Good?

Good?
Bad?
Ugly?

What do you guys think.

it's a nightmare

I think it could go either way really.
Just have to wait and see.

>D&D
>GoT creator
wut

That last season of GOT was a fucking nightmare

when the fuck did Westeros develop teleporters? (no way in fuck, gendry could run back to the wall and a raven fly halfway across a continent the size of South America and dany could fly all the way back while also finding Jons exact location beyond the wall in a 24 hour period)

Dothraki fucking up armored westerosi soldiers standing in formation (this is internally inconsistent established lore is that against an armoured opponent the Dothraki are shit, as demonstrated by Jorah of the friend zone in season 1) also let's not forget how did they get there? Dany's fleet was destroyed by Euron earlier.


The problem with Giving dungeons and dragons the ability to write a star wars trilogy depends on a simple question " was the last season of GOT so bad because they're hacks or was is so bad because George RR Martin is a hack who wrote himself into a corner (one that he cant possibly extricate himself from in the number of books he has left)?
If the answer is the former Star Wars is doomed if the answer is the latter then there is hope

Pic unrelated

a endless nightmare

GoT = tv show, ASoIaF = books

Yeea there were quite a few holes last season.
Although I still enjoyed it to a certain extent, the whole season felt... rushed.

Let's just pray Martin really did run out of ideas. I don't think it's unreasonable to think that he did.

I thought Rian Johnson was doing that

>Let's just pray Martin really did run out of ideas
it's not that he ran out of ideas it's that he doesn't know how to switch gears from the beginning of a narrative to the closing of on.

the books are all establishing stuff but now that it's time for pay off he has writers block

The way I read it is that they are both working on different series for Star wars all together

The trick is to let everyone and their mom make a Star Wars movies these days, about whatever the fuck they want. See who makes a good one, who makes a bad one, separate the wheat from the chaff.

Then set the bad movie ones on the mainline movies (currently the sequel trilogy), and set the good movie ones on good, old EU stuff.

lol no TLJ was trash and everyone knows it (that's why Disney was pushing damage control so hard) why else do you think they want JJ back for Ep 9? in spite of the fact many of the worst aspects being JJ's fault (niggers women and mary sue's)

Did you forget the part where a dragon flew ahead and burned the Lannister formation?

Hell even if you weren't hit, I'm sure the average man at arms would be breaking morale at the sight and sound.

To the guys who've read GrrMs short stories, would Dunk and Egg work as a tv show?

Are you forgetting that the Dothraki were winning even before that?

I could forgive it if it showed the Dothraki getting BTFO until the dragon showed up but that's not what they did

I stand corrected

I agree that without a dragon they should be fucked. They're not even Mongol-tier which actually could defeat German/Polish knights and armies.

The Dothraki are more like Native Americans, actually worse than them because even the Native Americans used horse archery more than the Dothraki do.

Charging unarmored because "Muh honor" is retarded.

>even the Native Americans used horse archery more than the Dothraki do.
Which is impressive because horses are an introduced species to North America (they didn't have them until Europeans brought them)

Except the Dothraki probably invented the wheel at some point

>MORE star wars

>rejoice
I have seen a majority of people NOT rejoicing over this

Finish your first trilogy first you fucking hacks. Capeshit was a mistake.

>the Dothraki were winning even before that?
Watch the episode again; the first contact that happens in the battle is Drogon burning a hole through the center of the Lannister line, which the Dothraki charge through.

So more terrible feminist characters and shit writing?

There are now two Trilogies planned
DnD's and Rian "Subverted your expectations of a good movie" Johnson's

It's a madhouse

>he only started noticing the problems in the last season

star wars can only go up from here tbqh
we bottomed out

>doing so fucking poorly in theater sales that you have to settle, and rely on the Soy of Thrones producers to unJUST your shit up
Even worst they're touching TOR AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH JUST FUCK EVERYBODYS SHIT UP WHY DONT YOU

Drogon & Yoda

TRIPS CONFIRMED

I can only imagine how bad this is going to be.