Dunkirk

Why was it so good?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=ean6zzWgvXU
youtube.com/watch?v=QijbOCvunfU
youtube.com/watch?v=JO3nveNaSo8
youtube.com/watch?v=o3jR_9oW3Lk
twitter.com/AnonBabble

Because it had a big guy wearing a mask crashing planes with no survivors for you

He also started the fire

Nolan saw how long and wordy Interstellar was and said gotta trim the fat mate

I don't remember it being good at all

Watch it again with your eyes open

I did a week ago, it wasn't very good

For me the kino was whenever they tried to make it feel like really being at Dunkirk, as opposed to any shots a human wouldn't achieve

On a small screen? Without surround sound? That'd probably be why. It was an experience, not a movie.

It did one thing and did it reasonably well.

this movie was shit, just a bunch of twink bois larping like soldiers. A bunch of gay shit happens then a little boy who is annoying as fucking bumps his head

>good
boring and sterile you mean

terrible taste user

Daily reminder that Nolan’s best film will always be Memento

>good
Maybe if youre into twinks

>this move is good
>but only if you watch it in cinema and preferably IMAX

then it wasnt good in the 1st place, pleb

a good movie will still be good even when viewed on a bootleg VCD from guatemala

>make movie to accurately recreate the feeling of being in a war zone
>think it can be enjoyed to the fullest on your shitty 19 inch laptop screen with a tiny speaker

Trash

This, that first stuka attack was so visceral I felt my stomach turn, what an experience.

That drowning scene was real.

Sound doesn't fix the fundamental script, pacing and structural problems

Fuck the aspect ratio for this film, so distracting and I bought a new ultrawide monitor and it looks like shit on it

i didnt even care about that potato, its funny how the movie tried to make it all dramatic and sad

they didnt develop like 80% of the characters on screen and then they die in many ways. The visuals are impressive but the authentic human element is absent. The girl beside me was checking her phone half the time.

>a war zone
>bombs drop on the soldiers
>zero blood and gore

that beach scene after he attempted to take a dump was when I rolled my eyes

The only issue was being non chronological for literally no reason. Other than that, if you were in the theatre and heard the fucking gun fire sound like actual gun fire you would be enthralled.

>using a woman a gauge for a film's worth, especially a historical film

Holy shit user you truly are a pleb.

I saw it in the cinema first

It wasn't a good movie

Was pretty bad, no sense of scale, lame characters if you could even call it that, loud as fuck intense music for the dog fights, exact same loud as fuck intense music during a quieter scene when they're loading the life vests on the boat. Woah man so intense!

The issue is if it was chronological it would be on the beach for half the movie, then suddenly stop showing them as aboat leaves, then the last 1/4 of the movie is airfight over the two boats that the other two potlines are on.

ME HEAR LOUD NOISE LIKE GUN OOGA BOOGA

no, im saying i was turned off by the cracks in facade of the movie thats why i noticed the thot beside me

obvious women dont get war films

but this isnt a war film. This is boys pretending to be soldiers in front of a camera, they didnt even convince themselves.

I think I still might have preferred that. The only reason I was interested in the first place was because most of the shots from the trailer were on the ground and nothing looked too flashy or ridiculous. I was hoping for a realistic experience of being at Dunkirk rather than some hollywood action-drama, and for the most part i think it delivered

>durrr gunfire is just loud noise
No. It was the fact the gunfire cracks through the silence and feels threatening when experienced in a theatre, unlike any hollywood action movie where they dub over some stick machine gun fire making sure it's quieter than the dialogue at all times.

No one is arguing that. It's a masterpiece.

it's shit

You haven't seen many movies have you

Why does Nolan make the best intros?

Fucking moron, he did but in this pic

The sound design.

Finally someone decided to pull the trigger and go full HEAT on it instead of making shitty post production gun shot sounds.

Also the clipping is insane.

why didnt he eject or land in allied territory?

Because he was out of fuel dingus

youtube.com/watch?v=ean6zzWgvXU
explain this scene he could have done it right after this

it was a beautiful film, just shallow. really immersive and entertaining, I just don't think about it anymore, you know?

he was flying to low to eject

Because they expected one of them in the wreckage, brother

autism

The films is good like plain white bread. Good, almost perfect with nothing wrong with it but bland and boring to eat by itself.

Because he used the last of his potential energy to take out that last plane, leaving him too low to attempt to turn again to land close to their beach. Literally everywhere else but that tiny spot is enemy territory.
Also, too low/bailing out is more dangerous

There was none at the time.

i would rather try to land in the water like the other pilot instead of being captured by literal nazis

>A*glo propaganda
>good

>tfw a five minute shot is better than an hour and a half movie

youtube.com/watch?v=QijbOCvunfU

best post

make better webms

It was a movie where he totally avoided his 2 greatest weaknesses: plot and dialogue. Not to shit on the dude but the plot and dialogue are both the weakest parts of his movies. He knows how to build a feeling and he has good cinematography, but the writing is usually shit. Dunkirk was pretty good at sidestepping it.

...

>you're done, kirk!
>i want your dog tags and rifle on my desk by the end of the day!

are you kidding, nolan?

fpbp

street looks too modern, really ruins the immersion

Thats your problem, I love imax format

>HURRR DURRR WHERE'S MUH FLAG-DRAPED CASKET BEING LOWERED TO THE GRAVE SCENE
>HURRR DURRR WHERE'S MUH WIVES CRYING AT PICKET FENCE HOMES SCENE
>HURRR DURRR WHERE'S MUH GUTTED SOLDIER SCREAMS "MOMMYYY" SCENE
>HURRR DURRR WHERE'S MUH GENERALS IN A MAP-ROOM SCENE

Nice food analogy, fag

>fat black "AYY YO U BE SAYIN WE IZ SURROUNDED ON DA BEACH N SHEEIT" """"""british"""""" soldier
Yeah nah this scene is fuckin trash

Its a britfaggot soyboy samefags about his garbage soyboy movie thread

Soyboy

i can see people ips, there is literally just one britfaggot spamming about this movie

Am I the only one who did not understand the disjointed timeline in the film until halfway into the film?

When was this in the film?
I literally don't remember seeing this scene in theaters.

Well, Nolan has a tendency of making 5-10 minute scenes that can stand on their own and don't need the rest of the movie

Shit, same here actually. I've watched the DVD version like a week ago and can't remember this either.

>brainlets go in expecting a war flick in which the good guys win and come back to their father's farm and their sweetheat Peggy Sue after kicking some german ass
>instead they get a survival kino about people scared to die with the theme of the perception of heroism and pointlessness of heroic behavior in the face of sure death
Best Nolan movie and best 2017 movie

Nah, the lack of writing was a huge problem for Dunkirk. He should just hire a good writer instead of trying to go for a minimal script himself. He's nowhere near good enough to make the audience care about characters without dialogue

Have frogs been mating with britfaggots?

As much as I like to laugh at Americans for not understanding why Dunkirk is celebrated, Nolan didn't make a good flick.

Thta would explain a lot wouldnt it

>theme of the perception of heroism and pointlessness of heroic behavior in the face of sure death
don't kid yourself, this was no Crosses of Iron

Literally the South East population of England

it's going to take a few more viewings for me to appreciate it. but on the first watch the non linear story structure confused me.

And as usual it's also going to take me a few more listens to the score. but I'm feeling like it's pretty good. Not as good as Inception or Interstellar.

It won't be something I can put on at any time like those two.

I heard he used real planes when shooting and if this shot is real those planes look dangerously close together. So cool.

I cared

>boys pretending to be soldiers
Yea that's how war is jackass. Bunch of 16-20 year olds looking like your dumbass were there. Not vin Diesel or some shit.

>don't kid yourself, this was no Crosses of Iron
The theme of the movie is the perception of heroism and attacking war propaganda though. It's not that Nolan is the master of subtlelty, it is what it is.

How much stupid can someone be

This

>Wore the mask
>crashed the plane
>getting captured was only a part of his plan
Bravo Nolan

>gf asks "why didn't the ship captain tell Cillian Murphy the boy died"

No, you never saw any fucking Nazis.
It's boring having just a bunch of faggots on a beach getting shot at with pot shots.

>muh cinematography
youtube.com/watch?v=JO3nveNaSo8 substantially better WW2kino with substantially better cinematography

...

>Cillian Murphy is a fucking hero on the boat saving the guys despite having little to no room in the boat
>same character is a broken man with no honor or bravery a day later after seeing hundreds die
Bravo Nolan but unironically

Goddamn I love war survival movies. Propaganda tier heroism is overrated. The horror of war is where it's at.

it was barely in the movie and the ending where they directly address it was clumsy and ineffective

BECAUSE GETTING CAUGHT WAS PART OF HIS PLAN YOU DUMMY

...

I really don't like the changing aspect ratio.

why do brits celebrate a retreat ?

I wonder... Would it hurt him if I took off the mask?

Wait a minute, why is this named Dunkirk scene then?

It would be very painful for you, of course

because it's at Dunkirk you mong

Oh you mean the place, not the movie. Okay.

I swear Nolan got Hardy and did all this shit with the sole purpose of indulging baneposters and Sup Forums.

He fucking knows this meme I'm sure of it.

No you're confusing it with this British porn film.

youtube.com/watch?v=o3jR_9oW3Lk