Should they have told Dale?

Should they have told Dale?

About John Redcorn?
Nah he was happy enough not knowing, no reason to upset him when they weren't hurting anyone.

Yes. Infidelity is a sin, one that ought be paid for with blood.
Weakling wretch

From a black and white moral perspective, absolutely.
But Dale would definitely leave her if he knew. He'd never find anyone else, let alone someone else on her level, someone who was willing to take care of him, and tolerate all of his madness so willingly. A world where they tell Dale is also a world where Dale spends the rest of his life alone, living in some shitty apartment because his wife would get the house, eating cans of baked beans and MREs in his underwear and tin foil hat. That complicates the decision somewhat.

Always wondered how dale managed to wind up with Nancy in the first place. From all the high school backstories, it sounds like dales always been a loser and it's not like dale and Nancy have all that much chemistry together.

Dale already knew but accepted it as a trade off for having a kid. Most likely Dale is sterile and would rather be seen as a Cuck than be denied a chance to be a dad.

Fuck off Redcorn

Imagine what'll happen when Joseph finds out though.

Nancy should have because you don't do that to a spouse. But I feel like it would have been selfish for John to say anything, even more selfish than the affair in the first place.

Well, it's clear that Dale treats Nancy like a princess and does whatever he can to make sure she's happy, so that's probably what drew her to him in the first place.

Dale landed Nancy whole Nancy was on the rebound after a particularly nasty break up. Also, that Nancy honestly DID try and make the marriage work till Dale gave her migraines and drove her into Redcorns arms

The real mistake was making Dale believe it was his kid.

Dale always knew that Joseph wasn't his kid. He just thought he was half alien.

>Should they have told Dale?
Do you honestly think he would have believed them?

Would have made a great episode.
But assuming they met in highschool, Dale probably did a white knight moment to Nancy after she got "mistreated" by her popular boyfriend. After marriage, living with Dale stressed her out to the point she went to John Redcorn.

Also Dale record all incoming calls, he fucking knew.

Remember that episode Bill was dating a woman with kids and Dale thought one was suspicious so he did a DNA test on her? In that episode it's shown he has gnome printouts of most of the people he knows, he even compares Jospeh's to this girl's and sees they share a father. Did he just never compare his results to Jospeh's? Because he would have seen he wasn't related to Joseph at all. Does he have redcorns? Did he just assume the ayy lmaos scrambled his side of DNA?

>Also Dale record all incoming calls, he fucking knew.
But he wasn't constantly listening to them. I could see a point early in the affair where Nancy learns that Dale records phone calls and makes a point to figure out how his system works so that she can erase phone calls with John Redcorn immediately after they're finished.

Or hell, maybe they just didn't talk on the phone very often, and when they did they kept the conversations "casual" enough so that Dale wouldn't suspect anything. Remember, Nancy might have been a cheating harlot but she wasn't an idiot.

>Did he just assume the ayy lmaos scrambled his side of DNA?
This is Dale you're talking about, remember.

>Woman who cheats would get the house
Ah yes, I almost forgot how pants on head retarded US Divorce law is. Thank you for reminding me of another reason not to even bother with relationships.

They should have told Dale and he should have left Nancy for the pigeon exterminator.

Good point.

I have mix feelings about this episode. Also that episode where Hank get's sexually harassed by a cop that use to be a cheerleader when he was in highschool.

The real question, OP, is should they have told him NOW that she left John Redcorn, and Dale fixed his relationship with Nancy, and they have pretty much the happiest life they can get?

Dale thought Joseph was half alien breh