Fellas, Nirvana or The Smashing Pumpkins????

Fellas, Nirvana or The Smashing Pumpkins????

Smashing Pumpkins, though it's very close.

tough call for sure, but Nirvana was more consistent and wrote better melodies. I guess Smashing Pumpkins were better with mood and technical effects

Smashing Pumpkins for sure.

Pumpkins, obviously

pumpkins have a bigger catalog. Nirvana only released a hand full of albums but they are all great. I prefer Nirvana but I spend more time listening to pumpkins

They are equal because they both only have one good song

I prefer The Smashing Pumpkins, but it's pretty close.

The chad redpilled alt-rock front man vs. the virgin liberal alt-rock singer

Nirvana = Reddit
Smashing Pumpkins = Sup Forums

Nirvana never wrote anything as good as Siamese Dream

I ain't heard of no Fellas, so I'm going with Pumpkins over Nirvana

Yeah but that's their best album. The three major Nirvana albums are as good or better than every other pumpkins album

I think Kurt was more sincere in some ways, wrote probably better songs overall, but Smashing Pumpkins had the melodies and technical skill in playing the music, so they explored more territories.
Billy is also still alive, and In Utero was the last thing Kurt did basically and Billy continued. Can we really judge what?
What would have Kurt brought the table if he was still alive right along with Billy. It would have been interesting.

Nirvana - All Killer No Filler

Smashing Pumpkins - Occasional great songs trapped under a deluge of shit songs and stupid gimmicks

Pumpkins, nirvana is trash

As far as their first 3 albums go:

Mellon Collie > Nevermind > Siamese Dream > In Utero > Bleach > Gish

My favorite song out of all of these albums though, Rhinoceros, is off of Gish.

Nirvana is dated as fuck, Smashing Pumpkins is still good

I like both, but The Smashing Pumpkins are way better

>Nevermind > Siamese Dream

I'd like to put a "=" between them, but I think that's a cop out. I like Territorial Pissings more than anything on Siamese Dream.

You can't really consider it, but the last song Kurt recorded, You Know You're Right, is also the best Nirvana song

>Bleach > Gish
Bleach is fucking garbage

smashing pumpkins with kurts vocals instead of nasally fuck billy

his voice kills pumpkins just like growling kills technical death metal

well my mind has been made up

siamese dream > in utero > mellon collie / nevermind > bleach > gish