Now that the dust has settled, which one was worse?

Now that the dust has settled, which one was worse?

AotC was absolutely retarded and has the shitty romance scenes. TPM has Liam Neeson

Attack of the Clones is the worst Star Wars movie.

Clones just feels "off" from start to finish.

aotc, definitely.

Phantom Menace visuals aged way better than AotC

Each one had major flaws but they all complimented the grand Star Wars story. Episode 7 basically made every film before it completely meaningless as it rebooted episode 4 except on a grander scale.

But in all honesty everyone knows it goes 5 > 4 > 6 > 3 > Rogue One > 1 > 2 > Christmas special > 7

This one

The Phantom menace is the worst starfox movies by far

Attack by far

Clones.

Phantom was a really comfy self contained story actually. Remove Gungans and it's pretty decent.

Phantom Menace is boring. Clones is just hard to watch.

TPM doesn't properly establish many storytelling elements.
AoTC does establish those elements, but they're all bad.

Phantom Menace.
Attack of the Clones at least gave us Mullet Kenobi vs Jango.

>TPM has Liam Neeson

AotC had Christopher Lee.

This's the first fucking ranking ive ever scene on here that I actually agree with

Lee was wasted

Qui Gon actually did stuff

True, episode III was even worse for Lee.

TPM was irrelevant. Everybody we meet is reintroduced in the next film and none of the plot lines need to be seen. It even ruins the Palpatine reveal.

Watch the movies in this order

Rogue One - 4 - 5 - 2 - 3 - 6. Then throw Phantom menace and Force awakens in the trash.

>Answers a question no one asked
What did he mean by this

Plus Pod Racing and the Maul duel.

This, the tone just feels strange. Kind of like a Sci-Fi original movie with Star Wars characters. At least PM is fun, AOTC is just boring.

SHEEV?

Plus Jar Jar

Good question. They're both bad, for different reasons. It's actually kind of interesting how Lucas managed to flub each of the Prequels in different ways, but he did.

TPM is almost a competent movie, in some respects. Its story is reasonably coherent, most of its performances are solid. Its main problems are that it's extremely childish and too self-contained. Unlike ANH, he *knew* he was making more, but he wrapped it off neatly with a bow anyhow, forcing the real "start" of the story to be in the next film.

AotC is just an absolute trainwreck. It's hard to fully describe how much of an abortion of narrative that movie is from start to finish.

For good measure, RotS isn't *that* much better than AotC, but enough so that it feels like it's better than it actually is in comparison.