Is he supposed to be shit?

Is he supposed to be shit?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=97IfPfjSaDg
youtube.com/watch?v=cbpuzYtp43Q
desuarchive.org/trash/thread/12610539/
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

At writing? Hard yes.

he really need to have a writer for sure, his jokes and pacing never really hits and it feels like he's just imitating things he's seen and hoping it's funny.
He's like a Legendary Frog except with much better animation.

Yes that is pretty much what he's going for and it gets the attention of Fuck wits like you OP.

>hurrr im shit ironically!
>if you say im shit then that means i win hurr

Be honest, you came from the /trash/ thread, didn't you?

I never like anything he does. He seems nice but everything is just so lame. I like Isabelle Ruins Everything though.

Although actually his delivery of his lines was really bad but Isabelle's voice actor was great.

I think Isabelle Ruins Everything proved that he can make a cute, funny cartoon without forcing edginess into every second.

Really bad? Come one, I think you just don't like his voice. He's not a terrible actor.

I should correct myself. I didn't like how he had Isabelle in every sentence, like "Oh Isabelle... Isabelle Isabelle Isabelle... Oh, Isabelle, Oh Isabelle" etc. he's an alright voice actor.

I just want to fuck the T.V. robot.

his new cuphead cartoon isn't edgy, it's pure 90s humor

we all do

No I think its shit on purpose.

tumblr thinks so and a part of twitter. I think he is a handsome boy personally.

would fuck~

>GOOFY EXAGGERATED FACES XD

Dude sucks john k's dick too much in his animations.

I honestly did compare his style as a derivative of K's. Good thing I must have something right.

I always pretend these threads are about Bendis, reads roughly the same

Put too many points into animation and not enough humor. He's easily one of the big dick animators like Harry but his stuff just isn't funny.

Sometimes he tries his darndest to be edgy and controversial, but I've seen enough of his heartwarming stuff that it just doesn't work.

His funniest joke ever probably was in the Winter Incident.

Isn't this the guy who made Isabelle from Animal Crossing fappable?

GET OUT OF HERE MAX

Trivia: There is nothing bad about his writing, it just isn't your generic flow of humor.

I got into him long before he kinda tried to be super edgy. Back with stuff like Joan and Mark and Adam Android or Skunk Girl. In all honesty he's made a lot of great stuff. Jerry's still one of my favorite flash cartoon series.

I get Ren and stimpy vibes from it
Like John K. wrote it

He's edgy? In what way?
I feel like the word "edgy" gets thrown around a little too much...

>ywn have Burnbot pity fuck you
>ywn have your dick size insulted in every possible way imaginable by her
>ywn have Goofball secretly film the whole thing and upload it onto pornhub with the title “Sad loser gets pity fucked by hot dom-bot”

... this. i honestly love max's work, it makes me giggle, and i can definitely have a hoot and a holler over his toons, and brain dump is really good. the shorts that he occasionally produces are remarkable and sweet, and the amount of work that goes into it is freaky awesome. love you maxxy

He is one of many who want to be John K.
He even calls himself Max G.

I think Max is funny

He has good ideas but the jokes and his vids go on for far too long. Good example is the first .MOV compared to the last few .MOVs

He needs an editor to cut out the bloat.

These threads are getting really old, always the same OP image
Always OP (Max probably) asking if he's shit and like 1 or 2 people trying their best to defend him.

As everyone always says time and time again in these threads, he's unfunny and his unwillingness to change his 2005 humor is causing his content to stay stagnated and no amount of asking if he's shit will fix it

I'm glad he seemed like he actually was trying with the Cuphead video unlike some of his others I've seen but the joke dragged on for way longer than it needed to be, especially with the good boy part.

He has fantastic animation and i really enjoy the voice actors he uses.....

that being said he could really stand to improve the quality of his jokes. i've laughed while watching his videos before, but many of them are underwhelming and often fall flat. A good example is his undertale video where the entire joke is sans shooting his brother saying 'get fucked nigggggggggggaaaaaa'. Some of his other shit just tries to be edgy and appeal to 14 year olds. Other videos rely too much on 'OMG LE FUNNY FACE'. Funny faces can be amusing but you cant hinge all of your comedy off of them.

it also really irritated me how he kept saying isabelle every sentence, its such an unnatural way of speaking.

I will forever love "Oh my God! Look at all this PORN!"

Essentially this.
The threads are always the same thing - everyone agrees he's a very talented animator but then it becomes a "debate" on whether or not he's a good writer. I use the term debate loosely as most people are in agreement with a few defenders who feel Max has no flaws.

I think he has it in him to be more diverse as a writer but he seems stuck on just violence for the sake of violence humor or just legitmately taking John K jokes and plopping them in his videos.

because it literally steals some john k jokes

His Quentin Tarantino animation is his best work by far.

BIG

Link? Plz

It's not like that's inherently a bad thing. He could do something different that doesn't strongly involve comedy and people would probably respond to it well, but it's like he makes himself insert some kind of joke for the sake of it (for some of his shorter animated videos). If he made an animated music video to showcase his talents it'd probably go over well

i forgot about that

that's a gooder

If John K isn't going to draw anything remotely appealing anymore, someone else might as well take that R&S style for themselves

Fine with most of his stuff. Feel his braindump reviews fall flat though. His Moana one being the worst since it was filled mostly with him conplaining about everything beside the movie itself. Dude definitely doesnt have the mindset at being a critic.

I thought the point was that there's not a lot to say about a movie that's so predictable and expected from Disney, other than
>yeah looks nice

MR TARANTINO YOU'VE BEEN WARNED ABOUT THIS

That one was pretty shit to be honest

why does Sup Forums like to complain about this nigger so much? he makes cartoons and they aren't even awful or anything just not great

are all of his fans resentful towards him and i'm just not understanding the culture or something?

>remembers the porn post of him

Hahahahaha

Man you're so fucking cool for saying the n-word on the internet. Like wow dude I wish I was as rad as you right now. How do you do it my man?

Speaking of which
youtube.com/watch?v=97IfPfjSaDg

Please keep racism to Sup Forums.

I still quote that from time to time

t. gaffer reject butthurt that other people don't adopt his own language boundaries

moar john k style
>sorry i'm also pooping
youtube.com/watch?v=cbpuzYtp43Q

His animation is god-tier by YT standards but he has to pander his writing to the lowest common denominator in order to get enough views to stay afloat. Not that I think is writing is anything special even when he can do whatever he wants.

These. If he gets a small, dedicated team who work for cheap if not free just for experience like an intern, his videos would massively improve. He has obvious flaws that he can't or won't improve on by himself.

Hey you leave stamper alone

>His Moana one being the worst since it was filled mostly with him conplaining about everything beside the movie itself.
That's the joke, user. That's literally the joke.
His braindumps are brilliant satire of clickbait. He makes a star wars video? he fills it with shitposting. He makes a moana video? it's about his personal life crisis as an adult.
I'm not even trying to be "deep" or "smart", I'm just stating what it is

Thank you, Captain Obvious.

Or else?

Captain Obvious is called into action when citizens are threatened by things going completely over their heads

I don't know but his face sure is.

I just hope he finds happiness and success somewhere.

Also Maxxy boy if you're reading this love ya.

This gave me an erection.

I like his stuff

>i really enjoy the voice actors he uses.....
It's himself a lot of the time.

Where is that quote from again?

the .mov series

I think his production values are excellent to say he doesn't work with a team. Wacky Game Jokes was impressive stuff back in the day.

Shame about the comedy.

it's dead, it was actually talking about Chris O Niel but he came up.
desuarchive.org/trash/thread/12610539/

Yes.

Holy fuck the SJW list posted was beyond repugnant, that makes me legit start a sort of cleansing by how bad they have got