*shoves Roger away*
*saves Pink Floyd's reputation*
*shoves Roger away*
*saves Pink Floyd's reputation*
Because A Momentary Lapse of Reason proved how great Pink Floyd could be without Roger, huh?
How come this board hates The Final Cut so much
It's a really good album with some really good heart touching lyrics. With some god-tier moments
>HOLD ON TO THE DREAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAM
It was the last great album from the band, after that, the shit went downhill.
t. Roger
if you're referring to nowadays, sure, Gilmour is the only one keeping the flame alive tbqh.
But Roger did some alright stuff in the 80's, like the Final Cut
Sup Forums likes The Final Cut though
Pink Who? You mean Roger Waters And His Magic Band?
>muh daddy issues the album
OI
GET YOUR FILTHY HANDS OFF MY DESERT
>Gilmour sings better than Waters nowadays
How the mighty have fallen.
Roger Waters has written only two songs which reference his father being dead throughout his entire discography. One being on The Wall, that being Another Brick In The Wall, and another appearing on The Final Cut's special edition "When The Tigers Broke Free", which was supposed to be on The Wall anyway.
So, what's your point?
what
he always did
Waters was never a good signer, he was the screamer.
>Through the fish-eyed lens of tear stained eyes
That song fucking hurts.
>I can barely define the shape of this moment in time
>And if I show you my dark side
Will you still hold me tonight?
And if I open my heart to you
And show you my weak side
What would you do?
I Saw Roger on his last Australian tour and it was the best live performance I have ever seen.
>and far from flying high in clear blue skies
I hope Gilmour does another concert soon, I saw the stuff he did in Pompeii and it is glorious.
I think it reached the top 3 in the UK Charts in 2017.
WOULD YOU SELL YOUR STORY TO ROLLING STONE? WOULD YOU TAKE THE CHILDREN AWAY? AND LEAVE ME ALONE! AND SMILE IN REASSURANCE AS YOU WHISPER DOWN THE PHONE!
would you send me packing?.....
OR WILL YOU TAKE ME HOME?
IF YOU DIDN'T CARE
>not posting the true voice of Pink
Except he completely butchers "In The Flesh"
SO YAH
THOUGHT YA
like to go to the SHOUH
I'm spiraling down to the hole in the ground where I hide
There's also The Fletcher Memorial Home but I think the song is mostly about gassing jews
Its just age, Rogers is what? 71?
Also butchers "Stop" somehow.
When I first saw the movie I was afraid they would make significant changes like these to the songs, luckilly it was only these moments, still pretty awful though.
Geldof was alright, but he acted more than he sang. Then again it was a movie.
His acting was great. I'll give him that.
>an old man butchering the very songs he sung well 30 years ago.
I FUCKING WISH ONE OF THEM WOULD INVITE THE OTHER AND DO A SONG TOGETHER
JUST A FINAL ONE
I DONT WANT TO SEE EITHER OF THEM DYING HATING THE OTHER ONE
the last song they did well together was Comfortably Numb
You better pray
that was the last song they did together period.
I just don't get how Roger can say that he doesn't feel any desire to play with Gilmour again because "it's retreading old ground and it's not new". Just say you dont like him. Roger's last album was fucking shit and desperately screams for Gilmour's mellow influence and playing.
Also in some Q&A session he did with Nick Mason where Floyd fans submitted questions he just dodged every Gilmour-related question. He's still ass pained after 50 years.
I love Amused To Death, Radio KAOS and The Pros & Cons of Hitch Hiking but fuck, I wish he'd get his shit together before he died.
please post funny pictures of david gilmour
David Gilmour on a reunion with Roger Waters, "Not gonna happen."
E|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
B|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
G|--15b17---------------------------------------------------------|
D|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
A|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
E|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
David Gil "less", as we call him in the industry, is nothing but a pretty face used to sell Stratocasters. Roger played all the guitar solos in the studio and wrote 100 percent of the music by himself, he was the Billy Corgan of music
Problem?
the album is literally
> do whatever you want to do
> but you're not allowed to join the army or defend yourself
like why even bother writing political songs when you haven't got your own politics thought out yet
>bends 15th fret for 50 years
>always sounds different
how does he do it?
9/10 or retard
Roger Waters is an 80 year old man and he still cries about his fucking dad dying. he never even KNEW his dad, his dad died when he was a baby. get the fuck over it
>mfw when nobody cares about Syd
he was shit so that's no surprise