Which one does Sup Forums prefer?
CGI vs practical effects
Brayden Hernandez
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
imdb.com
twitter.com
Easton Gomez
CGI
Matthew Roberts
...
Dominic Bailey
Some Practical effects from the 80s still hold up while CGi from the 2010s look like such a mess
Camden Morales
Practical. CGI always looks like a video game to me.
Xavier Harris
Practical and stop motion are the GOAT
Oliver Sanchez
Nah, you're just being biased due to that you grew up with movies from the 80s. Movies from the 2010s are much better when it comes to effects, scripts and diversity.
Colton Sullivan
Never seen these movies, but the one on the right looks like a real goblin. The left is obviously some dude in make up it's pretty embarrassing
Austin Brown
subtle bait
James Richardson
this
Christian Phillips
That's because video games are made using CGI. You could just as easily say that video games look too much like movies.
Are you retarded?
Angel Price
I think you are meming but starship troopers holds up and honestly looks better than a lot of shit today
Hudson Watson
what if I told you the one on the right is practical effects and the one on the left is just mocapped cgi
Benjamin Hill
lol
Samuel Lopez
>he pretends to think that a character from the new Warcraft trailer is a guy in makeup
Why lie?
Grayson Cooper
It depends on the quality and purpose of either.
Kevin Stewart
Wow, really? So that's why! Thank you for informing me. I had no idea. And yes, mommy tells me I'm special
Eli Rodriguez
Jurassic Park still looks better than anything since, because of the heavy practical dinosaurs. JW looks utterly shit in comparison.
Ethan Morris
Left panel! I tried watching The Hobbit series and it was like watching a cartoon. I'm guessing a handful of people pocketed truckloads of production capital intended for stuntmen,extras and location
Christian Morris
CGI if done right ie guardians of the galaxy 2 is fine
Camden Ortiz
Why is Pirates of the Caribbean the only series that can get it right? This was in fucking 2006
William Richardson
hoo boy
Jace Long
I agree
Logan Bell
If you can notice that it's CGI, then it's shit.
Henry Collins
It doesn't look that good in motion, especially in the second movie
Nolan Scott
It's the same thing with practical effects. You just need a competent art department and money
Easton Roberts
You're nuts
youtube.com
Juan Perry
The reason Azog looks shit is because Jackson only had a few weeks to do it in. The practical suit they DID make for Azog turned out to be shit and not right, so they put it on and CGI'd over it.
People attack The Hobbit films, but I believe that they would have been as good as LOTR had Jackson been on them from Day 1, rather than filling in for G 'All Whites Are Evil Racists' Del Toro. What Jackson pulled off was quite incredible based on the time he had. The first one was fantastic, the second one was OK, the third one was 50 pages of book stretched to 2 hours long and it'd have been shit no matter who had done it.
David Taylor
Good Practical > Good CGI > Bad CGI > Bad Practical.
Brody Turner
A mix of good practical with good cgi > all the things you listed
Noah Peterson
Props from Poundland is all ya need
Jose Price
Don't dis Poundland, lad. That shit is awesome.
Caleb Collins
I watched this doc the other day on the subject, it was amazing wathcing all those people talk with such passion.
Thomas Edwards
Still the high point for cgi character work.