The phantom menace is the worst star wars mo-

>the phantom menace is the worst star wars mo-

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=ZuPe-ly0BHM
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

what was hans arc in this again?

Raid leader on Endor

Why did you stop, finish your sentence.

Surely you can't be implying that RotJ is worse?

>OP is not a literal retar-

Imagine no prequels or sequels

blow up a tower

return of the jedi is better than all the prequels combined. Phantom menace is not the worst star wars movie, that would be Rogue One

It's been a long time coming, but I've come to see TPM as the best of the prequels. I'll agree that the teddy bears didn't hold up well in RotJ, but it's still better than any of the prequels.

This

V>IV>III>VI>I>II

Last Jedi is the worst Star Wars film and that's not even up for debate.

5>4>6>1>3>2

vie

ROTS is practically unwatchable
TLJ wasn't as good as TFA but still better than any of the prequels

it drags in the middle but the finale is phenomenal - Luke defeating Vader and the Falcon flying through the Death Star are all timers

No, that would be Force Awakens.

Last Jedi gets a pass for BTFO of every single shit-tier fan theory and annoying youtube peddler playing on the hype.

Fuck the fans, seriously.

It was better than TFA, although both are meh.

This new trilogy was poorly conceived from the beginning. Full stop. With that said, I thought '7' was pretty good, though it certainly could have been better, and was only rendered mediocre by the direction pursued by the second two films.

Are ewoks the most unlikable creatures in movie history?

5 > 4 > 3 > 6 > 2 > 1 > R1 > 7 > 8 >

>Putting the OT anywhere other than top 3 EVER.

>the one scene where an Ewok mourns his fallen friend is more emotional than anything in the prequels AND sequels

Can a thread be anymore obviously Reddit

5>4>6>3>7>restisshit

just kys honestly

LOL NO

I hate this movie almost more than episode 2. It's easily at the bottom of my list.

But I also consider Rogue One to be the best Star Wars movie ever made so no one cares what I think.

RO > V > III > IV > VII > I > VIII > VI > II

>he hates ewoks
>he hates the natives fighting on their home turf using hidden traps to defeat a superior enemy

Fuck. Off.

At last RoTJ didn't have Jar Jar Binks at the least the ewoks were useful.

Neeson, Lee and McGregor in I and II are better than anything disney has shit out

They're stupid and annoying and I'm happy when they die. They should have been wookies. Then I might care. /edge

>you will never be a b wing pilot cock slapping dipshit imperial design in your over-engineered bringer of death

Whatever you say, underage.

>there are people who legitimately think any of the garbage from the prequels and sequels comes within a mile of Return of the Jedi
>I post on the same board as these borderline retards

still the best space battle of all time

I'm 25, and I still don't think just because they OT was first means it's best.

Depressing isn't it?

5>6>4>8>3>2>1>7>R1

Any other variants are objectively wrong

How does this still look so good nearly 35 years later?
Hell the only part of the space battle that didn't age that well was the fire from the star destroyer but everything else is top notch to this day.

6>5>4>7>R1>8>1>2>3

literally cuz practical effects

THIS. SO. MUCH


everyone should watch the RLM plinkett reviews of the prequels...WARINING: YOU WILL LOL

8 above anything other than 2....

Nice try. Oh Vey....

that's not attack of the clones

>borderline

The mission and Leia comeback, plus Jabba's demise mean that he finally put behind his back the thug life AND their relationship is more stable.
He is not anymore the tough guy, Leia says "I know" to him, but he is heroic because he fights for the good cause.
Is now selfless, able to say to Leia "I can step back" when he thinks she has something for Luke.

Disney please go

>the prequels were loved before RLM

/thread

star wars was never good

fuck off retard you're making us look bad

4=5>6>3>1=2=7=8=RO

>GOOD MORNING BEN

BEN DO YOU WANT SOME BROWNIES BEFORE YOU GO TO BED

These scenes alone are more than enough to carry Jedi to the top 3 of SW movies.

youtube.com/watch?v=ZuPe-ly0BHM

lol no

Seriously how can anybody think anything in the prequels matches up to the emotional depth of the scenes in the Death Star from ROTJ?
I don't get it at all man, and I say this as someone who enjoyed the prequels growing up.

The throne room scenes are the best in the trilogy.

I'll admit in retrospect that the Ewoks were a bad idea, though.

I wish he went with Wookies like he originally planned.

>when someone ranks episode 3 among the OT

Fuckin idiots. This is objectively correct.

Only thing I like about the ewoks is the beautiful forests of Santa Cruz, california

That's patently ridiculous

Nothing in the prequels compares to this at all

You can fuck right off. Wannabe art critics shit on it because it has a happy ending but that's what makes it a great final film; we've persevered through hard times and have now earned victory.

>Phantom Menace over Revenge of the Sith
Look at this fucking pleb

This is a new level of shitty shilling. "Don't forget how bad the prequels were!!". Nah, TLJ is the worst. Fuck this thread. Porgs make Jar Jar look like fucking Shaft.

Episode 3 is pretty fucking good. It's epic and the best looking star wars film of the Lucas films. It's like the peak of George's vision.

>if I cut every sentence off it doesn't make me look like a reta-

You just described The Phantom Menace.

The amount of cringe in this post is vomit inducing.

I want to refute, but my brain is in so much pain right now.

This is what I do. Every day, user.

This, which is why I'm annoyed they even made a sequel trilogy in the first place.
The only good change Lucas ever made to the OT was the new Victory Theme by John Williams for the ending, but he still managed to ruin it by adding in all those stupid fucking CGI shots of Naboo and later on that awful Hayden Face.

Because the people involved actually cared.

>ep III
>best looking star wars film

Stop.

>"HURR LOOK HOW BAD EP III LOOKS GUISE"
>posts image from Episode II

Why does Luke have two normal hands in the poster?

jesus is the entire bottom part of the temple really just a giant fucking lobby?

Hola Reddito!

>mfw Last Jedi

EPISODE I: 6.3/10
EPISODE II: 6.5/10
EPISODE III: 7.7/10
EPISODE IV: 8.4/10
EPISODE V: 8.6/10
EPISODE VI: 7.9/10

Search your feelings you know it to be true

Yeah dude these movies are really visually distinct lel

underage out

It's easy if you try

Why didn't they bring back Lando for the sequels at all?
I mean in retrospect after TLJ I'm so happy they didn't but he would have been perfect for that casino planet subplot that otherwise meant nothing at all.

What the fuck

I haven't seen this movie in years, and watching that scene STILL makes me feel things. Hatred for the Emperor, sadness for Luke.. so good. I legitimately haven't cared for anything that's happened in the new movies, they are so utter shit and the droves of people that like them completely baffle me.

I've collected every Sup Forums user's Star Wars ranking since January 1, 2018.
>ranks had to be "this movie is better than this movie, which is better than this movie..." all the way through, no "this movie equals this movie"
Overall I collected 87 rankings, pic related.
>Empire Strikes Back (9.22/10) - 5
>A New Hope (8.57/10) - 4
>Return of the Jedi (6.92/10) - 6
>Revenge of the Sith (6.05/10) - 3
>Rogue One (4.47/10) - R1
>The Phantom Menace (4.06/10) - 1
>The Force Awakens (4.02/10) - 7
>The Last Jedi (3.35/10) - 8
>Attack of the Clones (3.33/10) - 2
5 > 4 > 6 > 3 > R1 > 1 > 7 > 8 > 2

This is the perfect rating. I might put 1 higher than R1 on a certain day but otherwise I don't think this can be argued.

Hurry for metadata.

Seek help.

Just give Star Wards to Marvel already.

Don't question my autism.

Thats.... actually quite interesting

I want to criticize you for being super autistic but you actually managed to formulate the perfect ranking what the fuck

this is totally acceptable

>he would have been perfect for the casino plot
They would never cast a black man in a villainous/traitorous role

lmao this is 90% my ranking; the only difference is that I swap 1 and 2... a trend I noticed tv used to agree with me that 1>2 but in recent years they claim 2>1

brava user... brava

Attack of the Clones is the worst Star Ware movie. As annoying young Anakin and Jar Jar are, at least it still felt like a Star Wars movie and not like a shitty CGI cartoon with a meandering plot that doesn't seem to go anywhere.

I'm right there with you. VI (Theatrical) > I = VI (Special Edition)

>smashing tanks with sticks and stones

phantom menace isn't even the worst prequel
that goes to Attack of the Clones

Every time someone mentions the Throne Room scenes or the space battle, most Jedi critics tend to shut up. Jedi is probably the most iconic film of the entire series.

>Seriously how can anybody think anything in the prequels matches up to the emotional depth of the scenes in the Death Star from ROTJ?

I always say RotS had better pacing but RotJ had bigger emotional moments. I think the two movies are in the same tier but I give the edge to JEDI just because they had an epic story to wrap up and they gave us an equally epic ending with the final space battle and Luke confronting his own father and then then emperor as well as his own death.

Yeah Jedi has some pacing issues with Endor and the Jabba scenes but its not enough to tank the whole movie and sure as shit not enough to dip it below Prequel Tier

and when did that happen exactly?