Which one?

Which one?


>Better lore: LOTR
>Better characters: SW
>Better plot: SW
>Better writing: LOTR
>Better music: SW
>Better directing: LOTR
>Worse prequels: SW
>Better memes: SW


I think I'm gonna have to go LOTR

>Better music
>star wars
Frig off

>Better books: LOTR
>Better toys: SW
>Better movies: ...fuuuuuuuck

>Better Characters: SW
okay
>Worse Prequels: SW
ah no.
>Better Memes: SW
I actually will object to this with a solid argument.

SW already had a massive pop culture presence and it was elevated significantly by their endless sequels and EU. So it only stands to reason that when memes finally did get rolling after both released, SW held a monopoly.

But the quality of said memes or even the potential for memes were undeniably better in LOTR.
>pipe references
>gondor calls for aid
>homoerotic hobbits
>You have no power here
>"Just use Eagles lol"
>council of Elrond

Don't tell me you forgot about the legendary, ancient, 20 minute council of Elrond GIF.

>>Better plot: SW
No
>Worse prequels: SW
No

Here it is

>Better for autist core children who don't care about plot holes: SW
>Better for adults who can understand complexities and underlying themes: LOTR

Yeah, and this is why LOTR has better writing


But SW's plot is a lot better and complex. "A son has to defeat his father" is a lot better than "midget has to walk to volcano"

LOOKS LIKE

What a question..
LOTR is so much more epic in every way.
The music is brilliant.
Had so many unforgettable scenes.
>ride of the roharim
>march of ents
>sam, frodo on Mount Doom
>you shall not pass
ect, etc
Star Wars is great and all but it's not epic in any way.

Still, I think the prequels were more entertaining than the hobbit trilogy.
Although Hobbit was better made.
(expect for the third movie)

>Better lore: LOTR
This is no competition. Star Wars was a "write-as-we-go" scenario. LOTR is based off of a series of books written by an autist who created a depth of history for his stories that is unparalleled in literature.
>Better characters: LOTR
Both have some tropes but SW follows closely to too many cliches and lacks enough complex characters, and those who are complex aren't likable in any way
>Better plot: This is the closest bone I'll give SW but still goes to LOTR
>Better writing: LOTR
This shouldn't even need defending
>Better music: LOTR
While SW has some fantastic music (some of its best coming in the prequels), LOTR has the best film soundtrack OF ALL TIME
>Better directing: LOTR
>Worse prequels: LOTR
>Better memes: LOTR

That's a quality post
I agree

lotr is unwatchable trash and its fanbase should be gassed. leave this site

Ft. Anally devastated morgothfag.

>Better characters: LOTR
Gonna have to disagree with you there, I thi-
>some of the best SW music is in the prequels
Oohhhhhhhh, nevermind, you're 16.

SW is for manbabies sitting in mom's basement and watching Luke kissing his sister over and over again.
No go away and watch your space family drama you little whiney faggot

>>Better music: LOTR
>While SW has some fantastic music (some of its best coming in the prequels), LOTR has the best film soundtrack OF ALL TIME


Not even close. The theme, Imperial March and Cantina Band are first tier

Bespin, Hoth, shit the Empire score alone defeats all of LotR.

>Better memes: SW

fuck off, eagleposting is a way better meme than anything SW has come out with

Comparing just the OT and the 3 LOTR films, I'd have to go with star wars simply off the strength of ESB. If you throw in the prequels then LOTR takes it

>this is what plebs unironically think

Only newfags would think Star Wars memes are superior to LOTR memes.

Star wars compared to lotr is like comparing no man's sky to dwarf fortress.

>I've never listened to any SW OT score.

Middle Earth kinda died with Tolkein in terms of new content. The Chris Tolkein stuff just wasn't the same. Whereas Star Wars can keep going forever because the different media and styles really work for it. Not so much for LOTR

Mate, the prequels had excellent music.

Fuck your fairy elven bullshit. Star Wars is a cultural icon.

this desu

what is more embarrassing though...being
>16
or posting on Sup Forums as a person who is old enough to have experienced the OG star wars trilogy in theaters

you're also underage as far as this discussion is concerned

and no, I am not underage. just not retarded and can recognize some of the amazing music from the sw prequels

Isn't Star Wars just an antichrist parable like berserk? Darth Vader is just the Griffith to obi wan's guts.

What?

Better Lore: LotR

if we are including the EU then no LotR doesn't even stand a chance

Star Wars EU is awful.

kotor was neat

Bigger does not mean better


SW includes stupidities like Luuke, Luuuke, Bigger Like and Breasts


No one makes fun of LOTR lore at all

Yeah, Kotor 1 and 2 were awesome games. The EU as a whole was a complete mess and for the most part poorly-written.

LOTR doesn't have breasts?

Lord of the Rings is superior to Star Wars in every way. I say this as someone who is a huge Star Wars fan, and who only kind of likes Lord of the Rings.

I'd say the only way Star Wars could win is if you compare individual movies. A New Hope, for instance, could beat out any Lord of the Ring movie. But if you're talking about Star Wars as a whole, there's just so much garbage. The most embarrassing thing about Lord of the Rings is the Hobbit prequel trilogy, and even that wasn't that bad (especially when compared to the Star Wars prequels, which I like, but they're bad).

Here is the patrician ranking

FOTR>ESB>ANH=TT>ROTK>ROTJ

patrician status not open for discussion

WRONG


ESB > TT > ROTK > ANH > FOTR > ROTJ

A Jewish cultural icon, I guess this is what you meant.

Lord of the Rings is heavily influenced from European mythology, it isn't a simple fiction movie, but it is deeply rooted in the White culture. If you haven't read the books then I don't expect you to have a reliable opinion.

>Better lore: LOTR
This is a no brainer. You cant name another work of fiction that even comes close

>Better characters: LOTR

>Better plot: SW

>Better writing: LOTR

>Better music: LOTR
I can listen to any lotr piece, they're all fucking astounding. There's only one or two SW scores that are on that level.

>Better directing: LOTR

>Worse prequels: SW

>Better memes: SW
SHEEV almost reached bane levels desu

>fellowship the worst lotr movie
>fellowship only better than rotj

What the fuck is wrong with you son? Do you not like to be /comfy/? FOTR is literally the comfiest movie in existence