I think in terms of movies that were released this year...

I think in terms of movies that were released this year. This was by far the single most emotionally impacting scene out of any of them.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=d0XrhHBiXQM
dictionary.com/browse/good-joe
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

dishonest scene from a dishonest film

how was the scene dishonest? Curious

So many other better scenes in this flick but you Sup Forumsirgins are obsessed with your waifu fucking bullshit

You're right, all the scenes are amazing!

>piss orange filter
>meme brrrrrap sounds
>waifu simulator
>Reddit Ford phoning yet another nostalgia crap performance
>autistic goose
>DUDE I'M CINEMATOGRAPHING DEAKINS
>JARED I'M ACTING LETO

No thanks

Glad to see we're in that edgy phase where it's cool to hate objectively good films.

Think again cuck.youtube.com/watch?v=d0XrhHBiXQM

>this year

issa time traveler

>orange filter
Nope, all in camera.

The rest of your points are just meme brainfarts so I won't even bother.

I think in this scene K meets the essence of Joi, sees her true nature. He is shocked and can’t understand how could he love this soulless computer program. But then he realizes that only her actions, words she said made her special. So it doesn’t matter if he is not the son of Deckard, he can become the chosen one, because only his own decisions determine the meaning of his life.

The whole point of the Joi subplot was to yet again bring up the debate as is necessary in the Bladerunner story as to what makes someone human. It could be said that through K's feelings to his Joi she was able to become self aware, and truly love him back. We'll never know though, ana's acting during her death scene was superb though. That desperate "I love you" was great.

You are correct. Here's a (you)

but she was not his waifu

why do you nerds only like films in a fantasy or sci fi setting?

I think in that scene he realises Joi never truely loved him or wanted to be real, the point of the Joi programming is to adapt to the needs of the user. K wanted to be the chosen one , K wanted to be more then a replicant. And so the Joi program did it's job and gave him what he wanted to see in her.

Because most films based in a real setting are either boring as shit or rife with pointless pandering/degeneracy with no substance at all.

>you look like a good joe

what did she mean by this?

One of her preprogrammed lines is "You look like a good Joe" ironically enough because of this K told Deckard his real name was Joe

we also like movies about the CIA and autists that Drive.

Let's see your film.

Why did his Joi suggest the name Joe? Why did she say that’s what (his mother, Rachel) would’ve named him?

dictionary.com/browse/good-joe

Why do you make gross generalizations from a single post by a single anonymous user on a Taiwanese knitting board?

you have the mind of a child

Good Joe is a saying. it basically means he looks like a good person. She said that because she's programmed to associate the word Joe with kindness or being good hearted

While Blade Runner 2049 was my favorite film of 2017, I think Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri had a more emotionally impacting scene.

Haha, okay. I'll bite. I have the mind of a child yep. Let's see, movies based in a modern setting released in 2017. Oh yeah, Jumanji was some deep shit bro. I totally see where you're coming from. Dunkirk was watered down trash that I had very high hopes for, The Post suffered from the same bland, watered down affliction with little to no decent cinematography to boot. What other movies are you referring to? Get out? Baywatch? you're literally autistic senpai.

Brainlet here. Was it explained at one point why K./Joe had the memories of Deckart's and Rachel's daughter? Did she design the memories this way because she was hoping a Blade Runner might investigate his own/ her past and she might find out more about herself this way? Was this her plan all along or did she just add a few of her own memories to make the design better, like she said?
Could it be that she and K. are even more connected than we think at first glimpse? She was desining a memory featuring snow in the last scene when Deckart enters and K.'s last impressions should exactly be the same: snowflakes. Did we maybe witness not a movie at all but just a memory design in the making?

we'll have to see in the next movie.

Fellas, I just want a cute gf with insect black eyes.

Did anyone else hate that scene with that cult more human than human shit? Its the only scene I don’t like.

You’re so sure.

Honestly, the whole subplot about Joi was the one that came closest to falling flat for me. Not because it was ill conceived or badly executed but because it's pretty much just a simplified version of Her.

>Was it explained at one point why K./Joe had the memories of Deckart's and Rachel's daughter?
Total coincedence by Ana putting her real memory into him. "Every artist put's a little bit of themself in their work". This is basically spoonfed to you with the later flashbacks. It's the insatiable need of every artist and it's even greater in her case because she's locked in a bubble and wants put more of herself out into the world..
Also she has to make original memories for millions of replicants based only on her 8 years of actual real life, ofcourse some of her real life will slip here and there.
And since K is a detective after all it makes sense for him to follow it through.
>Did she design the memories this way because she was hoping a Blade Runner might investigate his own/ her past and she might find out more about herself this way?
Not really, maybe subconsciously because you could say that she empathizes with replicants, but it's more about the fact that she only lived 8 years outside and can only create so many fake memories.
> Was this her plan all along or did she just add a few of her own memories to make the design better, like she said?
Nope, she has no "great agenda" or anything like that

And I doubt that there any supernatural "connection" you imply between Ana and K, but they sure are connected by the fact that K has the same memories as her, which make them operate on a similar level of thinking

It's funny how BR2049 made a ten times more genuinely emotionally investing romantic story in just a side story of the film compared to Her where that's the entire film.
This is most evident in that exact prostitute scene in Her which is entirely forgettable and comes out completely flat, while in BR2049 it's one of the best scenes of the entire film.

One of the best sequels ever made. There's alot of meaning to draw from this movie.
A clever metafiction that tells the story in a way so people can form their own meaning of this movie.

lold at reddit ford

Thanks for taking your time and discussing this stuff with me.

...

How do you know all this? How do you know she’s only lived 8 years outside? She’s been sub-contracted by Wallace for that long?

Also thanks for answering my other questions.

...

This will be looked back on as one of the best movies ever, certainly in the sci-fi/cyberpunk genre

jared sucked the life out of his scenes and his character was badly written. in the original Blade Runner, you had Tyrell which was a character with more dimensions. You could feel sorry for him when he was killed.

otherwise the movie was really good

>How do you know all this? How do you know she’s only lived 8 years outside?
She literally says that in the film when K asks about her work

I used to know these Cambodian girls. In their language, being a "good joe" is synonymous with being naive and stupid and they have nothing but contempt for people like that.

>This is basically spoonfed to you with the later flashbacks.
Actually it's K's thoughts that were projected to us. There is no real explanation to why she put it here.
K is meant to be an unreliable character and we see the movie from his point of view, as well as from Luv's and Deckard's POV. The poem from Pale Fire has a meaning to it because it came from a poem that was told from an unreliable character. Pale Fire is a meta fiction that is meant to have open interpretations.

the killing of a sacred deer, phantom thread and good time are some films from 2017 i really liked. you have the intellectual level of a 14 year old.

I liked the sequence ending with finding the wooden horse far more

I'll agree with you on Sacred deer it was pure kino. But you have some big balls saying I have the intellectual level of a 14 year old when you say that phantom thread was good. Also you talk like a literal redditor.

Watch more films

Tell me a more emotionally impacting scene of 2017 in any other film

user, Her and Ex Machina and BR2049 won't be the first or last movies about AI waifus.

I haven't seen them, but before that there was Cherry 2000 (1987), and Simone (2002). Not to mention Westworld (1973), arguably.

The real question is...

Did she really love him?

phantom thread was my 4th favorite movie of 2017. i think best picture will be between three billboards and phantom thread, and i think three billboards will win.

There's no doubt she loved him, it's literally what she's programmed to do. The only question is is that love "real" or worthy?
I would argue that to K it is absolutely real yes, and that's the only thing that matters