Nope. In 2010 when he was making TCW George explicitly said the dark side is a negative and bad aspect of the force. It's inevitable and you can't get rid of it, but it isn't something where you need 50% dark (selfish, hateful, suffering, hint hint all that shit he explicitly shows in the PT and TCW) and 50% light. You need to accept your dark side but you should strive to stay mostly in the light. youtube.com/watch?v=68dvgRT3Kx8
Jordan Perry
Ayo... So you be sayin...
Ayden Hill
WE KINGZ AND SHIT
Aiden Robinson
And within the last 2 years he talked about selfishness vs selfishness and you can't have too much of either
Brandon Gomez
*SMACKS LIPS* SO YOU BE SAYIN' *BLOWS BUBBLES* WE WUZ *SMILES* AY HOL UP *LICKS LIPS* SO WE WUZ *DRINKS WITH A STRAW* ITHORIANS AN SHIEET?!!!!
Colton Phillips
You do need 50% of each
To be purely balanced
"First comes the day Then comes the night. After the darkness Shines through the light. The difference, they say, Is only made right By the resolving of gray Through refined Jedi sight."
It's going to be gray force wielders using Jedi wisdom and practices. The old ways will guide them, but changed and refined so that the dark side is no longer ignored. The dark side is just as precious as the light.
Cooper Bennett
What's that lone mouth? Are you trying to say something?
Ian Hall
What did they mean by this?
Matthew Thompson
I get it, it's a cycle Light/dark/light/dark over and over again and the only way to stop it is gray with Jedi ways
Ethan Bailey
>tfw i felt impressed by this when I saw it and came out thinking "wow it was so real" >looking at this, I just feel embarrassed, both for myself, and for JJ
Nathaniel Flores
...
Caleb Nelson
Best Inky coming through
Lincoln Sanders
Favorite era? It might be my age but I prefer PT over OT because I love the Clone Wars stuff, Clonetroopers, different Jedi, etc
Dylan Green
Aren't those things supposed to hold basically an entire army? Why did they only deploy a few squads in that arc?
Tyler Price
aliens only no human
Oliver Rivera
It's a low quality webm of a giant puppet, what do you expect?
Dylan Davis
Man the Inquisitors were such a waste
Zachary Gray
it does look real tho
The propwork is the only good part of TFA
Joshua Smith
a race of pedos
Joseph Ward
As an era, I think you'd be hard pressed to convince me that the PT isn't the best era.
Even if you prefer some OT aesthetics, or the movies, the PT is literally just the Galaxy at its most rich and vibrant, the tipping point where all the biggest stories take place. TCW is pretty representative of the huge variety in storytelling that can come from the era.
Fall of society and rise of an Empire. The Mandalorian Civil Wars. Galactic war an on unprecedented scale.
The OT era is more gloomy, with the Empire always looming, and the stories usually just revolve around bursts of hope in a bleak Galaxy.
ST era is just the OT era but shinies, until based Rian and Pablo and even Filoni salvage it.
Carter Collins
That's Finn, the main character.
Owen Peterson
Ezra was space legal. Also, delet this.
Christopher Turner
kek
Grayson Cooper
I dont know about that user.. Someone post the webm of the shitty bird.
Jonathan Turner
Why though? Again, why? And don't evade the question. Actually answer why people need to use the Dark Side. Evidence has been given for why the Light with acknowledgment of some darkness without using the latter is good in canon. So why the claim using evidence that only appeared in a movie novelization?
Sebastian Lewis
I always loved the bounty hunters over the Jedi, do it for the money.
Connor Lee
The Steelpecker? I liked him too. You just hate it because Sup Forums said so.
James Adams
ST is a return to the times before the PT era's 1000 year Republic. Everything is just happening at a much faster pace, but the FO is pretty much like a Sith fleet attacking the Old Republic.
Nolan King
>And don't evade the question You had the question repeatedly answered for you like 100 times last thread, dude.
Balance of the Force is good, remember? So how could an individual being balanced possibly be a bad thing?
Asher Young
get cuck over by a teenage Asian
yellow fever is stronger with him
Lucas Phillips
...
William Anderson
Think they'll hook up before the end?
They've had any romantic interest be completely one-sided on Ezra's part and only show up in like, what...3 episodes?
Noah Miller
when fan art becomes real
Xavier Cooper
F-fine Snoke I'll eat your pepperoni pizza...
Josiah Allen
>disliking something from TFA means I am from Sup Forums You fucking what now? Don't relate me to those retards
The bird looks dumb, that's just what I believe based on what I see. Rathtars are shite too, which adds insult to injury if you ask me.
JJ's big "practical effects are back!" marketing campaign looks silly when the most prominent puppets looked like ass, and the biggest creature spotlight in the movie is a CGI spaghetti monster.
There are things I liked about TFA, that I talk about if they come up in discussion. But the discussion at hand is TFA's creatures and puppets, and I just happen to think they are shitty and only praised on the merit of being practical, because that somehow gives them a free pass now.
Camden Butler
Hah, yellow fever for the ACTUAL YELLOW waifu. Sabine was the one getting cucked.
Charles Cruz
Where in the actual evidence in canon? You have not answered with anything other than Reddit tier speculation and an interpretation from a movie novelization of dubious canonicity. Answer the question and this time don't evade or play cute.
Jaxson Sullivan
Interesting idea.
I think this was originally supposed to be more prominent.
I read that some of the original concepts of the ST era were themed around a Medeival aesthetic. I read that Planets will be entirely self-governed without a Senate, causing much of the Galaxy to degenerate into factions.
The only remnants of these concepts seem to be The Knights of Ren (which seem to have been sidelined), Phasma's armor, and Maz Kanata's Castle.
Adrian Kelly
>told not to evade the question >continues to evade the question
Joshua Lee
...
Jack Gomez
TFA is garbage.
Ayden Cruz
>watching cuck porn >notice pic related on the girl
Disgusting. I always knew the Rebel Alliance was full of whores.
Luis Hill
>not Profunditendies edition shaking my damn head to be desu
Michael Peterson
...
Cameron Scott
your green as Oola butt
Zachary Bennett
This. In all fairness the puppets and costumes were bad. And I actually think the CG for Maz was good.
Connor Fisher
...
Tyler Carter
>green wat
Landon Parker
>>watching cuck porn
Liam Reed
>of dubious canonicity It's 100% canon officially and has been for a long time. Snoke's interested in Kylo due to his duality in the Force.
And you have further evidence with Bendu showing you can use the dark side without corrupting yourself. That alone should have alarm bells going off >Ohhhhh Yoda was wrong...you CAN use the Dark Side without it corrupting and dominating you
Then the Ahsoka and Bendu meeting that Filoni spoke about and how she was going experience "change" while being left alone in Sith ruins.
Then you have this
"First comes the day Then comes the night. After the darkness Shines through the light. The difference, they say, Is only made right By the resolving of gray Through refined Jedi sight."
They're setting us up for the wisdom of balance in people and not just the Force spectrum.
Asher Peterson
I don't really like Maz's design or character, but she didn't take me out of the movie.
Although to be fair, I have a high tolerance for special effects. I always see people claim CGI stuff in the prequels takes them out of the movie, but thats never been the case for me.
The problem with the pig thing, and the bird, is that they are shoved front and center of the shots so that JJ could nudge the audience member beside him with a knowing wink and smile.
The Luggabeast on the other hand wasn't so bad. I liked that thing. I like the Teedo too, more than Jawa's. So not ALL the practical creatures in TFA were obnoxious and forced.
Tyler Butler
I honestly don't remember Finn doing anything of note in the entirety of TFA beyond sweating a lot and looking overwhelmed and scared of everything.
Joshua Flores
clearly the ISB is very dedicated to identifying all members of the rebel alliance.
Brayden Flores
The major prophecy that was strung out across SIX MOVIES is about the balance of the Force and restoring it.
Why is this so hard for you to understand?
Balance of the Force = Good
And you have to use the dark side to achieve that
Jace Diaz
And then Kylo falls over when his lightsaber immediately digs into the floor.
Jose Turner
This is what your Imperial tax credits are going to guys. ISB agents jacking off to cuck porn.
Samuel Johnson
The balance doesn't literally mean 50% good 50% bad.
The good side of the force IS the balance. The bad side of the force, in George's own terminology, is a cancer that is detrimental to the balance.
Jonathan Scott
>Balance of the Force = Good You're right, we all see it, and that's what we've been saying, a healthy body is one with out metastisizing cancer in it, balance is good when people aren't using the EVIL dark side to commit EVIL acts.
And you're still evading the question - define how evil = good.
Henry Adams
Nah, as we've seen in the series they work like real swords. So he'd have to put some pressure on it.
Just like we saw when they got impaled into objects/people, they stayed there and didn't move. The electromagnetic field around it acts like a physical barrier that has to be broken/squashed with enough physical force
Dylan Ortiz
I take that back. still a pedo
Colton Turner
Did you actually read the novel and all the parts in it that that aren't in the movie? Remember, the movie comes first. Meanwhile, the Bench was also shown as a somewhat selfish jerk who stood on the sidelines as evil grew stronger until prodded.
Yoda was right. Like sees what he's doing and rejects its temptations.
Again, give me proper canon evidence and none of your speculation. Or is that too much for you to handle?
Kevin Hughes
>imperialfags are cucks
knew it
Henry Campbell
This is the only kind of Ezra/Sabine I'll accept
Probably not
Jack Bennett
Bendu, not bench
Also, dont evade the question.
Hudson Fisher
Killing people to save lives is still killing and still wrong yet it's also good
The dark side isn't pure evil, it's part of nature. Not everything the light practitioners have done is good either, we've seen them cause harm before when trying to do good.
A gray Jedi isn't going to go around raping babies you dummy if that's what you think it means to use the dark side.
Isaiah Ward
>Yoda was right. It's canon he was wrong which is most likely due to his lack of education on the dark side.
Bendu is all the evidence we need. He's a straight up canon dark side user that isn't corrupted by it.
John Adams
Killing people isn't an inherently dark side or evil act. We're not talking about that. Explain to me how outright selfish and malicious intent in one's actions is a good thing in any belief system ever. Not even Satanists are that disingenuous.
John Reed
this will happen when?
Dominic Lee
Bendu is meant to be bad. He's given every chance to save the Rebellion but refuses until the Empire is a risk to him at which point he's immediately killed.
Noah Hill
You're backwards about this whole thing.
You actually think in order to use the dark side you have to do bad things and that's simply not true.
YOU HAVE SEEN THIS, whenever you saw Darksiders just doing random shit like moving things they were using the dark side of the Force.
OH NO HE MOVED THAT POT
HE MOVED IN A "EVIL" WAY
Jose Hall
Bendu is a selfish prick. For all his talk, he was just a loner with a me first attitude, albeit one who could be goaded. Deal with it.
Killing is still evil. A necessary evil sometimes,but still evil. It's when you start calling it good that you go over the edge.
Brody Bailey
Saying Bendu is bad is like saying Luke raped Sabine, it just isn't true.
Ryder Diaz
>Is that in her ass? >Right in her ass. >...Rebel scum.
Bentley Moore
I like how this retard you're replying to keeps going "b-b-but muh bendu!" while conveniently ignoring the fact that he's constantly a total fucking selfish asshole that murders indiscriminately and damn near kills the good guys for the sole reason they annoyed him. "Not corrupted" my ass, this Diogenes motherfucker ought to be stabbed. Fortunately Thrawnlexander did that with his ATATs.
Xavier Reed
Moving objects to throw at people or choke them is pretty dang evil in the context they appeared.
Hunter Ortiz
>Outright disagreeing with and saying lucasfilm storygroup is wrong
He was so clear and in the middle of the road that he was destroying both factions out of sheer neutrality and yet you can still spin your lies of stupidity and retardation to try and say he's evil, wow
Isaac Rivera
Well, I didn't like the asshole eyes but the CG was good at least, unlike Snoke. But like you said, they shoved them into the screen which made them look even worse. It would've been fine if they had them in the distance. The only ones that looked bad to me was the bird, pig and the big guy sitting with a girl at the castle.
Jace Sullivan
PT but I'm a sucker for lots of Jedi
Lincoln Powell
Except they use it all the time for things that don't involve any kind of malicious intent.
Daniel Davis
Using the Force to levitate an object when you could just pick it up and move it is one of the Seven Deadly Sins: Sloth. So yes, it is an evil way, with malice aforethought. Anakin himself did this in AOTC when he showed off his pear-cutting force powers.
Thomas Bennett
>watching porn
user...
Carson Reyes
Agreed for all of the same reasons: I used to be down of the PT but now I can separate my movie hate from the era itself. The era was diverse and even after TCW I think still has a lot to explore about individual Jedi, Clonetroopers, other planets, etc
Nathaniel Wright
That's called playing Devil's Advocate, you were already taking an idiotic view claiming he was good and balanced when its shown quite clearly that 50% light and 50% dark side is bad.
Michael Peterson
liking the rebels or Imperial not knowing the black sun is the only true heroes
Landon Diaz
Actually that's two Deadly Sins, sloth and pride. Three if you count lust, because Anakin was just trying to get in her pussy.
Cameron Barnes
That isn't neutral at all. When you kill people for the selfish reason of them bugging you, that's evil. Is this an elaborate troll on your part, or are you sincerely unable to understand what everyone keeps explaining to you. Every time, you evade the question and speculate with little actual evidence of any. Don't evade the question and this time provide proper sources without resorting to lies and insults.
Blake Reed
It was wrong because he was using it as a parlor trick for entertainment, that's what was wrong about it, not the fact he was using it to lift the fruit.
You see them use the Force for similar feats in various canon works when it's not as a parlor trick like obtaining a tool or some such.
Jaxon Jackson
To be a kid again, man. Back when you could care less about all this bullshit and just like it because it's cool.
Fellow Black Sun fan, btw.
Sebastian Ortiz
Dave Filoni himself said Bendu is an asshole.
Brayden Price
>when its shown quite clearly that 50% light and 50% dark side is bad. No, it's not. It's literally something children understand, wow
He didn't do it because they were bugging him, rewatch the episode dipshit
Caleb Thomas
Actually because it's mentioned numerous times you have to tap into your ANGER to use dark side force abilities, that makes 4 out of 7 deadly sins now: WRATH. The very act of using the dark side is literally the biggest sin of all. Lucas pottery at it again.
Hunter Thomas
Well there was a planetary blockade before. Budget reasons too.
Charles Diaz
>It's literally something children understand >you still can't understand it after having it explained to you for the past 4 hours what does that say about you, that children can get this while you can't
Josiah Hall
>you evade the question I've never seen him evade it once and I've watched this all day. What is with you? Is this what you do to people in person? You just keep saying that over and over no matter how stupidit makes you look? I'm surprised you haven't been beaten to death. Please don't evade the questions.
Ethan Diaz
We have provided arguments and sources. You have provided speculation, headcanon, abject misunderstanding of basic logical concepts, and hearsay.
Levi Morgan
back when the black sun had a small empire under the new republic.