This is the best Metallica album, and it's not even close

this is the best Metallica album, and it's not even close.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=lmFgeFh2nlw
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

That's not No Life Til Leather

That's not Killing 'Em All Is My Business... But Who's Buying?

Heh... not a high bar to reach... heheh...

aren't those just Kill Em All demos? Is it worth getting if I already love Kill Em All?

1. Kill Em All
2. Ride the Lightning
3. Master of Puppets
4. Black Album
5. ...And Justice for All

This is objective. /thread

black album isn't good.

/thread

Neither is ...And Justice for All

it's a 9.6/10 album

Best album is the one Mustaine wrote

Blasphemy.

10/10*

changed my mind.

(Nice dubs)
Well, the songs on there did end up on Kill 'em All, but Dave Mustaine is playing guitar, and not Kirk Hammett. Also, Whiplash hadn't been written yet, and Four Horsemen has different lyrics and is called Mechanix, which Dave took with him after getting kicked out of the band. It's one of the main reasons why Dave and Metallica have been feuding all these years.

AJFA might be in my top 3, maybe even number 1 if it weren't for the SHIT production and mixing. they really did jason dirty on this shit.
i do totally understand why it'd be someone's favorite though
my list is as follows(top 5, best to less good but still good)
RTL
MOP
KEA
AJFA
black

hmm, sounds like some super contrarian bullshit to call that their best release, but I'll check it out. hearing mustaine on a metallica release will be rad.

hot take: Master of Puppets is the worst out of their first 4 albums.

agreed, idk why but feels like the least relistenable album to me, much rather play the other 3 classic albums over MoP

whatever, i’ll take the bait.
why is MOP their worst of the tetralogy? great vocals from james, lars and kirk’s peak, cliff’s second best bass work on a metallica album. if anything, it’s probably the best out of that four.

kea > rtl > mop > ajfa > black > death magnetic > hardwired > load > st anger > reload

(you) are wrong

The title track is the best.

AJFA is objectively their best album one of the greatest metal albums of all time, RTL is second, anyone who thinks master of puppets is their best is full retard

Almost every thread on Sup Forums is full of super contrarian bullshit.

What's your point?

Yup

This is the correct opinion.

If you inderstand music you’d understand just how fucking awful AJFA’s production is, and specifically the mixing. It sounds like guitars and vocals but not really finished songs.

>not realising it really is

Everyone realises it eventually.

It's actually like this
>Kill em all>Ride The Lightning>Who cares lol they ran out of Mustaine riffs

It is really close

It COULD be their best it honestly is their most interesting but damn does it sound like shit. Fuck Lars.

this desu

the best Metallica songs were written by mustaine, period
that's why Megadeth will always outclass Metallica in every way, musically

lol worst production of any metal album

>listening to Metallica unironically

No Life Til Leather = KEA >RTL
The rest are full of bloat and poor songwriting.

>not realizing KTA, RTL, MOP, AJFA and even the black album are among the best metal albums of all time
everything else they've done is garbage

t. proge nerd

why does the kick drum sound so fucking weird

1. Black Album
2. ...And Justice For All
3. Ride the Lightning
4. Master of Puppets
5. Kill 'Em All
6. Death Magnetic

because Lars is a fucking hack

Awful.
1. Master of Puppets
2. Ride the Lightning
3. ...And Justice for All
4. Kill Em All

Black Album isn't even worth mentioning.

This thread inspired me to put on some Megadeth.

close, but
RtL
MoP
KEA
black
...AJFA
is correct

this
youtube.com/watch?v=lmFgeFh2nlw