So who's better?

So who's better?

Other urls found in this thread:

pollmill.com/f/what-is-the-size-of-biyou-bancho-silk-s-nipple-urx9j39/answers/new.html
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tee_Martin
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

Brady in all facets of life.

Carson Wentz

not the system babby

But Peyton has more Yards, Yards per Attempt, TDs and completion %

Stats are for losers.

Based Brady still winning owls while Peyton is retired shilling Papa Johns.

Dak Prescott

manning in his prime was cyborg-esque. but brady has the clutch gene.

Both only have as many superbowls thanks to the real goat Vinatieri.

I still lean towards brady

The one on the cover of the GOAT edition.

But Brady won his last two bowls without him

this.

Brady is top of every stat sheet, records, wins, plus most Super Bowl wins, MVP, pro bowl

Dumb question

And Brady has every post-season stat if you want to get technical. Oh and 5 rings.

No her not you stupid fuck. Her behind of Peyton and as well as Favre in a lot of stats.

Peyton was technically really talented, but he just didn't 'get' the game in the same way. Plus his talent was in line with expectations as the #1 pick, while Brady came out of nowhere.

It's like Elway vs. Marino out of the same draft class - Marino put up gaudy numbers, but Elway was a better student of the game and got to leave it with rings.

>*Brady

Another one; Which season was better: New England 2007 or Denver 2013?

Name them

The only stat I can think of is the number of starting games which he's about to break this season

Brady until his and the Pats next scandal is revealed.

God I fucking miss Brady v. Manning games on Sup Forums.This board peaked in 2009 with "Good Game Kid".

>So what makes you think you have what it takes to be a New England Patriot?

only because he played in a dome for most of his career

Brady has better dome stats in the few games he played in them than Peyton

TD PASSES
PASSING YARDS
300 YARD GAMES
400 YARD GAMES
COMPLETIONS
ATTEMTPS

He's literally so close to breaking all of those he will do it within 1-2 years, and his contract is for 3

Sorry boyo

Doesn't Peyton have a winning record against the Patriots in playoff games? lol

Is there really a difference in playing in a dome

>he has all the records
>her close to having

Patriot fans really are retards.

well lets judge it like this
who has a losing record against Cam Newton?
that's right ONLY TOM BRADY
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

he also didn't need to have a plate screwed into his spine to keep it from pinching his nerves.

Messi

>H2H record for comparing QBs

It's the source of all their butthurt.

The one that didn't cheat and proved he wasn't a system baby by taking 2 different teams to the Superb Owl and winning.

>implying he took the Broncos to 50
the defense carried that team that season

The fucking Broncos defense literally dragged Peyton's corpse to that Owl win.

>HGH
>didn't cheat
Deion said it best "if you're not cheating you're not TRYING" motherfucker

daily reminder that Peyton went one and done with the same team that Tebow won a playoff game with the year before

Deion was a ball-hawking faggot who couldn't tackle to save his life.

Daily reminder Brady lost more games the next season with the same Patriots team that Matt Cassel led.

>Physical gifts and talent
Peyton, literally bred to be a top tier QB

>Intangibles, winning quality, career achievements
Brady by a country mile

They had their own strengths. In the eyes of the general populace however, the career achievements always carry the greatest weight.

>Same team
>Vice President of Player Personnel Scott Pioli, who had been head coach Bill Belichick's personnel director since 2000, departed to become the general manager of the Kansas City Chiefs, while offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels was named head coach of the Denver Broncos. Quarterback Matt Cassel, who led the team to 11 wins in 2008 after starter Tom Brady was injured, was traded to the Chiefs along with veteran linebacker Mike Vrabel in March. Defensive starters Tedy Bruschi and Rodney Harrison both retired, while All-Pro defensive end Richard Seymour was traded to the Oakland Raiders for a first round pick in the 2011 NFL Draft days before the start of the regular season.
Not to mention that Moss was basically washed up

Pats had D...Pats

Daily reminder that teams win owls.. peyton better overall

Not true, Payton still carried the Broncos to victory since the alternative was a failure like Oswiler who was so shit, they needed Payton to come in to orchestrate a clutch, come back victory for them.

>Superbowl 50: 13/23, 0TD, 1 INT, 56 passer rating

So he's tougher than Manning too?

You just know that Brady is going to get caught using PEDs.

>b-but muh TB12 Method!!

Peyton Manning is good at facesitting

>Manning sexually assaulted a woman
Wew boy
His legacy is totally not getting a #metoo in a couple years

You realize some meme like Stafford will probably end his career with a few of those records to his name, right?

Tom Brady is the only quarterback to ever have a WINNING record after his team was trailing in the 4th quarter.

>Meme
Stafford is elite

>Elite

This word gets thrown around nowadays with reckless abandon.

Nothing about Stafford is elite other than his contract.

pollmill.com/f/what-is-the-size-of-biyou-bancho-silk-s-nipple-urx9j39/answers/new.html

Who's better, Montana or Marino?
This is essentially the same question.

Not quite an accurate analogy. Marino was very highly rated in the draft but he fell because of perceived character issues.

You never expect a 6th round draft pick to be a franchise QB never mind a Hall of Fame QB who is arguably the greatest quarterback ever.

Manning was technically excellent coming out of college but what he lacked throughout his entire career is an innate instinct that all the greatest QBs have.

It is that innate instinct that allows the truly great QBs to improvise on broken plays and consistently get the ball to a teammate for a big play. Bill Walsh called it an "intuition" that some players have.

Manning did not have that special intuition that better QBs than he have in spades.

not even close and I am dolphins fan. marino didnt do winning like peyton did. peyton won multiple rings.

yes, the air pressure is different.

Peyton was shit in the postseason.

no wind and the air is hot from everyone breathing

The one that is still playing is probably better right now.

Tom Brady
2× NFL MVP (2007, 2010)
2× First-team All-Pro (2007, 2010)
2× Second-team All-Pro (2005, 2016)

Peyton Manning
5× NFL MVP (2003, 2004, 2008, 2009, 2013)
7× First-team All-Pro (2003–2005, 2008, 2009, 2012, 2013)
3× Second-team All-Pro (1999, 2000, 2006)

>muh rings
Fuck off. It's a team sport. Peyton was better. Deal with it.

The one that didn't go one and done in the playoffs a dozen times

The one that didn’t choke in the post season. That’s right, Eli.

The statistical differences between them are not big enough to override the fact that Brady has accomplished an overwhelming amount more, and displayed more poise in do or die situations - not to short change Peyton, because he also has a great 4th quarter comeback record and all that, but it's not to the level of the GOAT

>muh accomplishments don't matter

If you think that Peyton would've beaten Seattle in the 2014 Owl, or that he would've been able to complete that comeback against Atlanta last year, you're foolish. Put prime Peyton on the Pats in both of those games and they fail both times.

Eli barely makes it to the post season enough to choke. Also you didn't watch the Green Bay game last season?

>If you're not cheating you ain't trying

Eli.

Kys

Head to head in the playoffs Peyton has 3 wins over Brady to Brady's 2 over Peyton. Why does this never get mentioned when discussing the two of them?

>implying I wasn’t being ironic
The Brady vs Peyton debate ended last February, if not in 2015.

have you adjusted Peyton's stats per-salary-dollar? The reason the Colts had crappy defenses was Pey-Pey hogging the salary cap for himself

How about the one that didn't fall ass backwards into both of his rings

Because H2H is retarded for comparing people that don't actually play each other. The only time H2H should ever be mentioned in sports is one on one sports like Tennis. Brady and Manning aren't even on the field at the same time.

Well that would be difficult for every year but if we look at SB winning years for Peyton in Indiana
2006 Salary Cap = 102M
2006 Peyton Salary = 10M
That equals 9.8% of the salary cap
Now lets look at Tom Brady's win in 2014
2014 Salary Cap = 133M
2006 Brady Salary = 14.8M
That equals 11% of the salary cap
Manning was also only the second highest earner

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tee_Martin

Peyton was really talented in hanging his receivers out to dry, getting them destroyed.

doesn't Peyton have the record for first-round playoff losses?

rare