 5

Red:

8 9 7 6 7
4 4 6 6 7
7 7 8 6 9
9 6 7 4 5

Blue - Pleb
Red - Patrician

>loveless, ok computer and spiderland 10/10
t. pitchcuck pleb

Red if switch Nirvana with Fisherman

>weezer
>not the soyest fucking band in existance

Considering how good Blue album was and its the nineties, I would't mind.

Red because Repeater is better than anything else on that list

red by a landslide.

sigur ros isn't (neither is fishmans) but to be fair, bjork was living in the uk during homogenic

Blue: 5.85
Red: 6.60

Music is thrash anyway.

why does america suck do much at the electronic music game

red

Siamese Dream, Millions Now Living and Endtroducing are the only albums on red that I care about.

Blue not even close. Only good stuff on red is Spiderland and Americ anFootball.

Blue is an incredibly easy choice

>blue album ratedly as highly as anything else

dogshit taste, friendo

Blue

Either/Or tho

Blue

both are such shit

""people"" who say red are everything wrong with this board

blue is trash as fuck

Still an Icelandic artist

Blue mostly because Tri Repetae

blue

Blue:
8 ? 6 9 8
9 4 9 8 7
7 6 10 ? 9
10 7 9 ? 7
Sum: 133

Red:
6 9 8 8 8
? 8 7 7 9
9 9 8 9 8
10 10 8 ? 9
Sum: 150

I love America, almost as much as I hate Radiohead. This is too easy

Sure thing, friendo

Blue just because Oasis

Red, no questions asked.

what is that brown-grey album on the left side

what is that ocean wave album on the left side

Brown-grey: Autechre - Tri Repetae
Ocean wave: Ride - Nowhere

thanks!

unironically this

...

This, but explain why

Blue fucking sucks dude
If red was just Down Colorful Hill and Low and the rest being nothing is still pick it over blue

red literally sounds all the same

t. Idiot

Blue

If blue was just Loveless and Laughing Stock it would still be objectively better than red
Slowcore is garbage my friend.

Blue
6 3 9 9 6
6 8 6 6 8
7 2 7 5 6
6 ? 5 5 6
Red
8 9 4 6 4
5 6 3 8 6
7 6 6 6 7
6 6 6 3 3
Give me blue desu

You're incapable of having fun

>blue
++++ Disco Inferno
+ Aphex Twin, Fishmans, Portishead, Bark Psychosis, Talk Talk
~ Autechre, Massive Attack
- MBV, Stereolab, Belle and Sebastian, BoC, Radiohead, Sigur Ros
>red
++++ Elliott Smith
+ Nirvana, Low, Modest Mouse
~ Slint, RHP, Smashing Pumpkins, Pavement, GY!BE, Tortoise, DJ Shadow,
- Weezer, NMH, Magnetic Fields, American Football

There are more bands I particularly like or dislike on blue, and a lot more I don't really care about either way on red. I like Disco Inferno better than Elliott Smith though, so I'll go with blue.

-Belle & Sebastian, Radiohead, Weezer, NMH

I don't like you

They aren't terrible bands. I like a handful of B&S and Radiohead songs, and I like NMH ok in general, more or less- but I think ITAOTS is a bit worse than On Avery Island and it doesn't stand up to the memeing. Weezer I unapologetically dislike aside from the "oh this song isn't as bad as some on the radio" way