Countermands orders and gets the entire resistance bomber fleet wiped out

>countermands orders and gets the entire resistance bomber fleet wiped out
>leads failed mutiny against the commanding officer at gunpoint
>OH BETTER MAKE HIM A LEADER OF THE RESISTANCE NOW LOL

Just because you aren't capable of learning from life experiences, OP, doesn't mean Poe can't. You fucking goof.

Serious question though, why Leia didnt' send him alone to defeat the entire First Order? he destroyed the entire Starkiller base all by himself, srly, this dude knows his shit

What are you stupid? Starting mutiny alone is enough basis for an execution.

Call me stupid again I'll slap you fucking silly.

Promotions are based on who can make spark/ignite/fire metaphors

stupid

>This movie was supposed to be propaganda for Hillary's America

My fucking sides

He lost about 5 bombers and few fighters while taking down SSD.

Thats some impressive feat.

If your leader is a bad leader and seems to be actively working against your side then it's your duty to mutiny.

THAT'S FUCKING IT

r u a retard m8

Holdo is lucky he didn't shoot her ass when she refused to explain her plan for no reason and kept pretending she was going to do nothing while they were getting closer and closer to death.

No, going in the Starkiller base with 4 friends and destroying that shit with no casualties was the shit.

>Holdo should have told him her plan
>Poe should have been court marshalled for mutiny
Both can be true

Overall that plot was a mess

He was actually right about the taking down the dreadnought. He was also partially right about going against Holdo's plan, which was clearly, deeply flawed, as she got almost everyone wiped out.

Admiral Holdinformation was a cunt

He was also right in that leaving in the small transports was a suicide, they lost all but 3. And Commander Tumblrina had to ram into Supremacy to buy some time.

Could he? It was clear that that was the most logical course of action based on the information he was given.
The Resistance isn't even a proper military organization, it doesn't rely on discipline but rather on their members working together for a cause they believe in. You can't expect people to just shut up and stay put when it seems like you are doing nothing but sentence the whole crew to death.

The whole idea that they wouldn't "be looking" for smaller ships is fucking daft. Like the idea is they just wouldn't have seen them if codebreaker guy didn't tell the empire to look for it.

I swear the star destroyers are fucking AFK for half the movie. There's like one guy shooting his turbolaser every few minutes and everyone else is having a fucking nap or something.

This guy gets it.
Also, as the movie comes to a close, it wouldn't make much sense to get rid of a guy as capable and daring as Poe when you only have like two dozen people left in your whole organization.

>It was clear that that was the most logical course of action based on the information he was given.
It doesn't matter though. A grunt doesn't rebel and try to take over an army because he thinks the general is pursuing a bad strategy. That's rule 1 of the chain of command. Now in episode IX any dumb redshirt has complete justification to arrest Poe if they think he's doing a stupid job.
> The Resistance isn't even a proper military organization, it doesn't rely on discipline but rather on their members working together for a cause they believe in.
It relies on both. The Resistance has ranks and uniforms and a chain of command, it might be ragtag but every military organisation needs to follow its commanding officers or you get anarchy.

>It doesn't matter though. A grunt doesn't rebel and try to take over an army because he thinks the general is pursuing a bad strategy
He didn't think it was just "bad strategy", he thought she was going to murder them all by not doing anything and then trying to run away.
>Now in episode IX any dumb redshirt has complete justification to arrest Poe if they think he's doing a stupid job.
If he is retarded enough to make them think he is going to allow them to die, then sure.
Again, this people are fighting because they want to and have no reason to be forced to do shit against their will. That would go against everything the Rebellion stands for.
>he Resistance has ranks and uniforms and a chain of command, it might be ragtag but every military organisation needs to follow its commanding officers or you get anarchy.
And the commanding officers must be smart enough to inspire trust in their subordinate or they will totally deserve said anarchy.
No one follows orders just because, much less in a group like the Resistance.

>he thought she was going to murder them all by not doing anything and then trying to run away
But it doesn't matter at all what he thought or what it seemed. If he's started a mutiny, in any military or para-military organisation he'd be put on trial, and most likely end up executed.
>No one follows orders just because, much less in a group like the Resistance.
They absolutely do. You must understand, authority and discipline is crucial.
Someone may start a mutiny if he thinks that the current command is doing bad job, but he has to realise that if he fails he'll be killed, other circumstances honestly just don't matter, that's how it works.

>We are the crank that rotates the gears, which pushes the lever, that knocks the boot, that kicks the bucket, that knocks the marble down the staircase, into the chute, hitting the pole, knocking the ball out of the hand, into the bathtub, through the hole, onto the seesaw, launching the diver into the tub that drops the cage onto the First Order
A little much don't you think Rian?

>Commander rank
>Grunt

Nigga u dumb. This guy was a relatively high ranking officer. He'd be in charge of a whole squadron, mid-sized vessel, or a battalion sized ground force (800-1000 men).

wow you searched wikipedia cool

They called him Commander in the movie you dumb sack of hair.

>You must understand, authority and discipline is crucial.
Commanders that fuck up badly enough to inspire mutinies also tend to get utterly pasted by their Superiors.
The fact Leia didn't rip her a new one for not mentioning it is also bullshit.

It's a Metaphora you dumb retard

STARWARS IS FUCKING DEAD

GET OVER IT

Kill
Your
Self

Neither can the Resistance apparently.