Rings aside, who's the better QB?

Rings aside, who's the better QB?

Brees

Tom Brady, holds a series of regular season records and playoff records, as well as over 50 game winning drives compared to rodgers being 0-35 when losing in the fourth quarter to teams with winning records.

>it's actually 2-35
h-He's c-closing in

Brady won a SB with Brandon LaFell. So Brady.

>game winning drives are not only a stat now but a QB stat
millennials were a mistake.

>rings aside

even without the rings i'd take tom

>muh flashy passes

sorry but brady's a proven closer. 5-3 in SBs including the two biggest SB comebacks of all time

>inb4 18-1/iggles shitposting

>losing to eli twice
>proven closer

>wins more SBs than any QB in literal history

interesting heh

>5 (five)

>superbowls are an indiviual stat
Rmyt

>5 (five)

>owls are an individual stat

Rodgers peak was higher but he is not near that level now. Now he is just regular elite rather than superhuman
Overall Brady wins

>5 (five)

...

(WOOF)

>5 (five)

(Woof)

Even without the rings, Brady has been doing it for much longer and has more MVPS

Rodgers isn't even Top 5 All Time DESU

>5 (five)

(Woof)

>be brady
>be 40
>went 500+ yards in the superbowl
>lost but still have the most rings by any qb
>be FUCKING 40 and playing an elite level
>have to still hear dumbass and moron telling you that some faggot fucker who chokes as much as he sucks dicks is better than you

>5 (five)

1. Marino
2. Brees
3. Peyton
4. Favre
5. Montana
6. Elway
7. Graham
8. Unitas
9. Starr
10. Young
11. Aikman
12. Bradshaw
13. Moon
14. Meredith
15. McNair
16. Kelly
17. Brady
18. Roethlisberger
19. Romo
20. Rodgers

>muh yards
literally doesn't matter when the other guy is getting into the end zone more, BIDF

And how many rings does brady have?
Any how many 40 years old put up stats like brady?
And how many rings that rodger has?

>And how many rings does brady have?
>rings are an individual stat

>Any how many 40 years old put up stats like brady?
>old greedy man outstays his welcome and sabotages the future of his franchise
>lejimmygaroppoloface.jpg

>And how many rings that rodger has?
>rings are an individual stat

Favre's 2009 season with the Vikings he had 33 tds, 7 ints 109 passer rating

Since 1950

1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Staubach
4. P. Manning
5. Unitas
6. Favre
7. Marino
8. Young
9. Brees
10. Elway
11. Starr
12. Roethlisberger
13. Graham
14. Tarkenton
15. Dawson
16. Rodgers
17. Bradshaw
18. Kelly
19. Aikman
20. Warner

>Kurt Warner is the twentieth best QB in the past seventy years
"no"

When Godgers starts getting up to Bradys age I'll decide. Both are GOAT QBs and guaranteed HoF when they retire. Currently Rodgers is a lot like Tarkenton. A ton of talent and can scramble and throw like no other but he doesn't quite have the win record as some of the other QBs in the league when it comes to crunch time yet. Not entirely his fault when the defense he's been playing with for the last 8 years all collectively shit themselves under the reign that was le scheme man.

And unlike Brady it was entirely his fault his team lost in the playoffs. He didn't even make it out of his conference.

what matters is how many times you reached the top of the mountain, not how well you did it

Brees

The goat homo Aaron

>People smash Brady
>Get flagged 15 yards
Jeez I wonder why he's won all those Owls.

Rodgers is better. The Packers are just mediocre as fuck. Belichick would have at least 7 rings if Rodgers was his qb

Also
>11-5 the year Brady's knee was BTFO in the 1st game
>3-1 the year Brady has to serve his suspension
While Rodgers literally has the whole team on his back and it showed last season with a 7-9 season. Rodgers is the better QB; Brady is just a system babby.

Tom is a little too old to be wearing his hair like that, tBh.
The GOAT shouldn't make people cringe.

you're never too old to dress the way you want user

>11-5
The season where they didnt win anything good
>3-1
The same season that brady made the historical comeback at the superbowl and won his 5th ring?

Fucking moron

This. Brees is the best QB in the league. Better than Rogers or Brady.

>winning records aren't really winning records

Brett Favre is better than both of these faggots.

which makes it fuckin disgusting the saints wasted him for so long. could you imagine if he'd played for a team that wasn't mostly fuckin rodeo clowns?

>i rate a bountybabby

>Brett Favre

Not even in the top 10.

Useless outdoors.

>tf
>tp

>Belichick would have at least 7 rings if Rodgers was his qb
this is such stupid bullshit, in every super bowl the pats have played in since 2007 they had the inferior roster and won because of tom bradys play in the clutch, something rodgers sucks at. id love to see rodgers try his meme plays with bradys white manlet wrs

Pretty good list, would move peyton up one though.

with an all star RBs, WRs and in a dome

The defensive group was pretty good too.

the one that didn't get outplayed by a back-up QB in the Super Bowl

They really should have won the owl, but Peterson just couldn't stop fumbling and you knew it was a matter of time before Favre threw a soul crushing pick

...

haha, great pic. Can I save this?

>Romo that low
>Brees and Peyton ahead of Favre Montana and Elway
>Brady that low
>Rapistburger that low
>McNair even on the list

LMAOOO you're a fucking retard

other than rapelisburger i agree but i dont think he can rape his way to the top

>I rate tony "3 good seasons" homo

Yeah but Jimmy Garopollo is leagues better than brett hundley or matt flynn. He went 5-0 on a team that started 1-9

>they really should have won the Owl
Even if thy beat the Saints there’s no guarantee they beat the colts

>

>waaah I’m butthurt my team got close but couldn’t quite reach the super bowl so I’m going to pretend the opponent wasn’t a team that started he year 14-0 and only started losing games when they benched their starters after clinching a 1 seed
The Vikings were probably the third best team in He league that year but the saints and colts were just on another level. Even in the vikes’ best effort all year and one of the saints’ worst, New Orleans still won

Rapisberger

Easy

Fuck your mother

Foles and Wentz are missing

Peyton Manning.

>even without the rings I'd use rings to justify taking tom
Yeah, Tom "Malcolm Butler" Brady did a great job of closing out the Seahawks Super Bowl

Then why are they counted, idiot.