Okay Sup Forums, what is the better star wars movie?

...

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/_hoXNXSpmng
youtube.com/watch?v=4yU44Xk5fFI
youtube.com/watch?v=hS57I6swXcc
youtube.com/watch?v=iu3qoIsGzUM
youtu.be/ixjd_GvNRu8
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

Episode III

III was always the good prequel.

V>VI=IV>III>R1>TFA>I>II>VIII

Me on the right

Not even a contest m8
youtu.be/_hoXNXSpmng

I never want to watch either of these movies again desu user senpai alam

I'm just going to say EpIII since it has one or two green screen shots of Portman I like pic related

honestly the prequels were great they did exactly what they were supposed to, they told anakin's story and the downfall of the republic

the new star wars are like a cluttered mess

The real question is how is 9 going to redeem the series?

5>4>6=3>1=TFA>R1>2>TLJ
Literally the only acceptable ranking

III. III at least had a great climax and the "YO NEW EMPIYA?" scene was kino. VIII fucked up, kylo ren isn't shit. Snokes a shitty serious, ren is a shitty Anakin, rey is actually not bad. Also where the FUCK were the knights of ren?

HOLY FUCK IM SORRY GEORGE. THIS WAS KINO

>redeem
user...

Revenge of the Sith by a mile because it has BASED SHEEV and the beginnings of the Empire, which in general are way more compelling antagonists than The First Order.

TLJ is the best SW

>III: Sheev
>VIII: No Sheev

>III: McGregors Obi Wan
>VIII: No McGregors Obi Wan

>III: lightsaber duels
>VIII: no lightsaber duels

4 = 5 > 6 > 2 = 3 > 1 > mediocrity > 7 > shit > 8 > whocares > spinoffs

miss me yet?

Snoke is a serious Sidious I meant

holy shit this is pretty kino.

SHITTY sidious

to be fair its literally the only good 1 minute and 40 seconds in the entire movie

III. Sheev having fun is much better than anything NuWars

SITTING ON COUCHES AND TALKING
STANDING UP AND TALKING
SITTING ON COUCHES AND TALKING
SHOT... REVERSE SHOT
WALKING DOWN A HALLWAY AND TALKING
SHOT... REVERSE SHOT

4 > 5 > 7 > R1 > 8 > 6 > 3 > 1 > Christmas Special > 2

I bet you got that from some fag on youtube

Huh?

Hayden nailed this part

V > IV > VI = VIII > VII > III > I > II

Sup Forums is in the "le quirky opinion guize - movie sux xD" phase right now. TLJ has just about the same balance of filler/interesting parts as VI

Star wars is a series about redemption... This is just a meta story arc where the film's redeem themselves

apologize

You forgot
>III: God tier OST
>VIII: Meh OST

fuck off shill

I did, good shout user!

Objectively wrong
5>4>3=6>1=8>7>2>literal pile of dog shit>R1

> I LIK EMPIAH MOR CUZ IT HAB GUNS SHOOTEN!! ALSO WOOOOAAAA THE GOOD GUYS LOST?!?!?!?! WTF!!!!

Hope > Return > Empire > Awakens > Clones > Sith > Last > Phantom Menace

That's unfair since Episode 3 is the climax of a story while The Last Jedi is the middle instalment.

I NEVER DOUBTED YOU GEORGE

Is Williams just phoning it in, or is he too old?

haha so quirky amirite xD guize?

TLJ and Disney Wars as a whole is basically fanfic at this point but its not terrible. The prequels are bottom-of-the-barrel deviantart fanfic level in comparison though

sheev is embarrassing crap that people like ironically for meme reasons, mcgregor sucks as obi and the lightsaber duels in sith are terrible

And Episode III is getting shat on because..?!? This feels way more better and way more Star Wars than TFA.. and people prefer Force Awakens over this? What the hell.

Not true this part was also great:
youtube.com/watch?v=4yU44Xk5fFI
Basically a lot of the moments in Ep3 where there was no dialogue and just great John Williams score were great

Personally I think IV is my favorite, but that does not mean it is objectively better than V

Exactly

V > VI = III > VIII > IV > VII > I > II

RotS is better than anything (((disney))) has produced so far.

Imagine being this wrong

Star Wars is OVERRATED SHIT. If you care about it and you're not a child you are either a manchild or an attention whore fake geek girl who is looking for beta orbiters.

>III being that high
rewatch it user, nowhere near as engaging as when you were 12. the only redeeming parts of the prequels is the score but the writing and acting are objectively worse than the Disney Wars trilogy

V is objectively better because it explained everything you needed within one movie instead of two.

because the context of the scene is that he's planning to murder everyone he knows and doom an entire republic because some guy told him that some guy who may or may not have existed could stop people from dying. the movie is a big fucking mess

exactly my point, which is why I put is as number #1 on my rating list. If i had to choose a personal favorite, it would be Last Hope hands down though

Revenge of the Sith obviously.

youtube.com/watch?v=hS57I6swXcc

>mcgregor sucks as obi wan
Gtfo faggot , literally the only good thing about the prequels.

nice meme

...

Mustafar floating platform & backflips vs. superman Leia - which is worse?

He wasn't "planning" to murder everyone then, you dumb shit. And it wasn't because of some guy just told him to. Maybe you should pay attention instead of picking up your phone every two minutes, ADHD kid.

t. nu male faggot who enjoys mouse wars

The Last Jedi was better. RotS comes right after in terms of ranking.

OT is always gonna be the best.

I agree but it also is the most interesting. Episode III shows how Anakin became Vade mainly because of how naive he was and because he wanted to save Padme. That's fucking tragic. I mean, the guy is the ready to do whatever it takes to save Padme but in the end, by doing so, he is the end of her. And when he realise that "Where is Padme ? Is she safe ? Is she alright ?" it is too late but he has nothing left. No Padme, no Obi wan, no Jedi Order, only motherfucking Sidious standing by his side. He became a machine and lost his humanity at the same time Padmie gave birth. May seem stupid but I like the symbolic here

Episode III is far from a good movie but it is an amazing story.

The true order is as follows:

5 > 4 > 6 > 8 > 3 > 7 > 1 > 2

Rogue one is probably somewhere between 3 and 7.

t. millennial retard who hates movies made before 1995

mcgregor is terrible. he can't act and his obi is so unlike the obi of the ot that it might as well be a different character

This was good

>the guy is the ready to do whatever it takes to save Padme but in the end
he then chokes her out and accuses her of having "turned against him," abandoning her and thus the very reason why he turned in the first place. great writing

I haven't seen VIII but that's the most accurate ranking I've found up to date.

The porgs are like the tribbles of star trek only in star wars

It's more accurate, but imo III shouldn't be quite that high, and VIII is definitely not at the bottom.

Despite people going crazy online, it's at the very least better than TFA.

This 100%

Revenge of the Sith just for the far better music and Palpatine

youtube.com/watch?v=iu3qoIsGzUM
this scene alone is better than any disney sw movie

This scene was fucking stupid.

God, it's so easy to see who grew up watching this trash as kids.

ROTS

I want kids like you out of Sup Forums, seriously.

5>4>6=3>RO>1 = Mouse Wars

Autism: The star wars ranking

V > III > VI > IV > RO > I > II > VII > VIII

miss you always george

...

Revenge of the Sith.

> They can't even use roman numerals

VIII > VII > V > I > VI > III > IV > II >>>>>> R1

You really have to be a nostalgiafag to appreciate so much the OT

it's a great scene, it's humorous without being faggy and contrived

>luke's father hated sand
>in his final battle luke doesnt disturb the salt so he doesnt reveal any sand

absolute kinography

III and it's not even close.

You've got extremely fucked up taste.

>Despite people going crazy online, it's at the very least better than TFA.

Are you insane? TFA was lazy ripoff, but TLJ was even lazier and still a ripoff.
>Rian, what about Snoke's backstory, the Knights of Ren, Rey's parents, Kylo's relic hunting?
>lol fuck that, put in blue milkies and super leia

>now: STAR WARS
vs
>then: EPISODE III

why the change in the title format...
I wonder...

only a master of eville, darth

5>4 >6>3>7>R1>8>1>2

>then: I'm george lucas and would like to emphasize to my audience where this move stands in my epic space saga

>now: were disney and just want to emphasise to our audience that this is STAR WARS™! Please buy tickets!

>R1
Kill yourself

SPBP

The old Star Wars are good only if you are a kid and of course I also love them when I was young. But when you grow up and try to watch them again honestly they are simply not that good.

The prequels were shit but some parts in them were splendid, like the duel of fates fight.

While I don't understand how someone that likes the SW universe can't appreciate VII and VIII. The only reason for me is if you see this franchise as a religion and not just movies.

Oh yeah R1 had like the worst flat characters ever seen.

The entire OT blows the rest of the series out of the water. You're absolutely out of your mind. And yes, I have watched them recently.

5>4>>7>>>>>>3>1>2

Still bummed out that 8 was such a disappointment.

the prequels are fucking shit movies but i still would watch them over mouse wars any time. based george was just having fun

I did it too some years ago and I almost felt asleep in many parts and hated the wookies even more I could imagine.

But I'm happy if you can still find them good. The only scenes I can still enjoy are the ones where Solo, Vader or Palpatine are involved.

ROTS by a fucking country mile.

Episode III by a mile
youtu.be/ixjd_GvNRu8

still the last jedi. nothing will be ever worse than prequels.

what i liked:
>everything about kylo ren
>flashback scenes
>johnson experimenting with new force abilities
>surprisingly, poe dameron stepping up
>the scene where snoke's ship blew up was amazing
what i did not like:
>snoke died too easily and the opportunity to explain who he was and where he came from was lost
>no hayden, no ewan mcgregor again
>little too much humor in too many places
>phasma did nothing worthy again
>no knights of ren WHAT THE FUCK WHERE WERE THE FUCKING KNIGHTS OF REN
>leia superman scene
>the casino and stables scene was way too long
>rose being awkward af
>duels were underwhelming to my liking
>luke did not wreck shit up like everyone in the world wanted to except making one amazing dodge and jump
>rey and kylo did not join forces
>clear rey vs kylo for ep 9, with rey winning with the help of ghost luke

>snoke died too easily and the opportunity to explain who he was and where he came from was lost
he was a nazi you altright dipshit
all you need to know is nazis get PUNCHED