so which one?
So which one?
Levi Collins
Other urls found in this thread:
Jaxson Stewart
Newt is awful and ruins the film for me, alien is pretty consistently great throughout
Evan Baker
how could you not love this CUTIE
Nicholas Anderson
>trying to campare films from different genres
I shiggydigeridoo
David Clark
Alien is vastly superior to Aliens in every way
Jayden Gutierrez
Apples to oranges. Just enjoy them both and appreciate that the sequel is an attempt to do something different and exciting rather than clone the original and fail.
Landon Baker
Given that there are several versions of both films, here are my thoughts:
Alien (Workprint) version is best (extra 35 minutes but slows pacing)
Aliens (Theatrical) is best, special edition slows the pacing and has a lot of unnecessary scenes added.
Josiah Russell
Aliens.
Adrian Sullivan
Easton Torres
why not both? People on Sup Forums invent reasons to hate Aliens all the time, but the fact of it is that they are both excellent movies and near the top of the sci-fi heap.
Angel Cruz
Alien>Aliens
T1>T2
Adam Turner
Aliens of course. Only insecure cucks say Alien because they've been conditioned to.
Levi White
Alien because it looks as good as it did when it was released and didn't have horrible cliche characters in it.
Newt is the entire reason Aliens holds up to Alien and stomps other action films.
Dominic Adams
>how dare you compare different things
>you should only compare two exact same things
Hudson Allen
Alien > Alien 3: Assembly cut > Aliens > Alien 3 > AvP > Alien 4 > Prometheus > Alien: Covenant > AvP2
Dominic Fisher
Alien. Aliens is closer to Prometheus and Alien 3 than Alien.
Colton Jones
>compare
Yeah, that would involve actually comparing the two films, discussing the differences, different areas of strength, or weakness, etc.
Not just saying THIS ONE IS BETTER or THAT ONE IS BETTER. That is ranking, not comparing, and ranking inherently becomes subjective and thus pointless. Knawmsayin'?
Jace Perry
2 different genres, both are great.
Ian Cooper
Sup Forums has taught me that the most innocent girl is a whore, so away with this demon!
Jordan Wilson
It depends on which genre you prefer
Nicholas Garcia
Gavin Cruz
A sci-fi cult classic or an average vidya tier action flick? Really makes you think.
Nathaniel Cook
Aliens is better because its timeless
Alien was great because it was the first of its kind but today its just another slasher movie in space
Logan Cruz
Alien by far
Sebastian Ortiz
exact opposite actually. Aliens has been reconstituted and ripped off about a million times more than Alien. every grunts in space story made after Aliens owes a debt to it.
what Alien achieves is way more singular. few things are willing to be that stark, weird, brutal, etc. etc.
Connor Barnes
alien. i never liked aliens that much
Aiden Powell
Aliens. Literally no contest.
Jaxson Hughes
3
Aiden Rivera
this one
Wyatt Morgan
...
Matthew Howard
They're both good enough that preferring either is a respectable choice.
Personally prefer Alien though
Alexander King
nah
Cooper Stewart
I used to think Aliens, user. But that was when I was, like, 12. Plus, Aliens has aged terribly.
Alien all the way.
Incidentally, saw Alien3 the other day...it's a lot better than I imagined it; but the CG alien at the end is fucking terrible!
Ayden Allen
Bitch why can't fruit be compared?
Benjamin Roberts
because opinions
Evan Thomas
RIPLEEEEEYYYYYYYYY
Fuck that kid.
William Flores
>the sequel is an attempt to do something different
But it's not? It takes its time to put the protagonist in the same situation as in the first movie. And it's so fucking full of genre clichés, you could make a movie and call it "Cliché (2018)". But of course, everyone would say you rip off Aliens.
>Apples to oranges.
Are you a woman or something? Away with that crap.
Ethan Sanchez
Both are great. For me its Aliens. It held up a little better, Alien looks really dated for me today.
Julian Cox
If not for Newt the film would have been a handful of space marines btfoing dozens of aliens. Would have been a long second act.