Song I am working on (needs more verses), would be very keen to hear feedback on lyrics and chord progression. Asthma bad today so voice not on top form unfortunately.
You should try to do some different types of chord phrasing alongside the progression you have. try sustained notes or try to make it not so repetitive.
>so repetitive Fuck, that’s definitely not what I was going for. 7 chords is quite a lot for one of my own songs, although I have only been playing guitar for eight months.
somebody keep the thread up for the next 30 minutes or so. gonna record something a bit more involved.
William Wright
yeah i can tell there's a good use of a lot of chords in it, however the progression goes by so fast that it sounds like the chord changes are frantic. sometimes less is more, family
vocaroo.com/i/s1XBZfzzxChn my original "Walk Around" that I've posted here a few times before. i wrote it for some girl I was dating back towards the end of 2017. im trying to appeal to that tumblr-girl demographic lmao
I quite like it, really nice lyrics. Descriptive and communicative without being obvious. I don't have as much of an issue with the chords themselves as the other fella but I think it'd benefit with a bit of a stronger vocal melody. I think that's what's contributing to it sounding kinda "samey" rather than the chords themselves. >tfw no music gf But yeah this is comfy little album. Obviously y'all aren't going for technical perfection or anything so I won't critique it on those terms, it's nice for what it is. r Yeah I think you're definitely hitting that target demo right on the mark. Really like that dirty guitar tone and you have that rough around the edges vocal quality that's always really cool. Not really my go to kinda music but it's definitely some good shit.
Jackson Stewart
Nice work, not sure I agree that you need more verses though. Perhaps a middle 8 or just an instrumental section. I can hear the Dylan influence.
I do agree with though. Due to the strumming pattern it does get a bit repetitive. Maybe try finger picking for the verses? Up to you. Considering you've only been playing for 8 months, the fact that you've got an actual song finished is very impressive. When I was 8 months in I was still pleased with playing a riff over and over again.
I like it. I'm getting mid-noughties alt-rock feels from it. Sounds like it needs a full band behind it. Really like the ending. Excellent!
The main progression is pretty cool but it repeats so often that by the end it gets kinda grating.
Owen Wright
Fair enough. I still like it though, normally I play it in a higher key so the vocals take a bit more precedence so it's probably not typically as grating. Was really just kinda trying to find something to add to it with my electric, though I don't think that really worked either but oh well.
Justin Nguyen
Thanks for both your comments on my piece (OP). Glad you both like the lyrics. I think my voice lets it down a bit too listening back, as I say my asthma was bad this afternoon so I was out of breath at the end of each line. Will continue to experiment with the style of the song to command more attention from the listener.
I really like this. Guitar reminds me a bit of late Bert Jansch, but you have a much better voice than him. I like the electric guitar riff too.
I like this but I think you have gone a little too spartan on the guitar melody at the start, could use a bit more going on.
Eli Green
clyp.it/5dd5fuyn Demo of a song, im not sure whether to keep the oo's and ah's or make them bass and synth lines
I like the oos and aahs. I think they work better than a bass or synth would. In fact I wouldn't add much to it at all: your percussive kind of playing hints at everything that needs to be there, and the lyrics are great in a true stream of consciousness kind of way. For that reason I'd say maybe sing them a little softer - they stand on their own pretty well, so maybe try and work your voice more around the melody than the words? It's a great song, man.
I don't know what language this is, but it's got a hell of a groove to it. Your playing is spot on. Gets a little more intense than it needs to be toward the end, though - I get where you're going with it, but the groove you've got and the melody don't really know if they're rock or if they're more laid back, if that makes sense. They would work great either way, but not both.
Your vocals are on point, man. Kind of reminds me of Dashboard's stuff. It really doesn't feel like nine minutes at all, weirdly enough. Well done.
Jonathan Adams
Not bad. The oo aas were a bit odd at first but grew on me the more I listened.
OP again with another song of mine. I've worked hard to address some of the criticisms of my last song, would be keen to know if this is an improvement.
I love the chord progression. Certainly doesn't show that you haven't been keeping up the piano lately. Your voice is very smooth too but you maybe go a little too high for your vocal range at a few points. But otherwise great, quite Neil Young like.
Hatchet - Darkening Skies youtube.com/watch?v=5JiTqY3szJ8 good acoustic for the first bit, little bit more electric and drum near the end, but still good Hatchet - Revelations of Good and Evil youtube.com/watch?v=_U9BJMrBdYg fantastic the whole way through, really nice sound, well played Hatchet - Where Time Cannot Exist youtube.com/watch?v=iIjdJbAUJRk really good acoustics for the first half or so, the decent into more traditional metal near then end isnt great but overall its still a good song
Nolan Johnson
What in the fuck are you on about.
Aiden Taylor
its acoustic song, and theyre mostly acoustic, why are you mad?