This reads like it was written by someone several months after dealing with concussions from a terrible crash

this reads like it was written by someone several months after dealing with concussions from a terrible crash.
is sean murphy actually retarded or just memeing towards some kind of 2deep4u, timm/dini dick sucking finale?

>is sean murphy actually retarded
Yes, Sean Murphy is actually retarded. He was raised catholic but became an atheist because he was drowning and God didn't personally come down to save him.

Artists shouldn't write, desu.

still better overall than anything marvel or indies are shitting out right now

It has wonderful writing and it is a nice alternative look at how Batman's war on crime has taken a toll on Gotham

Sean Murphy drew the pictures you fuck

Literally not the guy to be complaining about

if I was you I would be so embarassed

There's several examples of you being wrong, but since you only read capeshit, well...

Sean Murphy wrote it too idiot. Matt Hollingsworth is a colorist

You can't be serious.

If you can't differentiate between a cartoonist and an artist, well.....

Beating America Chavez and Mockingbird isn't actually an accomplishment.

Nightwing's redesign is so lazy lmao

I am completely serious.

He means people like Hergè, Alex Alice, Bryan Lee O'Malley.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought that story was laughable

Then you have no taste or your reading pool is extremely limited.

Those are cartoonists. Mignola, Cooke, Moebius... all cartoonists.

I mean come on, that's literally a parable used to describe how God works.

sean, please go to bed.

Yo.

You casuals have gotten wayyyyy to confident.

Wait that's why he turned into an atheist? That sound like a fucking super villain origin (because it's fucking is).

Creature of the Night has a better premise and Dark Prince Charming has fanatic art.

This is just Reddit junk that is overhyped and constantly shilled due to Sean's connections.

Is Frank Miller a cartoonist?

It's not even the worst Batman comic that's come out this year.

>if I was you I would be so embarassed

So you are him?

Yeah, I'd say so.

Murphy brings out the worst in writers, his books are always shitty even though they look pretty

You didn't like Joe?

Never heard that before. He put that on Twitter or DA or something?

The Wake was pretty good.

Educate me

You sound like a colossal faggot.

>actually reading for Sean Murphy's script and not just drooling over his amazing art and thinly-veiled boner for all things automotive
Murphy is basically just a car fetish art. I was under the assumption that everything he touched was just an excuse to draw cool cars doing awesome things.

so are you saying athiests make love to goats?

but cartoonists are artists just like a square is a rectangle

>became an atheist because he was drowning and God didn't personally come down to save him
And yet... he didn't drown?

Where in the fuck did I say I was reading this book for the shit story?

Because you made a thread, explicitly complaining about it?

fuck Morrison for wasting Murphy's art on such a terrible story

I bought Punk Rock Jesus just because of the title and was left throughly disappointed.

He hasn't tried to draw anything in a remotely realistic fashion since DKR, so yeah he is.

Man the writing is bad, the book because of some twists and art isn't shit but the writing is bad, the stupid scene where Joker beats Batman was intended to be "symbolic" but in first place that's not symbolic but parallelism and you don't catch it like that cause it seemed the Joker showing off his muscles, you don't get the feeling that Joker is where Batman used to be. Once somebody suggests it you think this what the writer meant and failed to deliver.

If the matter of the story is that Joker is a good guy why that final battle felt like the evil guy boasting

>symbolic but parallelism
Look I don't care which literary technique it was, I thought that was a nice scene

I don't know if Murphy is an asshole or wanted to seem interesting but a very idiot thing to say

Very true which is why despite this one being super amateurish i encourage him to keep up the w/a act

Again, he IS the writer. That's the problem.

The parallel could have been kino if delivered rightly but it was focused on Batman being defeated like a villain winning. If for example Batman had lost it and attacked somebody even if he didn't want to hurt any innocent one it could have had that feeling of a change in their roles but it was just "look I beat you in this too and I have a nice body, that's what makes a hero, right?"

I think the focus was more about how joker had always wanted that and now that he got it it felt like a let down and he wasn't entirely sure what to do next

I've only glanced at it but somehow I don't think it's the very best book being made today. Not everything has to be so huperbolic. Saying it's good would suffice.

But if that was what the writer meant he couldn't deliver it. We have two separate problems. One the focus, there wasn't a correct emphasis on this matter just a thing in the end but Joker needed more feelings there, more emotion, more real doubt and I'm not talking about some gay thing. The second problem is the setup for the scene that was a little forced and wasted the opportunity to do it in other way

>is sean murphy actually retarded
no he is just a liberal male feminist

I kek'd so hard.

>man with a massive ego turns atheist
what a shocker

Nobody knows what feminism is anymore

How did he end up drowning in the first place? Because if it was his own fuck up that makes this story all the more stupid.

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Not exactly a good post OP, you hate the book and I understand it but just insulting it isn't enough. "FUCKING SHIT" "SUCK" "HE'S A DICK JUST BECAUSE" It looks like Tumblr

his books with Morrison, Millar and Snyder aren't any better
he's too talented as an artist that writers (including himself) overindulge on aesthetic and forget to write a competent story

That Batgirl cover is my favorite

>timm/dini dick sucking finale?

I wonder what's the problem with Timm/Dini

>he's too talented as an artist that writers (including himself) overindulge on aesthetic and forget to write a competent story

Is it the story, or the storytelling that's an issue? If you imply that three writers who usually do better work elsewhere. didn't with Murphy, and you also name Murphy's writing as having this problem too, maybe it's about the storytelling?