Fullmetal Alchemist

only one of them is a woman
which one is it?

the one in the middle

Lust
Envy was always cuter regardless

Clearly the one with a vagina in her chest.

Lust

Are you really asking this on Sup Forums?

Fuck this yellow-washed piece of shit movie

It doesn't matter. I'd fug them all

The more important question is, are there nudes of the actress who played Lust?

The one on the left is a boy.

Where THE FUCK is Winry?

Isn't Lust suppose to be Middle Eastern or something?

Middle is hot

Lust is not meant to be Ishvalan, no

Even better desu

They should have gotten white actors, they're clearly European in the anime

Isn't FMA supposed to be set in some late 19th century pseudo-Europe?

Nah Japanese people don't give a shit about stuff like that.

I couldn't even finish this shit because its so dishonest and completely shits on the show.
First of all, the show was definitely supposed to be based in Europe and all the characters are white. Im not trying to racebait but its clearly pretty integral to the plot, so having japs play the characters felt so off it really ruined the mood.
Also what the fuck was with Edwards character, from his hair to his shitty costume, he just looks like some retard cosplaying. The only praise I'll sing for the costumes is Al, he actually looks pretty faithful and actually not shit.
Anime fight scenes DO NOT translate well to live action, I'm surprised directors haven't caught on to this.
The pacing can kind of be excused since theyre fitting a whole show into a 2hr movie but I still felt like it was executed poorly.
Overall I genuinely think the Death Note adaptation was better than this junk.

I'm saying it should have just been an English show.

Why did they get Markiplier to play Hughes???

I think she was in the first anime. Envy shapeshifts so gender doesn't matter as much.

Her actress was god damn terrible.

The story is written by a woman so she thought it's cute to effeminate men

I get what you are saying and I'm saying the Japanese who made the film. Don't care about stuff like that. The movie was made by Japanese for Japanese. They aren't going to fill it full of white people. The fact that Netflix wants it for their weeb audience probably wasn't even a thought when they made the film.

The only reason it's so stupid that they used all Japanese actors is because ethnic/racial differences and conflicts are absolutely key to the entire plot. It would be like making American History X with all white people, or Mississippi Burning with all black people.

Also just the fact that everybody bitches about white washing constantly but nobody gives a shit of literally any other race does the same thing. It's retarded and hypocritical.

You think you can make a watchable movie by switching all characters with white people?
No. They were Japanese people given European names. The way they talk, think, joke and laugh is all Japanese. You can't have a white guy calling an empty armor his bro. It just doesn't work. White people dont think like that. Best let japs do all the awkward shits

>It's retarded and hypocritical.
DELET!
>
.

Stop making sense. Bad goy.

>The only reason it's so stupid that they used all Japanese actors is because ethnic/racial differences and conflicts are absolutely key to the entire plot.

It's not really. The plot is about an an immortal being sacrificing people human lives to kill God. Neither the anime or the manga really goes out into any racial conflict expect for Scar. Which isn't really that major of a conflict if you include all of the story.

> It's retarded and hypocritical.

The Japanese people didn't care about white washing in ghost in the shell because they are OK with doing it in their own country. The Japanese expect every country to adapt the story for their country. If Africa made a FMA movie. The Japanese would be OK with it being filled with Africans. It was only SJW Americans who cared.

>It's not really.
t. brainlet

Watch the anime or manga. You guys are pretending like it's the anime version of menace to society. Outside of Scar and the war. It doesn't really go into other characters race. Hell Scars storyline isn't even half of the story.

He's right you cuck, the Japanese have the right attitude by ignoring the original races of the story and the West should follow with a black Achilles, Indian king Arthur, Mexican Washington

You're an idiot. The Ishvalan war is a huge, multi-faceted element of the story. The same goes for Xing and the relationship between them and Amestris, as well as their different use of alchemy. Plus the culture of Amestris is very heavily European. Why would Japanese call their leader fuhrer?

>pls be sarcasm

Japanese people still go to theater and watch shots like Hamlet or Three Mustkeers. They watch those shits played by Japanese actors saying Japanese lines. So they are ok with Japanese people being called Edowado.

This.
Racial issues are interwoven throughout all aspects of the story. Failure to see that shows a serious lack of depth in one's comprehension.

This.

Which shouldn't surprise you since we're talking about anime. Weebs aren't known for their intellectual sophistication, if you catch my drift.

> The Ishvalan war is a huge, multi-faceted element of the story

The Ishvalan war has nothing to do with race.It was discovered that the Ishval War, along with all of Amestris' past military conflicts, was used to create the massive bloodshed needed for the Nationwide Transmutation Circle.

>The same goes for Xing and the relationship between them and Amestris, as well as their different use of alchemy. Plus the culture of Amestris is very heavily European. Why would Japanese call their leader fuhrer?

What do you think you are arguing with this sentence? The only connect Xing has in the story is that Ling Yao and their alchemy, There isn't some deep hard-hitting story between the nations.

All explain it then. Like I said the Ishvalan wasn't about race.

Oh okay, so you are just retarded. My bad.

Obviously not ham hands on the right. Something tells me left is the trap.

only in the shitty first anime

The one on the left played Nishi in Gantz and Armin in Attack on Titan.

this movie was so shit

unironically worse than DBZ evolution

Lust was pretty we done. She was all the right kinds of evil and sexy.

Yes she is, you retard. She was the former girlfriend of Scar’s brother.

Another fine fma thread.

> They pitched CGI Alphonse
> That´s technically CGI Alphonse

The irony on trying to convince Alphonse he has a real body somewhere when they made even his human self CGI

So is it so terrible it's funny, or just plain terrible?

FMA:Brotherhood is a god tier anime for me

Blondie

Mexican Washington would be kino and you know it

that's 03 not botherhood/manga

*blocks your path*

How bad is this movie?

Honestly I'm surprised comparatively how manly envy is in this.

...

How bad is the english dub of Brotherhood? I want to rewatch it but I can't fund any torrents with subs and I don't want to stream.

;_;

Fuck off, subfag

>shitty

I think you mean brotherhood

Inferior to the first version, for sure. They ruined Als voice

>preferring first version over second
How can you have this shit of taste?

Brotherhood is objectively better than vanilla FMA. It´s time you accept that.

The one with the vagina?

>tfw the movie was pretty good
I was happy with it.