Loeb is a top 5 Batman writer ever right?

Loeb is a top 5 Batman writer ever right?

No, the top 5 is

>Morrison
>O''Neil
>Miller
>Moore
>Either Brubaker or Snyder, but probably the former

>no Grant
>ever considering Brubaker or Snyder
Get a load of this pleb.

Before he went insane sure.

Top 15 maybe but not top 5

>O'Neil
>Dixon
>Frank Miller
>Gardner Fox
>Rucka

Before Sam Loeb died, sure. Then his works became 2 edgy 4 me. He literally killed the best Marvel alternative universe because his son died.

1. Greg Rucka
2. Paul Dini
3. Frank Miller
4. Jeph Loeb
5. Chuck Dixon

>no grant
What do you think Grant's last name is, user?

No you horrendous plebeian, Loeb isn't anywhere close to the top five. He gets away with awful stories because they're carried by great artists.
My five? In no particular order...
>BILL FINGER
>FRANK MILLER
>CHUCK DIXON
>ALAN GRANT
>DENNY O'NEIL

Are you retarded?

>no Grant
>Get a load of this pleb.

He means Alan Grant

YOU SHOULD ALL BE DISGUSTED WITH YOURSELVES

ALAN
GRANT
REEEEEE

Alan Grant you fucking idiots. Jesus fucking Christ.

I hope we've been b8'd but you can never overestimate the taste of Sup Forums

>Morrison
opinion discarded

I love RIP and pretty much his entire run, but I don't think he deserves a spot in the top five considering his work is largely built off of every previous run on Batman

>I have no idea how Ultimatum came to be the post

Somebody said something about Loeb.

I would rather believe that somebody doesnt know Grant Morrison's full name than that somebody thinks that Alan Grant is a good writer.

Wow, just... fucking wow. Morrisonfags, everybody.

>Miller
>Moore
>Either Brubaker or Snyder
>Not Adams
>Not Byrne
>Even Loeb is a better choice than those
Hmm.....

What does that have to do with anything? Every run of Spidey up to OMD builds on what came before, that doesn't make any of them less good.

I like his art, but Neal Adams can't even write a shopping list.
His stories are memorable for precisely all the wrong reasons
>Byrne
Is this a fuckin joke?

I mean that Morrison's work is meta as fuck, idiot. A love letter to the character and his silver age insanity.
There's no Spidey run like it. Zur-En-Arrh, Lord Death Man, etc.

>Moore
Are you serious?

And Loeb was originally going to write an X-Men and ultimate crossover until Bendis and Millar said to make it bigger

Alan Grant was fucking shit and carried by Wagner and Breyfogle. His run dried up when Wagner left. Nobody would even care about Grant if thousands of casuals didn't flock to Tec because of the movie. He was the Snyder of his day.