Hey guys, art historian here. Were there any good movies made by communists? Can't seem to think of one

Hey guys, art historian here. Were there any good movies made by communists? Can't seem to think of one.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=TgzrI1okwrQ
youtube.com/watch?v=sYFXv6bDIY8
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rootless_cosmopolitan
youtube.com/watch?v=flEDBnDW4Rg
youtube.com/watch?v=5DXysv-jkiY
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Potempkin

>not real communism

that movie was very critical of communist regime though. i'm talking about pro communism movies not movies made in the communist era (there were tons of great movies made under communist regime)

Can you name ANY good propaganda movie though?

are you implying that all pro communism films are propaganda?

Stalker.
Battleship Potemkin.
The Cranes are Flying.
Solaris.
Moscow Does Not Believe in Tears.

No, it wasn't. The film was ordered, reviewed, and approved by Lenin himself.

yes
by definition

Come and See.

It has it's called Stalinism the Five year plan was a total smash hit.

>Stalker.
not pro communist
>No, it wasn't. The film was ordered, reviewed, and approved by Lenin himself.
doesnt mean it was pro communism
>solaris
lol gtfo retard you are an idiot
anti war =/= pro communism

>art historian
>doesn't know about soviet cinema
Not a very good one are you

>Hey guys, art historian here.
Fuck off, reddit

i said GOOD movies
gottem

>No, it wasn't. The film was ordered, reviewed, and approved by Lenin himself.
Are you sure? I think the movie was released in mid 20s, by that time Lenin was either dead or demented

They forced me to watch this at school when I was little. Don't remember if good of bad. just a lot of shooting

Fall of Berlin dankest movie

youtube.com/watch?v=TgzrI1okwrQ

Real communism is impossible by nature.

Battleship Potemkin.isn't a good film?

All of Kubricks films

Chaplin's films were pretty good

Communism is for teenagers who've never actually had to work on a factory floor for shit wages.

Actually its inevitable by nature. Start with Hegel and then Marxism will make more sense.

Tarkovsky wasn't a gommunist

Shortbus

ad hominem

>very critical of communist regime
Are you literally retarded? The regime they defeat isn't the communist regime, it's the Imperial regime. The good guys are the communists.

communism is for people that hate themselves so much for being losers that they cant stand the sight of other people making something of themselves because it makes them feel even worse

every commie i know is a horrible dark self obsessed piece of shit.

>DUDE lets all do nothing all day and get the same ration of food and shelter xD

>dude literallye veryone is equal i mean u can choose to spend your time the way you want to but you will never have more than what everyone else does LMAO

Communism is rational though. How would you organize a society of machines? Would you really use capitalism? Come on son. Your machines would be in a communist regime.

Except in Communist regimes you either go to work or get slapped on with a social parasite tax and then get randomly bullied by the militsiya

>The good guys are the communists.
hahahahahahahhahahahahahahhahah

The truest kino can only be made free from the confines of the profit-oriented mindset.
it's the logical final stage of economic evolution

What happens when a psychopath decides to manipulate a bunch of followers and take over?

Fascism is kino, senpai. It's also inevitable.

They literally are. Was this not subtle enough for you?

Triumph of the Will

Capitalism and communism are way too similar for my liking. Close the borders and create a socialist state and we'll be good. Avoid invading others and let them see National Socialism is the best way on its own. Don't fall for Jewish lies, folks. They are the invisible dictator for now under your precious ideologies.

That isn't an argument against Marxism itself. It could happen under fascism just the same.

I guess Juche is the answer.

Marxism is a joke for kids who are too privileged to know reality. Go to .gif and watch some gore webms if you're too far away to experience itself. What's "Natural" is survival of the fittest, my boy

The point of fascism is that it's built for reality, and doesn't hide from it like idealist children.

>Capitalism and communism are way too similar

Under National Socialism workers are paid a living wage, though. We don't trat our people like animals. A strong bond and brotherhood, strong families, etc. is essential to a strong state.

Soy Cuba
youtube.com/watch?v=sYFXv6bDIY8

>Stalker.
>Solaris

Highly doubt someone as deeply Christian as Tarkovsky was a Communist.

Nazbol is the future

The current leader of the Russian Communist Party is Christian LMAO

They are. Both result in a wealthy powerful 1 percent and slave labourers. Capitalism at least gives people the illusion of luxury but most systems form the exact same way. As I already mentioned, fascism does not shy away from this fact.

this desu

Fascism blames imaginary things as problems for why they don't succeed. Pretty sure you are trolling though.

literally did nothing wrong

>that pic
Communist is the kino of social political models, and the way to a parnasian society regarding art as the most important activity for man.

Very ironic for a communist to say this. Open your goddamn eyes.

no one cares tarkovsky wasnt a commie you fucking retard

materialism is imaginary?

Russian communist party is currently more economical right than something called Liberal-Democratic party
Russian politics are fucking joke right now

>no Chinese propaganda posted
Surely they've made some

What would you say about libertarianism, I wonder?

>implying fascism isn't anti-capitalist
>implying Jews don't run Hollywood, the news media, and the educational systems
>implying Jews don't encourage destructive Marxist beliefs in the West while running a fascist dictatorship in their own homes.

Fucking sheep.

>Marxist Beliefs

It's called cosmopolitanism retard.

How is it more "economical right"? Please elaborate.

>ITT: people arguing about whether it works or not
The dude just wanted to see if good pro-commie movies exist, why is everyone so damn triggered

I love this shitposting

Libertarianism is okay, but people don't really know what they want and quickly become bored and disorganized. Total freedom is overwhelming and most people don't know what to do with it while also craving some sort of cause to dedicate themselves to. It can be personal, of course, but I can't see a libertarian society maintaining itself well on the global stage. If you become weak, you lose. It's that simple.

Call it whatever you want you bourgeois faggot.

This thread has been seized by Nazbol Gang

You are giving false labels you fucking cretin what you call Marxism is Cosmopolitanism.

op here, this thread is going exactly how i intended it to

Ask BLM what they think about cosmopolitanism is you privileged little ass.

Same as globalism, then. Fucking sheep.

Why would why I care what some damn monkeys in some anarchist group thinks?
You can call a triangle a square but that doesn't make the triangle a fucking square.

Waterloo was filmed with something like 10k Red Army soldiers playing the English and French.

>Socialism in Country
>Globalism

Average yankee education.

So then what do you propose? A homogenized state? If so, you may be a fascist, after all.

>National Socialism
>Not socialism

I'm not American, fag.

They should stay in their own countries and find their own path for success the end.

12 years a slave ((although i hate it))

Well that's exactly what I believe, friend.

I am talking about Stalinism though.

Isn't Stalinism just fascism but worse?

loach maybe? it's a free world hit me quiet hard. also sweet sixteen made me cry for communism all nite long

>2 hours of GEE BILL WAR IS HELL

Stalin did nothing wrong

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rootless_cosmopolitan

You'd prefer living in Stalin's Russia over 12 years in Nazi Germany (minus the war part because I personally think that was a retarded choice by an egomaniac.)

the question wasn't about the movie being pro-communism tho, it was if they were made by commies

I'm sure Stalin and his cronies really hated living in that palace while the rest of the commoners were happy scrounging for shit.

Had Hitler not been a retard and listened to Strasser he should have pursued an alliance with Stalin.
Instead he showed mercy to some Zionist Jew Anglos at Dunkirk what a tool

Come and See, although it's more anti-Nazi than anything. It was originally going to be called "kill Hitler"

Communism was too big a threat to be left alone. He should have initiated alliances with the West. The Communists were (kept) too stupid to properly understand what Hitler stood for.

Stalin and Hitler referred to each other as comrades in the international struggle against capitalism in their propaganda before the war. If it weren't for Hitler's retarded racial ideals an alliance would definetely have been possible.

>implying Stalin wasn't a shifty motherfucker

Would you really trust the guy? That said, though, it was retarded of him to try and take them on alone. I heard actually they were having a fine time with the invasion before they sent the SS who started killing everyone. The peasants were happy to be rid of Stalin before that happened.

>I heard actually they were having a fine time with the invasion before they sent the SS who started killing everyone. The peasants were happy to be rid of Stalin before that happened.
This is true. Ukrainians recieved the nazis as liberators...until they started getting killed for not being german.

>There is a tradition of cosmopolitanism, and if we had time we could study this tradition, which comes to us from, on the one hand, Greek thought with the Stoics, who have a concept of the 'citizen of the world'. You also have St. Paul in the Christian tradition, also a certain call for a citizen of the world as, precisely, a brother. St. Paul says that we are all brothers, that is sons of God, so we are not foreigners, we belong to the world as citizens of the world; and it is this tradition that we could follow up until Kant for instance, in whose concept of cosmopolitanism we find the conditions for hospitality. But in the concept of the cosmopolitical in Kant there are a number of conditions: first of all you should of course welcome the stranger, the foreigner, to the extent that he is a citizen of another country, that you grant him the right to visit and not to stay, and there are a number of other conditions that I can't summarise here quickly, but this concept of the cosmopolitical which is very novel, very worthy of respect (and I think cosmopolitanism is a very good thing), is a very limited concept.

> You also have St. Paul in the Christian tradition, also a certain call for a citizen of the world as, precisely, a brother. St. Paul says that we are all brothers, that is sons of God, so we are not foreigners, we belong to the world as citizens of the world

Lmao christ cucks

Letter Never Sent

This would be nice if they didn't act like white men were the only ones responsible for upholding it.

I thought it was a Joseph Stalin biopic instead it was just capefaggotry.
Fucking false marketing

Damn you guys are petty and rooted in the past. Communism and Fascism are two sides of the exact same coin, and they lead to the exact same place. The organization and centralization of power abetted by altruism is an unstoppable process that's going to rock our species to the core. Technology is going to give us the capacity to completely redefine what an individual is, and what place they might play in a society. Every biological principle you assume is going to be open to negotiation, and only a machine-like system operating on a total war mentality will be the last one standing when everything is said and done.

relevant
youtube.com/watch?v=flEDBnDW4Rg

Kin-dza-dza

How would that be sustainable? I don't see how the worker ants are supposed to become impenetrable cyborgs and still breed without us running out of resources, unless we don't need to eat, that is.

He really liked his parades

youtube.com/watch?v=5DXysv-jkiY

Earth (1930)
Arsenal
Soy Cuba
Strike
Battleship Potemkin

Oh and if you don't think Potemkin is pro communist your an idiot.