Moderation And Regulation of Mods on Sup Forums

Continuation of
#

Hiro wants us to discuss how we want to be moderated, so let's discuss how we want to be moderated. What is wrong with Sup Forums mods and how do we fix it?

Other urls found in this thread:

strawpoll.me/11229277
strawpoll.me/11229277/r
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Since the old thread actually stayed up, I am assuming Hiro actually manned up and told the mods to leave these up for him. Or the mods are playing Mr. Nice Guy

The topic most people want to discuss is if live action adaptations of comics, should they continue to belong in Sup Forums or should they be move to Sup Forums or have their own board.

In this thread we will discuss this subject, here a poll, go and vote.

strawpoll.me/11229277

No literally what's the point anymore. We're just arguing the same shit over and over now and nothing is even happening. It's a lost cause, I can't be arsed bickering more.
I mean, what of the past two threads, we just ignore them now and the points and posts made there?

Already wasted enough time and everyone is too busy bitching about things they don't like to focus on the shit tier moderation Sup Forums is faced with.

1. Get rid of the mods. They're all sjws and care more about their political agendas than they do the rules. I got banned recently for reporting a black nationalist thread on a non-Sup Forums board.

2. Ban all sjw content.

3. KEEP Sup Forums IN Sup Forums REGARDLESS OF POLITICAL ALIGNMENT/POSITION/OPINION.

4. GET RID OF FLAGS AND IDs ON ALL BOARDS.

5. CHANGE /asp/ BACK TO A ALTERNATIVE SPORTS BOARD AND MAKE /pro/ FOR WRESTLING.

6. DELETE /wsg/ IT'S A FUCKING WASTE.

7. ALLOW GEN 7 ON /vr/ AND CHANGE THE NAME OF THE BOARD TO /vc/ FOR "CLASSIC GAMING".

8. Ban complaining about "le e-celebs".

9. No board split on ANY board.

10. NO CUK FAGGOTRY OR INTERRACIAL THREADS ON ANY BOARDS INCLUDING Sup Forums.

11. ALL GAY CONTENT GOES ON /hm/ OR /lgbt/ WITHOUT EXCEPTION. THIS INCLUDES TRAP THREADS AND TRANNIE FAGGOTRY. PORN OR OTHERWISE, DOESN'T MATTER.

12. REMOVE ALL WORD FILTERS.

AND MOST IMPORTANTLY OF ALL

BRING BACK BOARD CULTURE (INCLUDING THINGS LIKE ALLOWING ALL DISCUSSION OF GAMERGATE ON Sup Forums [JUST TO GIVE AN EXAMPLE] AS LONG AS IT STAYS ON TOPIC ABOUT GAMING JOURNALISM AND DOESN'T BECOME A POLITICAL DISCUSSION [WHICH WOULD GO ON Sup Forums INSTEAD]).

what about having a /cape/ board and Sup Forums? would that help?

What I personal believe based on the suggestions so far.

Movie and tv show threads need to be limited to Sup Forums.
Discussion about them is not inherently wrong but threads dedicated to them shouldn't be allowed.
There shouldn't be more than one thread dedicated to a specific show or comic.
Lewd content should be allowed so long as it isn't pornographic, its spoilered and it pertains to the topic of the thread.
Shitposting, such a threads that serve no purpose, must be a bannable offense.
Overall better moderation is needed.

The reason gamergate got kicked the fuck out was because of shits that forced it everywhere.

Live adaptations btfo when?

wow, triggered much?

Removing Sup Forums posting seems to be a pretty popular suggestions. That and doing something about generals comes up a lot.

That would good, but I think it would be better to separate comics and cartoons entirely. I don't pay attention to the cape threads so I'm not sure, but I don't think one specific genre would be enough for a whole board.

hey, capslock is on

...

Send all live-action to Sup Forums.

The opposite of all of these, please.

We also need to stop the bias between Marvel and DC. Marvel gets a free pass on almost everything and DC is treated like shit by the Mods.

We need a superhero board for all facets of that genre. Movies, comics, games, and everything.

No, I want to discuss comics here and creating cape complicates that.

How so?

well thsi cant be more then 3 boards. way I see it

Sup Forums: board to discuss TV and movies that aren't related to Marvel/DC
Sup Forums: Place to discuss cartoons and comics that aren't Marvel/DC
/cape/: Place to discuss anything and everything related to those two

Retard.

>more people voting to move them

PLEASE for the love of GOD dont make me use that fucking cesspool known as Sup Forums

1. Agreed. But we need to start with the boards with the most clear corruption, those being Sup Forums, Sup Forums, /asp/, Sup Forums, Sup Forums, Sup Forums, /tg/, /qst/, /his/, /lit/

This. It's not cape comics that are the problem, it's cape movies and shitty moderation that fucks things up for everyone.

I think they should, but be moved to a new board for superheros in general.

Not voting because people will just use whatever figures are there for their ebin anti-superhero adaption agenda

Its not their thread so why would you include them in the first place unless you're one of them, faggot?

huh?

Sup Forums needs to fuck off but making a new board for capes seems like a bad idea. Marvel/DC comics books should still be posted on Sup Forums I think, just move all of the film stuff to Sup Forums where it belongs. I think a new board would just really split up the userbase unnecessarily.

>removing movie discussion from Sup Forums
>moving all discussion to Sup Forums
>devolving all movie discussion to cuck kino cuck kino cuck kino mcuck dcuck kino kino kino kino snyder kino

Are you crazy?

Boohoo, you'll have to shit in the toilet you're supposed to.

I think it would. It would be better for superhero fans, too. There was a big stink over the Marvel game threads being deleted a while back, as well as the mods putting Gotham threads on an autosage filter.

A cape board would solve all those problems, and it would keep superhero movie threads off Sup Forums.

There are literally no drawbacks.

If cape comics are removed from here this inherently becomes a cartoon board and anyone suggesting /cape/ is a Cartoonfag.

Can the mods figure out whether Korean and Chinese threads go on Sup Forums or Sup Forums already?

>post manhwa thread on Sup Forums
>thread gets deleted
>if it doesn't get deleted in 10 minutes, inevitably some anons pop up and tell you to go to Sup Forums
>go to Sup Forums
>thread gets deleted
>if not then anons will complain and your thread gets deleted later

Seriously. Making /cape/ is a convoluted solution that really only benefits Sup Forums. A person trying to discuss cape comics on /cape/ would be told to go to Sup Forums, and a person trying to discuss cape comics on Sup Forums would be told to go to /cape/. Meanwhile Sup Forums would have an extra board to shitpost on.

No you idiots, how do you define "superhero" or "cape" comics? You'll complicate it all.

Its easy to just think of Marvel or DC, but then you get shit like Hellboy. Is Hellboy a cape comic? Punisher isnt a superhero, does Punisher MAX still count as "superhero"?

Dont. It hurts everyone.

Sup Forums shitposter-kun pls

Allow fur characters being talked here, is fucking bullshit that I can't make threads about the new Start Fox cartoon unless the thread is being made around the time the episodes get released.

I was banned once because on a draw thread I posted a Judy Hopps drawing that someone requested...

Literallt banned just because the mods felt like banning me

How? If you want to talk about superhero comics you go to /cape/. If not, you go to Sup Forums.

This shit ain't hard.

See:

>Allow fur characters being talked here
No.

Sup Forums can be saved if Invisibro gets the boot. He ruined Sup Forums.

2. No. Then you're just silencing people, even though I despise SJWs. Keep them contained on /lgbt/

3. Tricky grounds. Censorship in media and video games should be allowed.

4. Yes. They do nothing

5. Fucking this.

6. It really is

7. Yes.

8. Fuck off

9. Yes. No more fucking useless boards.

10. Yes.

11. Kick the camwhores off /r9k/ and Sup Forums and that'll help

12. No

Where did I say remove cape comics?

This, but add indie superheros too, like Spawn. All superheroes go to /cape/

what? that doesnt make sense.

its still Sup Forums related so it should be discussed here. You idiots are still fine with live action adaptions of cartoons.

I said this last thread, and I'd like to say it again:
There needs to be more consistent moderation. The way the moderation flip-flops from very strict to very lenient is confusing.
It would be best if there was a written set of rules that both users and moderators/janitors can follow. It's confusing when posts that were allowed only the day before get deleted, and it's irritating when things like waifuspam happen and nothing is done.
If there was a clear set of rules that we can all follow, I think it would be very beneficial to everyone. Right now it seems like we're all relying on unwritten rules to gauge what we should and shouldn't post, which leads to instability in moderation.

Honestly we may have to make /jp/ into an Asian Culture board.

But Sup Forums is shit and i dont want to attempt discussion there because its shit, how does that make me a Sup Forums shitposter?

Every time I have visited Sup Forums there are several anime or cartoon threads. What's the point of Sup Forums and Sup Forums if Sup Forums allows that content?

Get rid of everything that isn't comics and cartoons.

Spawn is a superhero. Invincible is about superheroes. Hellboy could go either way and would he fine on either.

It's not like /m/ existing means Gundam can't be on Sup Forums, does it?

We can't have that because we have the most corrupt mods I have ever seen. They refuse to be transparent with us, ban anything they don't like, allow Shitposting whenever they feel like it, actively hate the userbase, and have no respect for Hiro

Because the shit you want to be allowed here is Sup Forums shit.
And Sup Forums shit belongs on Sup Forums.
So you support Sup Forums on Sup Forums.
Which makes you shit.

Cartoonfag pls. There are so many posters that storytime both kinds of comics, plus what Superhero is isn't as simple ofva definition. You just want your caroonshit board, directly ask for it. Don't be a cuck.

Why? Superhero fans rarely overlap with Steven Universe and Loud House fans.

A /cape/ board is better than splitting superhero media. That would be like forcing Pokemon to split between Sup Forums and Sup Forums

Again, I just want to be able to have a thread about a Nick show without a huge magnifying glass on my thread with posts and threads constantly being deleted for no reason.

Also, Sup Forums vs /tumblr/ shit needs to fucking leave, it ruins literally every board.

It's not fucking Sup Forums related you dunce. It's a live-action film. Just because it's got Iron Man in it doesn't make it a fucking comic or cartoon. I can't discuss the GitS movie on Sup Forums, I can't discuss a movie based on a book on /lit/ and I can't discuss a video game based off a film on Sup Forums, so why the fuck would a movie be allowed here? Take all Television & Film shit and put it on the fucking board for Television & Film. Sup Forums is for printed comics/websomics and western animated cartoons. It's a board for a MEDIUM not CONTENT.

>I hate superheroes and want all superhero fans to suffer

What a bitter little faggot you are.

Fuck off! I don't want to talk about comic book movieson Sup Forums, all they do is shitpost about cucks and ''kino'' and how being racist is the norm over there, fuck them and fuck you two assholes for bringing that idea up!

>A /cape/ board is better than splitting superhero media.
No it isn't.
And nobody is talking about splitting superhero media.
Specific media already has its own board, its about enforcing the rules that already exist.

Define exactly what a superhero or what counts as superhero/cape is and then think how broadly that can be applied.

You idiots wouldnt ban Hellboy or Alien/Predator comics despite them hitting many of the checkboxes of being cape comics i bet you.

You seem exactly the kind of person we need to get rid of on Sup Forums.

>all they do is shitpost about cucks and ''kino''

That's all they do HERE.

Punisher is absolutely a superhero. He's in the Marvel Universe.

get rid of these two queerbags

>Iron Man is not Sup Forums related unless is a drawing.

Wow, retard alert!

I wish all the people who want to talk about politics on a video game board could fuck off to 8gag like the rest of those faggots

Anyone talking about "ban sjw" content are just mad about opinions that hurt thier feelings

>It's not like /m/ existing means Gundam can't be on Sup Forums, does it?
Thats EXACTLY what people are suggesting. Thats the problem.

Really?

Punisher: MAX is a superhero comic about a superhero doing superheroics?

Use your brain for two fucking seconds.

Yeah, and over there is even worse!

When did I say comic book movies? I'm talking about comic books. They should make a live adaptation board that discusses any sort of adaptation. I don't want to discuss comics on a live adaptation board.

Godzilla is in the Marvel comics.
Godzilla is not a superhero.

Can the mods lift the ban on My Little Pony in general? Not Friendship is Magic but the other generations. My Little Pony N Friends has more in common with Strawberry Shortcake or Rainbow Brite than FIM. /mlp/ wants nothing to do with G1.

That's a thing? I have made Lion King, Sonic, etc threads without issue.

Bad idea. Asians hate each other more than latinos hate each other. Every Korean thread on Sup Forums inevitably has a dozen comments about how crappy Korea is and how their comics are either manga ripoffs or Deviantart tier.

Obfuscate the point all you want. The live action movies still go on Sup Forums.

>its not Sup Forums related if its not drawn even if it uses Sup Forums characters and stories and designs

You're an idiot

>They should make a live adaptation board that discusses any sort of adaptation.
There already is a live adaptation board.
Its called Sup Forums. They talk about live adaptations LITERALLY ALL THE TIME.

Then steps should be taken to fix Sup Forums.

>They should make a live adaptation board that discusses any sort of adaptation

That's retarded, people talk about comic book adaptations a lot but not that much.

So why dont you complain when threads go up about live action adaptions of cartoon material?

ITS ALL OR NOTHING.

A live action movie is not a comic nor a cartoon.

Good. Capeshit adaptations deserve the worst.

THIS

>Its called Sup Forums. They talk about live adaptations LITERALLY ALL THE TIME.

Shitposting and talking is not the same.

Not that I hate the idea, is just that I don't see it happening.

Did you even read the post? Are you a fucking idiot who can't understand how the same characters/franchises belong on different boards depending on their medium? I feel like you don't even grasp the fundamental purpose of different boards for different mediums.

Those should go to Sup Forums as well. All live action goes to Sup Forums.

What all could fall under the genre? What separates something from being a cape comic and not being a cape comic?

Theres obvious ones like say hack/slash vs. iron man, theres a clear difference, but shit like Hellboy is on that borderline where it would effectively be banned from the site if discussion on "cape" and "comics" were split.

>Shitposting and talking is not the same.
A problem for the other board, not this one.

Then contain it to Sup Forums. Majority don't want that here.
Fuck off and they do.

all the same fagging and nothing's gonna change

>is just that I don't see it happening.

Good job being a defeatist.

As last thread, I feel this is what it should be done in order to actually change things in Sup Forums.

1.- Better and actual comunicative moderators and janitors, don't let the mods have some bias over their "board culture", and if there needs to be a voting system or complete change of mods, so be it.
2.- Ban all Sup Forums, Sup Forums tier and Sup Forums shitposting, HOWEVER political, videogame, and movie/shows cartoons and comics can stay as long as they actually talk about that stuff, or make actual OC (Original Content, you can check the rules for that shit, I think)
3.- Regulate threads so that waifufaggotry, e-celebrity, gay content that's not related at all with the thread and fights to the minimum
4.- LOL threads are out, because there's no actual LOL, only shitposting about some shitty awful comic that then people take too seriously, and start spamming.
5.- Generals should be allowed, but only if the show's actually on air/not in hiatus. If the general's content and "posters" leak into other threads (aka try to shitpost any usual thread with their fanboyism), report and sage
6.- Company Wars ARE NOT ALLOWED
7.- Eliminate all SJW and Tumblr content that is only used as shitposting.
and I just added a new one.
8.- If a thread is made in order for Sup Forums users to have fun, it shall be allowed as long as there's no avatarfagging, shitpost, and as long as actual OC is made and complies with the rules of this board.

Yeah and where are you when we talk about Sup Forums video games?

Dont see the "take this shit to Sup Forums" shitposting there, huh?

Oh no but thats different clearly, thats fine.

Can't you peole see that nobody else is behind this stupid idea?

Comic books movies are Sup Forums related, retards.

Discussions about video games based on Sup Forums properties should go to Sup Forums. Those mobile game threads that used to pop up were an eyesore.

Sup Forums has threads for comic book video games all the time, and nobody shitposts about how it should go to Sup Forums. I don't even remember the last time someone tried to make a video game thread on Sup Forums. and if they did and it's off topic just report it.

>same fagging
strawpoll.me/11229277/r
Kill yourself Sup Forums. Fuck off back to your shithole.

>gay content that's not related at all

Yeah but nobody would complain about the cheesecake that has nothing to do with the threads, right?

If people get to see sexy girls, they should get to see sexy dudes and gay dudes if they feel like it, stop being a prude, if you don't like it just close your eyes

3/4ths of the poll disagree and a fucking ton of people in this thread want Sup Forums threads removed. You're a retard and I won't miss you when you're gone.

MATH CAPTCHAS

8 out of 10 times complete retards happen to not understand anything about math. 2 out 10 times are rare people who have something interesting or valuable to say but not good at math (collateral damage) and faggots who know math, but also cancerous.

>Those mobile game threads that used to pop up were an eyesore.

why, were you forced to read them?