Which was the best of the Trilogy Sup Forums and why?
Hobbit posters need not apply
Which was the best of the Trilogy Sup Forums and why?
Jackson Adams
Liam Perez
Followship > Two Towers > Return of the Kings
Sebastian Jackson
>contrarian
James Evans
>and why
why is it the best one?
Alexander Nelson
>Followship
Henry Robinson
TT > FotR = RotK
Robert Wright
Fellowship, theatrical version. To be exact
Chase Anderson
Fellowship Extended>TT theatrical>ROTK theatrical>TT extended>ROTK extended
Brandon Reed
this
Alexander Martinez
Fellowship. A great introduction to the world of middle earth and the profound beings which reside in the world. Each movie captures the scope of the story exceptionally well and fellowship set the bar high for the other movies and fantasy in general. It's difficult to separate the films from each other as they build on one another seamlessly.
Colton Bennett
Ah, a buzzword. The hallmark of those without a thought of their own.
Christian Richardson
ROTK for me bc Gondor forever
Aiden Robinson
Hear hear!
Aiden Anderson
this is a good answer ty user
Brayden Adams
FPBP
Jack Nguyen
Correct. Personally it'd be
>FotR > TT = RotK
for me, but Fellowship is definitely the best of the three.
Lincoln Campbell
What was his fucking problem?
Cameron Price
With which movies is theatrical>extended true?
Dominic Jackson
The one that won every oscar
Jaxon Torres
The only answer is, all of them were perfect. No one is over from another one!
Liam Rogers
imho none, but the extended version of fellowship probably adds the least. The scenes it adds are nice though. Two Towers scenes with Boromir and Faramir are almost essential and its criminal they got cut from the theatrical release. I can't watch theatrical RotK anymore because I get way too triggered by the lack of Mouth of Sauron and Aragorn talking shit to Sauron through the Palantir
Aiden Nelson
how are boromir and faramir scenes essential and the concerning hobbits prologue/extended council scenes not
Tyler Parker
Correct.
Colton Smith
All three.
Ayden Reed
The entirel trilogy is almost equal but fellowship edges it out because of the whole fellowship being together, gandalf give advice to frodo etc was heartwarming.
None.
Wyatt Martinez
Two Towers, that Rohan theme is kino
Benjamin Ward
Sauron mostly.
Daniel White
Fellowship
This answer was good.
Carson Lee
The moment when swells up and then just the one violin plays the main part over the wide shot of Edoras gives me goosebumps every time.
The charge out of Helms Deep and the coming of Gandalf are great moments too.
I just wish Faramir didn't get toned down from the book. The whole reason he had the visions before Boromir was because he was more suited to be in the company of the ring but Jackson thought it silly that he wouldn't be tempted by it when he met Frodo.
Two Towers even has the old school memes going for it with PO-TAY-TOES and They're Taking The Hobbits To Isengard.
Landon Hughes
Fellowship is better storywise, but I still think RoK is a better movie. The pacing of the story in Fellowship makes it boring to rewatch.
Chase King
Fellowship > Return > Towers
Evan Price
Fellowship because Galadriel.
Justin Taylor
Fellowship.
It has all the best things.
Comfy shire, characters all interact, premise setup, action, music
Julian Gonzalez
Fellowship stands on its own more, TT and ROTK blend in together for me, not that it's a bad thing.
Ryan Martin
People who like TT the most, what is it about it you enjoy it more than the others?
Samuel Murphy
probably helm's deep
Asher Garcia
FOTR is the most cinematographic
ROTK got most memorable moments
TTT is most campy and comfy
Xavier Wood
FoTR>RoTK>TT
Although Helms Deep was the best battle of the trilogy.
Jackson Cruz
FOTR = TT = ROTK
fixed it u retarded fucks
all extended
Easton Carter
See Add onto that the hottest woman in the series, Eowyn.