Am I allowed to enjoy his films?

...

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=_nS66IvbvcI
youtube.com/watch?v=ks4DmdF5bh8
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

No, unless you want JEWISH pedophilia poisoning your mind.

if you can't separate an artists work from his personal life, you should go back to Sup Forums desu

You're a piece of shit if you even consider it.

sure, if you're 70 years old
all his films feel like musty newspapers you find in ur grampy's garage

>oh hes such an auteur
fuck off octagenarian

Charles Manson did nothing wrong. READ "SIEGE"!

If you believe that, then you believe the ends justifies the means. Fuck you.

Who is in the wrong here

Hell Yes.

The Ninth Gate is awesome, and for some reason I keep coming back to it...

The shithead pedo is in the wrong, dumbass. Pay attention.

How about Platoon, considering Charlie Sheen is an AIDS-ridden pedophile who is an active user of child porn?

That's actually untrue. A creation becomes divorced from its creator the minute it is published, death of the author and whatnot. Do you also refuse to watch anything produced by MGM or the Weinstein company since they may never have been produced without Harvey and Bob's acumen ?

>A creation becomes divorced from its creator the minute it is published
Prove it

Hitler dead, so white supremacy is now good. Thanks, user. Now I can hate the lesser races guiltfree.

If a creation is divorced from its creator when published, then there is no such thing as plagiarism.

in all forms of art (music, literature, films) you have people who produce absolutely stunning, groundbreaking works but happen to be pieces of shit. if you can't put aside your personal preferences against said person to appreciate art, what the fuck are you doing in the first place? you're not judging the person who made the art, or their motives, you're exclusively judging the art itself. hating someones work because the person themselves is a big meanie is the most Sup Forums thing in the world. it's like saying Red is your favorite color but you don't associate with it or buy any red products because it has gang ties when you don't even live near black people.

I bet the other dude is an avid video game player and gamergater because he sounds pretty pathetic.

yes it is reddit to hate him. he is still the greatest. in the 60s/70s everyone was fucking everyone. you should hate him for being a manlet if anything

youtube.com/watch?v=_nS66IvbvcI

how fucking retarded are you?

it's an opinion, autist

>doesn't understand how formal logic works at all

I don't believe in artistic property, either. It's a necessary (according to the interested parties) functional institution to protect the self-interested monetizing of art. Stems from, other than the obvious desire for publishing companies along with the creators themselves to make capital, a need to attribute greatness to a single source. For some reason people have an issue with appreciating art when they can't imbue its creator with the significance of the work itself

>I don't believe in artistic property, either. It's a necessary (according to the interested parties) functional institution to protect the self-interested monetizing of art. Stems from, other than the obvious desire for publishing companies along with the creators themselves to make capital, a need to attribute greatness to a single source. For some reason people have an issue with appreciating art when they can't imbue its creator with the significance of the work itself

Yes, you can enjoy his films and hate the guy unless you're a retard.

He may have gone too far in a few places.

oh yeah, I forgot actually having opinions on here makes me a faggot, shit

Am I allowed to read The Odyssey if the greeks were all pederasts?

why does everyone have to hate Polanski anyway? I mean, what he did was obviously fucked up, but I don't know him or the girl involved, so I don't really give a shit t b h. I mean, if people had to disown anything where the creators did immoral things, it would be pretty impossible to like any tv/movie/music whatever. There aren't many sterling examples of people , especially not in the entertainment industry according to recent headlines

>he put his penis in my butt

laughed out loud, shouldn't have but did

brainlets can't fathom enjoying things based exclusively on how good it is, and have to bring in a persons character when it has nothing to do with said piece of work. even the girl he raped is over it.

>More than 100 people in the film industry, including Woody Allen, Martin Scorsese, Darren Aronofsky, and David Lynch signed a petition in 2009 calling for Polanski's release. Multiple actors, including Meryl Streep, gave a standing ovation at the 2003 Academy Awards.
What did Hollywood mean by this?

They really liked The Pianist I guess.

would they have been so candid with their support in the current year of the Hollywood witch hunts? Really dingles my bingle

Maybe if he made a film as good as The Pianist in the current year

>people who care about making art want to see an artist have artistic freedom

wow, truly makes me think

Does Meryl Streep care about making art?

>he deserves artistic freedom therefore he should be released from jail for committing the crime of raping a minor

>does the best actress this generation care about making art

>polanski is in jail
do you even know what the fuck you're talking about, retard?

This. His films are worthwhile, and one's personal bias doens't factor into it.

Okay Meryl

>without Harvey and Bob's acumen ?
I though Spacey was the one cumming in men

HNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNG
Did Polanski ever make this movie? This script makes The Tenant look like shit, I'd actually watch this and jack off

released from banishment, whatever. point is the same

Not that user but even though he isn't in jail i think what he meant to say was should Roman be forgiven of his crime of raping a minor just because people find his artistic work good ? You're absolutely baiting me or are a retard if you think that

The Tenant is shit.

>should Roman be forgiven of his crime of raping a minor
Should Led Zeppelin? Polanski just gave this chick some ludes and buttfucked her in a Jach Nicholson's jacuzzi. That sounds more fun and classy than getting pussy-fucked with a mudshark in a hotel room, and I'm pretty sure Polanski's girl was 15 at the time vs. zepp's 14 year old

You should make like the end of that film and throw yourself off the roof of a tall building twice in a row to get the job done

Go to bed, Polanski. Fuck you and your crossdressing desires.

Ok? That's what he is saying, Polanski should not be forgiven for his crime. Also the girl was 13 at the time

>best actress this generation
>look blankly just off camera and leave your mouth slightly open
Streep is so fucking overrated

>should Roman be forgiven of his crime

forgiven by who exactly?

>forgiven by who exactly?
This. He didn't do wrong by me.

Yeah, but Led Zeppelin fucking sucks.

I think his victim (or at least one of them) actually forgave him. She was tired of the rape affecting her life. Although that doesn't mean he deserves anything but imprisonment in a US prison.

heh

>rape
lmao the slut fucked him willingly and it's obvious

Are we allowed to enjoy Michael Jackson's music even though he was a child molester?

yes you fucking soyboy.

>awesome
it was garbage, granny
especially the shit ending

go to bed, roy moore

Should the right to artistic expression really be held in higher regard than than justice for a crime?

who cares about some hoe??

Haha, Polanski literally admitted in a Charlie Rose interview that he thought Ninth Gate was just a silly movie.

youtube.com/watch?v=ks4DmdF5bh8

Even the "victim" forgave Polanski, stop blaming the jews and thinking we are all rapists of children stupid idiots.

The more you talk back against us the worse things will get for you motherfuckers!

Heather O'Rourke died from Spielberg's septic cock raping her rectum at age 12.

No because his movies are shit