What would you rate it Sup Forums?

What would you rate it Sup Forums?

3/10

cant decide if its a 6/10, 8/10 or an 10/10. im too indecisive, its why i would never have a rym account

original 9/10

2018 5/10

I don't rate music

You know that you can catalog music on RYM without rating it

Decent to strong 8.

honestly about 6/10

*tips*

6
the 2018 version is superior and if you disagree it's because of nostalgia
I give the remake 8.5-9

i'm not really a fan of beach life in death or cute thing tbqh lads. but the rest of the songs are at least good, and it has some brilliant ones. im gonna settle on a strong 7 to light 8

BODYS IS THE JAM OF A LIFETIME

it's very good. a banquet of melodies

8/10 on the scaruffi scale

agree

>i'm not really a fan of beach life in death or cute thing

the state of you

8/10

6/10 for the original and 9/10 for the re recording

IS IT THE CHORUS YET?

something that willl toledo is highly gifted at actually is creating such a variety of melody in a single song. or at least that's how it sounds ?? ive never really heard anything like it before

It happened a lot back in the golden years of indie, not in the last 10 years though

yeah well that's just like your opinion man

i guess, but even then he does it to an impressive extent

So descend into cliche
If you've found your holy grail
I could fill back in that grave
I could hammer in that nail
I could give you what you want
I could give you what you deserve
I could sing another song
I could watch that hammer swerve

And when the mirror breaks
I wouldn't miss it for the world
Call it blackstar, call it painstar
The same thing happens when you touch it
Did they tell you what happens when you touch it?
Let me tell you what happens when you touch it...

billis/10

I cry to this

love Famous Prophets (Stars)
hate beach life in death
love sober to death
hate cute thing

simple as

that's the cover for the original which is 10/10

the new one is 9/10

don't know of anything about the new version, but Sober to Death is by far better than anything else on the album

>when the horns come in on famous prophets

obvious contrarians are obvious

0/10 cringy high school tier vomit

xiu xiu for underage

twin fantasy is shit

7/10 for original
5.5/10 for remaster

Fockoff melon

8/10 for original 9/10 for 2018
Overall alot of the songs were improved, however the monologues do suck alot more than the original.

Original is 9/10
2018 is 8/10