thoughts on garbage / shirley manson?
Thoughts on garbage / shirley manson?
Jose Sanchez
Adrian Collins
would rather listen to curve
Julian Rogers
they're garbage xD please upvote
James Sanders
why not both? it's not like there's a deluge of bands like them.
Carter Lewis
Top tier 90s fapping.
Jaxson Baker
rank their albums
Ryder Collins
Strange Little Birds < Not Your Kind of People < Beautiful Garbage < Bleed Like Me < s/t < Version 2.0
Jace Diaz
slb last? imo it's better than bg.
Nathaniel Murphy
I thought it was pretty much garbage, lol.
Aiden Hernandez
her fretting hand position is atrocious, carpal tunnel on its way.
Liam Lopez
she played guitar just for one song (my lover's box, i think).
Asher Taylor
I prefer their self titled to 2.0, but other than that your list is practically perfect. Strange Little Birds was terrible.
Brandon Ortiz
I saw Garbage years ago in Los Angeles. The band were autographing things after the show, so I waited in line. They all talked amongst themselves as they absentmindedly signed autographs. When I got to Shirley Manson, I said, “Hey, that was a great show!” She responded, “I signed your shit, now fuck off!"
Asher Howard
That doesn't sound surprising. I used to follow her on social media, she went off the deep end a while back.
Jaxson Diaz
Curve were fantastic.
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
That band could have been extremely popular. They had everything, the sound, the presence, the right connections, everything. I have no idea why it didn't happen.
Luis Ross
they aren't good tbqh. curve was superior
Jacob Ramirez
As for Garbage, they were okay. Highly listenable radio pop, enjoyable in a shallow way.
That said, someone posted this in a thread on here a few days ago and it seriously rules.
Hudson King
How are their live shows? I'm thinking of seeing them in London later this year but unsure if it's worth the £45 asking price.
Gavin Morales
They just weren't accessible enough. Garbage had a much poppier sound which appealed to the mainstream.
Noah Jones
They didn't age so well but they are still enjoyable.
William Powell
They weren't accessible enough to compete with Madonna or Oasis or whoever, but they could have been a massive band in the alternative rock landscape at least. They would have fit in perfectly between the likes of Nine Inch Nails, Jane's Addiction, The Cure etc.
Whoever was in charge of promoting Curve fucked up bad.
Juan Sanders
this. I spilled many loads over her tiny tits and hard nipples.
Brody Gonzalez
You got it wrong. There is no need to "promote better". You don't have to make their music more accessible to "compete". It*s fucking music man, not a competition.
Grayson Ortiz
Nine Inch Nails, Jane's Addiction, and The Cure are all still more accessible. I think Curve suffered a lot by using 'shoegaze production'. A lot of the vocals are quite buried in the mix.
Luis Carter
>I think Curve suffered a lot by using 'shoegaze production'. A lot of the vocals are quite buried in the mix.
That makes sense, actually.
Ethan Bennett
My favorite band growing up and Shirley was my top waifu. I still listen to them from time to time purely for nostalgic reasons.
Blake Jenkins
Curve were too harsh and industrial-ish to mainstream.
Nicholas Davis
This is a Curve thread now.
Samuel Thompson
Besides the vocals I don't hear any significant similarities between Garbage and Curve.
William Anderson
They where the biggest band in the whole "shoegaze" scene by far at the time and got a shitload of international copycats.
Check out this shit from Argentina, they where the hip couple of the 90s (she was a supermodel and he was the drummer for the biggest latin american band ever), it got a lot of airplay at the time.
youtu.be
Garbage are good but they where literally created to succeed in the American market, they never hid that. s/t has some gr8 tracks
Jaxon Turner
this