TFA VS ROGUE ONE

Okay guys seriously what film was better and why?

who cares, no joke star wars fucking sucks. wasted potential.

fpbp

Both shit, whoo cares.

R1 was marginally better because it had mads and a plot that wasn't a complete rehash but seriously both of these movies are fucking dumpster tier

Rogue 1 no contest but that's just a guess based on which one I preferred even though I can't even remember why I preferred it other than flipping out over the last scene with Vader leading up to episode 4

Both are meh, but Rogue one way much better than Tfa,

the force awakens was like a deconstruction of a star wars movie. it felt like everything in that movie was an intentional subversion of a new hope. it would have worked better as a wayan's brother spoof.

rogue 1 had marginal characterization so i guess it was better. the climactic battle was also pretty cool, but the fact that i didn't give a shit about any of the characters detracted from it. i didn't feel anything when they died. the darth vader lightsaber rampage saved that movie.

Reminder that RLM is gonna break into your houses and sodomize you while you sleep

Rogue One was fantastic, I personally really enjoyed how dark it was. I'll go as far to say R1 is top 3 alltime SW films.

TFA? Easily the worst SW yet to be made, a travesty.

TFA was actually enjoyable if only once.
R1 was unbearable the first time

Star Wars is female

People who like Star Wars will say TFA
People who are indifferent of Star Wars will say R1
I'm going with They both suck, and are no different than your average Marvel flick

Felicity Jones can actually make more than one face

Haven't seen rogue one but tfa was a really standard hollywood movie.
It had characters I didn't give a shit about and the plot was still a childish good vs evil plot.

Rogue One easily, but it's no masterpiece for sure though.

Rogue One was better because of Diego Luna and whats her name, the main character.

Rogue One is definitely better, but that's not saying much.

R1, but that's on TFA being fucking shit.

R1 much better

Rogue one broke new ground. TFA brought nothing new. Kylo Ren is literally darth vader 2.0

force awakens by miles, rogue one was straight up boring

TFA is a lot better than Rogue One. People tend to forget the fact that Rogue One had worse cgi, more pandering, etc. They also tend to reminisce about Rogue One and post images from the promotions that didn't actually show up in the movie. It could potentially be considered a fault of both movies that certain things don't carry over, like K2SO droids given how cool they seem to be, but that droid alone isn't enough to carry the movie.

TFA might have been basically pointless to make since A New Hope already exists, but at least I wasn't completely fucking bored watching it. R1 was a damn snoozefest.

K2SO was unironically the best part of the movie.

Rogue One sucked a little less. It was actually trying to be Star Wars.

R1 looked better and was cooler than TFA, but godamn it was pretty boring in parts. The first 30 mins after Mads been taken are an utter abortion of random locations, planets and faintly Mexican looking dudes. The last 30 mins was better than anything in TFA, but as a whole film, TFA just edges it.

Neither were anything above a 6.5/10.

I like Rogue One better.

Rogue One is an one-off story so it has beginning middle and end. Whether you like it or not it contains one complete story.

TFA is beginning part of a trilogy thus it has open endings that not answered in the movie. It has introduction to characters and state of the current universe but not satisfying enough story to stand as a its own movie imho.
TFA's place gonna be clear in the contex of the trilogy.

They're both shit.

>TFA
>blatant rehash of ANH
>unimaginative designs
>bad acting
>mary sue bypasses character development
>chock full of throwbacks (WHOAH REMEMBER WHEN LUKE CALLED THE FALCON JUNK? WHOAH REMEMBER THE TRAINING DROID? WHOAH REMEMBER THE DEATH STAR? WHOAH REMEMBER THE TRENCH RUN?)

>RO
>unecessary prequel
>you can easily tell where the reshoots occured because the movie tries to portray the Rebels as just as bad as the Empire but then turns into REBELLION FUCK YEAH at the end
>does more to ruin ANH that provide a set up
>once again, chock full of throwbacks (WHOAH REMEMBER THE TURBO TANKS?
WHOAH REMEMBER HE-DOESNT-LIKE-YOU AND I-DONT-LIKE-YOU-EITHER? WHOAH REMEMBER THAT ONE GUY FROM THE CLONE WARS SHOW? WHOAH REMEMBER THE PROBE DROID? WHOAH REMEMBER RED AND GOLD LEADER? WHOAH REMEMBER WHEN VADER WAS A BAD@SS WHO DIDNT USE THE FORCE TO SNATCH THE DEATH STAR SCHEMATICS? WHOAH REMEMBER WHEN LEIA JUST SAT IN A WAR ZONE FOR 30 MINUTES BEFORE DISEMBARKING ON THE TANTIVE IV AND VADER SAW HER BUT STILL ASKED IF IT WAS A CONSUL SHIP?)

Awful movies, they feel like capeshit with star wars costumes.

I enjoyed R1 more. It was an okay action flick. TFA was just setting things up for the other movies and shit and it sort of detracted from the story and feel. R1 just felt like a complete story tightly wrapped for your pleb enjoyment.

bunny > xenomorph

i bet you beat off to this pic don't you.

not him but i have fapped to her making weird faces probably dozens of times since TFA came out

i like the bunny

her body doesnt do it for me senpai

how can you even say that? she's pretty darn thicc.

...

hnnngggg that dress is way too small on her

>microscopic tits

>plebs saying TFA was just a rehash of ANH
>not realizing it actually had shades of all three of the OT
>not realizing that the ending was more similar to ROTJ

literally no tits senpai, i rather suck alicia vikanders

...

Huh, I never noticed she had great legs

they literally look like 70 year old breasts

>womens legs look better when they wear heals

Surprise

...

Oh I'm not a MUH LONG THIN LEGS man, solely mirin those quads over here

a-anyone got pics of her f-feet?

TFA is an uninspired mess featuring a vast array of hateable characters, a truly horrible plot, and visuals made for the basest plebian made by one of the biggest hacks in hollywood

RO is a misguided mess featuing a vast array of non-characters with a fresh (star wars wise) but still derivative plot, restrained visuals, made by a disney sweatshop director who still managed to be more competent than Abrams

TFA: D-
RO: C+

...

R1 because of sarcastic droid just by itself made R1 superior

I dont recall any villains dying or any plot line closures in TFA
I dont recall main characters meeting any mentors at the end of ROTJ

Disgusting, she should have a queen of spades while she's at it

One is a dumb spin-off.

TFA is a 1/10 flick and R1 is 3 or 4/10. You can debate as long as you want but the end result is that they are both shit.

7/10 drops to 6 due to dumbass tattoo

why do so many girls have dumbass clip art tattoos on their feet? it's literally MS Paint shapes, stars circles hearts leaves etc

small tits can be still alright her abdomen does stick out further though...

Look out, we got a female body inspector over here.

>the force awakens was like a deconstruction of a star wars movie. it felt like everything in that movie was an intentional subversion of a new hope

cause they're totally wacky and cutesy!

They are the worst SW movies next to Attack of the Clones, but Rogue One is the best of the worst.

What if Porg became a new racial slur?

I unironically really liked R1
I mean it had some horrible flaws but there was a lot I enjoyed

I really liked Ben Mendelsohn as Orson Krennic because it felt refreshing experiencing "Imperial Middle Management" in the space opera setting
He's a fun actor to begin with but watching him trying to be the big man while running around cleaning up after his subordinates and preventing rebel sabotage while constantly getting shit on by his higher ups makes for a really enjoyable setting between the space-fantasy of the main saga with the knights rescuing the princess from the great fortress of the evil wizard
I just like knowing that there was a guy who built the great fortress, and his asshole boss stole the credit for it
and then killed him with it lel

Both are pure garbage.

This.

I don't really get the hate for R1
It was a pretty decent attempt at making a star wars film without aping what had come before. Obviously there are flaws but I think it justifies its own existence well enough, which I can't say for TFA

tfa was a rehash of star wars clichés, rogue one failed hard at making us attached to that bunch of bad ass characters so... its like rotten vs bland... how about we all lose in this game

Love it how people just have a blind spot for Star Wars just because it's Star Wars
"it justifies its own existence" is high praise indeed!

Can you say with 100% certainty that you justify your own existence?

No? If my life was a movie it would be the most boring shit ever though, so I don't see how that relates to the point at hand

>what film was better
The one with the superior lead.

i hate the force awakens and am indifferent to rogue one. but was slightly hurt when i went on youtube and started watching the deadth star trench run and all the comments were. wow becasue of rogue one this makes me appreciate this more or who here becasue of rogue one. it made me hate the rogue one a little more

>what's better, this piece of shit or that piece of shit?

This.

Both films felt fake at times. But TFA had some real cinematic moments and bits of good acting from every one. R1 was destroyed by Felicity Jones. A part her slightly sulking face, she didn't show much range.

my order of favorites
ANH
ESB
R1
RotJ
RotS
PM
AotC
FA

she looks trash there, like a 12 year old all glammed up, disgusting.

brother you are gay

Rogue One is better than all the mainline movies.