Name a flaw

Name a flaw

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=_r3ArjXUMrI
youtube.com/watch?v=ALHJI0Zqweo&ab_channel=RantandBollox
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

It's a little long. Could have done with a cut of around 20-40 minutes.

They didn't show charles killing the xmen

No inbred hillbilly hulk children

Lack of full penetration

More tits, more usage of the word fuck, even more gore, Logan getting drunker, make the movie even more depressing somehow, and more tits.

It's still an amazing movie though.

He's not naked.

>Logan doesn't kill any of the big bads

source material meant for kids geared towards manchildren of reddit. sad!

>every bit of suffering is brought on by imaginary x-men problems rather than real character flaws
>albino is a plot device
>villain takes a break for an entire act while two more less memorable ones takes his place
>spic loli sucks at acting, especially when she talks
>some nurse can edit an oscar worthy documentary on her phone
>overuse of violence makes it's impact inert and meaningless

He doesn't hang dong

>Charles Xavier has no purpose being in the story
>wrapping up two of the franchise's best characters with a tale that has nothing to do with what they did in prior films
>well meaning minorities terrorized by country yokels
>filling your frame with footage from another film
>ending your film with another film's closing dialogue instead of writing your own
>"look, this is totally a western not capeshit TAKE US SERIOUSLY PLS!!!"

>edit an oscar worthy documentary on her phone
Yeah, sitting in the theater this struck me as odd on the spot. Also,
>Charging a phone and it turns on
>Immediately hits play on a video
It's like you're asking for it to die again. Also resuming playback automatically? Maybe in 2030.

For me, it was the fat black kid. The fuck was he doing there.

>minorities
It's the future. They're not minorities anymore.

Xavier was the moral compass

>movie isn't releasing in japan until fucking JUNE
>only way to watch it is shitty camrip some stupid faggot couldnt even hold still for any amount of time and so bad visual quality and audio quality might as well not even watch it
>if i dont watch this shit quality cam rip im going to have like spoilers you faggots spam every other second ruin the movie for me

I wish Logan and Laura had more bonding time. He really didn't seem to give a shit about her until the last ten minutes of the movie so the impact when she was crying over him felt forced.

i got more of a King Lear vibe from him.

The fans

>Name a flaw

No flashbacks with the other X.men. Even just a couple secs of them being killed at the school would have been a good inclusion.

Logan was directed by the guy who did Knight and Day, the Cameron Diaz and Tom Cruise movie nobody saw except me.
There's a part in Knight and Day where Diaz falls unconscious and wakes up multiple times in a row to get her body from point A to point B.
They did the same thing with Logan from Charles's death to him reaching the kid's camp and I thought that was off-putting.

This, where was the ass?

There isn't one. Actual superhero kino.

They should have used Hurt instead of When The Man Comes Around in the credits.

The girl I went with to watch it thought the movie was terrible and was bored all the way and we didn't hatefuck afterwards

>Hurt instead of When The Man Comes Around

another plebfilter

Cheap looking CGI

Why do people have this awful opinion?

Not being shown was way better. Charles' emotions were more than enough replacement for a fucking flashback.

Do I need to see all the Wolverine films to understand/enjoy this? The last X Men movie I saw was Last Stand

No. You only need to know Wolverine and Xavier. And maybe a little about x-23.

X2 literally leads right into it.

everything looks cheap in a shitty camrip

Second best super hero movie ever (behind Dark Knight) but it still had some big flaws:

>tone was inconsistent. Right after Charles dies we get a slapstick comedy scene of Logan hitting the truck. Then after Logan dies they play The Man Comes Around which to me, while a song about death, is a pretty lively and not so serious tune. So that took me out
>Not enough focus on Logan and Charles' issues. They mention what happened in Westchester but after the hotel scene that plot point t kind of disappears, there isn't any payoff. Also Logan's inner demons are never really resolved. I guess that's the symbolism of him fighting X-24 but I never really felt that

Thats not a camrip. Thats from the red band trailer

You kid but damn those were disappointing tbqh...I mean I read spoilers and wasn't expecting anything crazy but at least flop those tits around a LITTLE.

>I watch movies to be told about things instead of seeing them

uh, huh

I don't think Cash's Hurt really fights the bill. Honestly Reznor's hurt is probably more apt for the credits

They should have left out the shitty Johnny Cash all together

CGI was fine,I didn't notice it once

you kind of need to see the Wolverine but not really

I really fucking loved Logan. To me it is pretty much perfect.

My only problem is I could have done without all the other kids at the end. Maybe just have 1 or 2 who survived. It was quickly approaching the reason all the other X-Men movies suck, too many characters.

was not slapstick comedy though, it was just our pleb brains that couldn't realize he turned sadness into anger and so we laughed because we didn't know how to process it

Ooh ooh OK I thought of a good one maybe.
>No attempt to explain that the DNA of the dead X-Men was used to create the new mutants, which is why there was a Storm, a Iceman, Magneto etc.

the movie is surprisingly self contained. if you know the general gist of the characters from the comics, you are fine.

That would have defeated a main point of the movie.

Mutants survive, but their life is always suffering.

Man, I did. Just got home from the theater and I noticed it a lot when X-2e was doing flips and stuff and whenever Logan would brain somebody. The cgi was definitely weak, no question about it.

Yeah The Man Comes Around felt like a tonal misfire even if I understand. I think playing Hurt from the trailer would've worked just fine. Though maybe they wanted to play something not so depressing when the movie's already depressing enough.

They had a flashback for Westchester and cut it and I'm happy for it. I think it's a lot better unshown. It doesn't "disappear" as a plot point, it's basically the movies whole reason for being. However some of the details were blink and you miss it and it appears many people missed it so they should've had it more clearly stated.

>thinking that killing the badguy is the point of the movie

They suffer because of dipshits like Magneto with their muh darkness and suffering bullshit.

The movie's already depressing enough with Xavier's and Logan's deaths. I think having a new generation of kids survive - in a world that no longer has a place for mutants - is a good mix of happiness mixed with the inevitable despair you know is in store.

I would have liked to hear "The day the world went away" somewhere in this movie. It kept reminding me of it.
Even if it were just the instrumental version;
youtube.com/watch?v=_r3ArjXUMrI

No they suffer because they are mutants. The movie did a great job of showing no matter what people would want to either use or kill them. If mutants were real you bet your ass a world government would try to turn them into human weapons and they would never be allowed to live normal lives.

>I'm a fucking child that needs to be wowed by special effects and unnecessary scenes because I can't be assed to infer anything.
Seriously, what would you want from the flashback? Charles having a seizure and no one being there with medicine to stop him? So literally the casino scene all over again with a different ending.

I can't think of a way to present this flashback without being shit.

I feel this opinion, I am really sad for Nine Inch Nails. Almost wish the remake never happened but not really. Just damn tired of this pleb Redditcore opinion that we should all forget the original version forever and ever because it isn't fit to even suck the new versions dick.

There is still a place for the more industrial and grimdark middle aged addict version and the heartspilling country old man version.

>too disconnected from the X-Men universe. Would have been cool to see some old defeated Sentinal wreckage, or maybe Xavier talking about his time with Eric, or Logan mentioning Jean, etc. It's like they took 3 mutants and moved them to a world where mutants never existed.
>No explanation as to how all the mutants died (the food shit would have prevented mutants from being born, but it couldn't have removed the powers of every mutant)
>going to the black farm family was nuts. Logan pretty much gave them a death sentence, and the black guy from ER knew it when he tried to shoot him

more garbage capeshit that you think is a 10/10 because you only watch other capeshit and garbage flicks

last third of it was fucking terrible

They said they had Caliban round them up and they executed them.

They lived normal lives in the original X-Men trilogy, it wasn't until Magneto channeled his jewish butthurt and attacked the non-mutants and made people concerned. That CIA slut also awakened Apocalypse too.

Logan is different tho. its actually a good capekino movie, most capeshit is garbage but. there is something about Logan which makes it an amazing film.

>too disconnected from the X-Men universe. Would have been cool to see some old defeated Sentinal wreckage, or maybe Xavier talking about his time with Eric, or Logan mentioning Jean, etc. It's like they took 3 mutants and moved them to a world where mutants never existed
This has been brought up to the director but he said he wanted to this movie to be about these 3 characters and not what happens to X character.

We've had like 4 alternate Wolverines in previous movies, and we already have an alternate Wolverine with Laura. X-24 was too much. He should have been an interesting new mutant that is uniquely useful against Logan, or just make the metal hand guy more competent and cut X-24.

As far as editing, I would have liked a little less action scenes and a little more exposition. I love how vague everything was, but I would have liked a little more exposition, just a little, toward the end of the movie. There was so much of Logan brutally shredding people that it lost its impact. The opening scene with the mexicans should have been cut and the scene with X-24 killing the rednecks should have been cut too.

Caliban was great but his death wasn't really satisfying. Logan and Xavier's deaths were very good, but Caliban just dropped a grenade to kill himself and like 1-2 henchmen. I'm on board with the suicide, given him being tortured into tracking people he cares about to be killed, but the method of suicide didn't satisfy me.

Overall it was a 9/10. Best capeshit movie, tied with Days of Future Past. I don't know which is better because they are both so different but great. DoFP would be a 10/10 if it wasn't for JLaw.

>They said they had Caliban round them up and they executed them.

There's no way Caliban could round up millions of mutants around the world. And I don't get why Logan gave Caliban a pass for this.

Fuck me, do you have some kind of disability that prevents you from paying attention to a 2 hour+ movie?

dude, how can you blink and you miss it when CHarles had that dialogue in his bed

>Nurse pays "Logan" 20,000 dollars to transport X-23 to North Dakota, saying that he'll get the remaining $30,000 when he gets there.

>She later confesses [on the video] that the remaining money doesn't exist.

>Later in the movie, it turns out that the extra $30,000 does exist, just so that "Logan" can turn it down to prove he's a great guy

Why would she lie about the money?

You are right about this, first it would have been interesting if there was at least a mutant graveyard somewhere in the story or more of a Jedi feeling to the mutants. Sometimes I also felt like the guys sent to capture them were too careless and should have had nets and other long range non lethal weapons so they couldn't just get blasted into bits by the kids.

no thats the 10k he had left I think? maybe it's a plot hole I will have to see it again

That second wad of cash you're talking about was the first wad of cash. You're just dumb.

It was a rated R children's movie and devoid of any meaning except the most basic of symbolism. Which I guess is only a flaw if you believe it was supposed to be the masterpiece the faggots on this board purport it to be.

>This has been brought up to the director but he said he wanted to this movie to be about these 3 characters and not what happens to X character.

I get that, but after 16 years of movies it just looks like they're avoiding the elephants in the room. It just seemed odd. I watched 2 grandparents die. At the end they talked about the past constantly. Friends, loves, each other, etc. Xavier not mentioning Eric, Mystique, etc,etc (but talking about watching Shane as a kid) was just weird.

You dont think the world governments could execute millions of people if they wanted to?

>DoFP would be a 10/10 if it wasn't for JLaw.
damn it, yes

>Fuck me, do you have some kind of disability that prevents you from paying attention to a 2 hour+ movie?

Be more specific with your argument. Explain what I don't understand.

I almost felt bad for the rednecks, that got a little into white genocide for me. I am not serious so don't get pissed but still, I mean it was gratuitous how much white people died for sure.

You and I have a very different definition of normal. I wouldn't call living in constant fear and the government first trying to round you up and then "cure" you normal.

Unnecessary.

you mean the mumbling that even in theater was difficult to parse out? Sound mixing sucks these days. I understood the point though but I read a lot of people who didn't understand what had happened.

Watch the movie again, and this time don't suck so much dick.

Don't you have presidential things to do?

third world user here that watched it with subtitles, so that wasn't a problem for me

watched the cam version. Was the nudity cut out of it? I didnt see any. What part is it at? It also unfortunately cut out the entire scene after logan injects himself and then goes beast mode on everyone at the end

>You dont think the world governments could execute millions of people if they wanted to?

Governments, sure. But Caliban couldn't have made that much of a dent. And wouldn't this hunt-down have led to a massive mutant/human civil war? And how did the humans win? A team of elite transigen troops couldn't even take out a couple of kids.

>but after 16 years of movies it just looks like they're avoiding the elephants in the room
Fox executives are fucking morons. Ryan Reynold had to practically beg to get his money maker movie made. Wolverine took a 50% pay cut to get this movie made despite us knowing it would be a success prior. They probably didn't want to let this movie reference past events in case Fox wants to make more shitty nu-X men movies and it just aligned with Manigold vision of focusing on the characters so the old x-men were never mentioned.

What a horrible opinion. I kept dreading a scene where they would over explain everything but I was really surprised , pleasantly so

>190 years old
>been in every major war since WWI
>saw his lover die twice, killed her once
>saw all his friends die to sentinels
>go back in time to stop it
>live another 60 years
>all your friends are killed anyway, again
>get adamantium poisoning

Jesus, Logan had a hard life. No wonder he couldn't wait to die.

This: I mean BvS was far more deep than Logan for example and its in the same genre. However, I felt a lot more feelings watching Logan than any DC movie.

My dad said that he didn't cry for Logan because he said he wanted to die and so it didn't effect my dad at all which was a interesting take on it.

Logan was perhaps way too fatalistic and didn't care about living, he could have showed more love to X-23 and could have had a little word of wisdom to her before dying.

>Watch the movie again, and this time don't suck so much dick.

Again, you're just being a vague shitposter. I gave my arguments, and yours is "herr derr watch it again, you don't get it". I'm not going to watch it again. Explain to me what I don't get.

Only nudity is a girl flashes him in his car while he's working, it's brief

It was heavily implied considering X-23 is Wolverine's daughter. Does everything need to be spelled out for you?

That's what surveillance is for.

>I mean BvS was far more deep than Logan for example
You are joking right? Logan touched on real themes like family and emotional support. What the fuck made BvS deep?

It's all literally explained in the movie, and others in this thread have pointed it out to you already.

It showed the shit they were putting in the food/water etc completely neutralized the mutant's powers. From there itd be as simple as rounding them up and executing them, which it seems did occur. I imagine the vast majority of them at this point were at Xavier's school or with Magneto.

Although mutantkind has ended, it's still infinitely better than the Sentinel apocalypse. And let's face it, the movie also demonstrates why (some) mutants are an existential threat to mankind. Though with the scientific research mankind is probably still doomed anyways if we weaponize mutants.

Its super weak man. In the Limo scene with the wedding party, she said "check out these tits driver!" and pulls her dress down but the boobs are either really small or barely pulled down at all.

Damn someone already answered you but I am still posting this lol

at the very beginning? I think its cut out of the cam version. Theres a part where hes driving around some guy in a cowboy hat, then a bunch of guys partying and shouting USA. Then a part little later with a bunch of girls partying, but they just get out of the car and leave

Are you kidding? That was pretty explicit. Even at the end he's like "lol take a sample of Caliban, good tracker high IQ"

>It's all literally explained in the movie, and others in this thread have pointed it out to you already.

You're failing really hard it. I'm too dumb to get it. Please explain it to me. If you can't, go away.

Bvs tried to be deep
fucking hack snyder doesn't know how to make a movie youtube.com/watch?v=ALHJI0Zqweo&ab_channel=RantandBollox