Rogue One really does get better with each viewing

Rogue One really does get better with each viewing.
They should get Gareth Edwards to do an original trilogy.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=6L8b1zPE0-Y
youtube.com/watch?v=53H0pNk1RSw
youtu.be/8Zb80smyukE
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

they should make Felicitys butt the main character

If the trilogy will be like rogue one but bigger, it'll be 50% boring references, and 50% decent movie, so.... no

I personally think Rogue One is the best Star Wars film. Followed by ESB and then ANH/RoTJ. The rest I thought were a load of shit. Especially the TLJ. I'm not a big fan of the series though. Like I've seen all the films at least once and the original trilogy maybe three times each.

I have noticed that the real fans of SW don't like Rogue One but non-fans do. Any other non-hardcore fans think the same?

i feel like i'm the only person who really liked R1. i mean it isn't perfect but it's one of the best SW films imo.

generic as fuck and no memorable characters, miles better than the two other clusterfucks though

>If the trilogy will be like rogue one but bigger, it'll be 50% boring references, and 50% decent movie, so.... no

I don't get why people are against something like that happening. It wouldn't affect the original films. Like you could ignore it and it wouldn't change anything. Just a bit of EU fan pandering which isn't always a bad thing.

Mads Mikkelsen deserves better

Wish they woulda saved him for a bigger role

i like it too. the hatred for it is too strong and entrenched so i've given up trying to discuss it and usually just ignore these threads

This didn't feel like a star wars film at all to me. It felt more like a generic scifi flick. None of the characters were worth liking or remembering. Nothing that happened was exciting or interesting.

This entire movie was boring through and through. Personally I would rather watch any of the prequels over this.

>They should get Tony Gilroy to do an original trilogy.
FTFY

Maybe it's because everyone dies, and there's no reliance/focus on super hero Jedi and shit.

i'm not going to say good things about rogue one because it's clearly marketed to the "serious star wars crowd."

it's fan-wanking to appease that demographic while disney takes a transgender dump into episode 7,8,9 and SOLO. i hate rogue one by association.

> Rogue One really does get better with each viewing
He watched it more than once...

I would like.

Do yourselves a favor and never watch Doctor Strange then

The only thing I hated was the music. It sounds like the cheap music HISHE uses to replace the music of the movies they parody so they don’t get a copyright strike
Like, you’ve heard the real Star Wars theme. This video starts with music they quickly made to sound like the Star Wars theme without being identical
youtube.com/watch?v=6L8b1zPE0-Y
This is the Rogue One theme
youtube.com/watch?v=53H0pNk1RSw
You see what I mean?

my favorite part in rogue one is when the two asians (that are obviously meant to be a gay couple, but without really dwelling on that matter because we want the asian audience) are emotionally dying near each other when all they want is to hug and hold hands and this plays in the background youtu.be/8Zb80smyukE

It's true. Rogue one is the only SW movies I have ever watched and I love it.

I live and breathe Star Wars and Rogue One is near the top for me also. Probably third after ESB and RotS. It's a fantastic film that really does the franchise justice while doing its own thing. There's a reason George Lucas himself actually praised it despite shitting on TFA and TLJ.

Rogue one sucked. I'm so depressed about these new sw movies i simply decided to not waste my time or money on them.

Still haven't seen TLJ and i don't plan on it

I've seen it maybe four times and couldn't tell you much about it from memory... it's truly forgettable.

Maybe you're just thick as shit.

Everything else about Rogue One was great except the main cast, Not really because of bad casting or anything but the cast was genuinely bloated and as a result, nobody could develop a serious connection with any of them beyond maybe K2-SO and the gooks. Chirrut and Baze were both cool but most people dont even remember their names exactly because character development was forced to take a backseat due to the amount of them. Cut away the pilot, Focus on Jyn and the gooks. The droid carries itself without much character development on the basis of being funny and the not Kyle Katarn should have been the one to stay alive to appear again at some point in another A Star Wars Story. He should have been exactly that, Disneys Kyle Katarn and he basically was except that they killed him and Jan before they did anything beyond stealing the death star plans. Kill everyone but him and suddenly you have Punished Cassian (and yes I had to fucking google his name)

Cassian was a good character. I don't really care if I remember the characters' names, I still remember them.

said no one ever the thread

better than 60% references, 35% shit movie and 5% decent attempts like the ST currently is

>keep watching something
>it becomes anodyne
No shit, Sherlock.

I could watch Citizen Kane 10 times and still think it's shit.

The most kino of all SW movies.

I loved it.

I watched it again recently and the second viewing made me really appreciate just how fucking good the cinematography was in it

Why does Disney hate it so much?

Because it was good.

I'm really getting sick and tired of this "negative space=kino" meme. It's not just the SW threads but seemingly everything.

Rogue one is a pleb filter. Only true fans can appreciate it.

story was ok except for the stupid fucking ground assault
its biggest problem was that it was made in 201x by retards
runner up probably the quippy bullshit
and the death scenes that make no sense
one day an important character will die without some stupid pointless last words scene
that droid was fucking stupid too
and the shitty character design (putting stupid impractical hats on an otherwise normal human)
oh and all the force nonsense come the fuck on

wow this movie had a lot of problems

I disagree with all your points.

Everything you listed is wrong. The problem may be you.

>the force nonsense

Pleb detected

not counting the gook couple, i mean

Some of the few knocks against R1 are: mentioning kyber crystals. And Ghost Dog going out like a bitch.

The inclusion of kyber crystals was kino. You’re an idiot.

>ghost dog
forgot about that bit
what a fucking lame way to go

kyber crystals were literally irrelevant

>He didn't like that Death Star is a giant fuck you lightsaber.

Its lame EU crap. Explaining shit that don't need explaining.
Also the random woman in the beginning saying "Trust the Force" like its some religious shit observed all over the galaxy.

It allowed for turning the Death Star into a nuclear bomb metaphor as well as pottery of making the Death Star be powered by the same thing as lightsabers.

No one can match old fan's expectations for a trilogy. Think small.

I think it's the best Disney Wars one, but I still couldn't stand about a half to two thirds of it.

>Also the random woman in the beginning saying "Trust the Force" like its some religious shit observed all over the galaxy.

I guess you're too much of a brainlet to understand the Force metaphor.

>the virgin ackbar

>the chad raddus

I've wanted to make this image but I don't know how to use Paint.

I never got the hate. Its literally the only Star Wars movie I enjoyed.

So you want to compare a person to a ship. R-r-r-retard

Agreed. I’m not a hardcore fan but I enjoy the films and video games

5 > RO > 6 > 4 > 3 > 1 > CW > 2 > Xmas > 7 > 8

Here's your (you).

I'd rather Gareth Edwards made more monster moobies tbqh

actually it doesn't gets worse.

I think this is it honestly, the characters felt more real because they all died. They weren't some mary-sue Jedi with magic powers and a super sword, they were mortal humans just like us.

Did Vader kill Admiral Raddus?

no its fucking terrible the characters are fucking horrible all of them, all fucking terrible.

its fucking star wars not modern art. who gives a fuck about a scene created by a computer? I want story structure, some good action and likeable characters.

Every time of these movies get made it just confirms in my mind, that star wars fucking sucks and it will continue to suck forever, not to mention i have to deal with the fucking hype for every movie, than the inevatible fallout cause its doesn't meet any expectations. than the arguments from people clearly paid off by companies to shill their shit movie, and the idiots who eat it up.

I want off this ride, please no more star wars, let it die. lets stop beating a dead horse

You seem to be working over-time in the salt mines, m80.

Rogue one was boring

star wars is about characters.
>makes a star wars film with characters even less memorable and cardboard than tpm's and Aotc's and tfa's characters.
Sure OP

Rogue one was fan service.
TLJ was fan defiance.
I'll take the one that pisses people off on Sup Forums the most.

If he could do it without executive meddling yeah/ I was really hoping for a director's cut of Rogue One.

>Gareth Edwards to do an original trilogy.
I agree, but Disney / Kennedy wanted to control the process too much for his tastes. He left out of his own will.

50% decent is pretty fkn decent

Probably. I can totally picture him stopping by the bridge to take out his rage on the rebel officers trying to make a last stand before going to hunt down leia.

The Story was complete shit. The idea on paper sounded good (lost girl whose father is a physicist for the Empir and created the death star...) but the handling was sub-par for me.
I wasn annoyed by all the Feminist references too.
Mads Mikkelsen was awesome of course and deserves an Oscar for every movie he's in, but more than half of the other actors played really badly. Also, I hate felicity's face, she's punchable.
3,5/10

>Feminist references

...like what?

I really doubt he would take the time. Raddus would've been executed by troopers, either after an interrogation or as soon as they found him.

If you don't like bunnyfu then there's no hope for you.

Well, I don't remember all of the shit of course, but I went too fast, I said feminism but I wanted to say more generally the Lefttist bullshit : there was like 3 whites in the entire movie + a girl lead.
Minorities and women = 90% of the movie
I'm not generally bothered and I can watch Blade and enjoy it, but this is Star Wars and we're white here thank you very much.

this.