What does Sup Forums think about the Mass Effect trilogy?

What does Sup Forums think about the Mass Effect trilogy?

1 good
2 great
3 shit
4 it's gonna be shit

Is the general opinion i get around here.

>ME1
9/10
>ME2
9.5/10
>ME3
7/10 (with the extended ending)

ME1 was a good start, but had plenty of flaws. Rather than fix the flaws they turned the games into rather generic shooters. They even changed the atmosphere/aesthetic to something more generic and dark.

1 was a janky but promising sf rpg
2 was a bad rpg, but a good 'shooting + waifus' game
3 was 2 with worse writing and better combat

ME1: 9/10
ME2 on its own: 9/10
ME2 as a sequel to Mass Effect: 6/10
ME3 sans the ending: 7/10
ME3's ending: 0/10

i'm still mad

It's like having a randomization button in character creation that skews facial features further and further when you press it: the result always ends up shittier and uglier then before you pressed the button.

1 was amazing, combat was kinda tough to get into but once you had it down the game was superb. cool setting, great tone, and the enemies were breddy spooky.

2 and 3 i think moved away from the overall story to focus on more personal shit between characters while also making the gunplay easier to pick up.

me1
8.5/10
me2
7/10
me3
6/10

ME1
>combat is clunky but charming
>levelling has a lot of cool numbers to autism over

ME2
>two skill trees BIOTIC RUSH and THING THAT ISNT BIOTIC RUSH

ME3
B I O T I C R U S H
I
O
T
I
C

R
U
S
H

I really like that skill

Blue
Red
Green

I think the series combat shouldve evolved to be more like the rainbow six games, more tactical battle scenarios with team compositions that open up more options on the battlefield.
>Heavy fire has you pinned down
>Order one of your biotics to jump to the next level and start suppressing the enemy with biotics.
Or
>Same scenario
>Order tech specialist to hack a piece of equipment near the enemy and cause a explosion.
>Move in while theyre caught off guard and clean up
Anything would have been better than "Gears of Universal Cooldown".

Das it mang

> 4 it's gonna be shit

What

>the council goes back to not trusting you even after you save their asses from sovereign.

I should have left those limp wristed retards to die.

Back before ME3, the series was considered pretty much gold here, and there were huge mass effect generals on Sup Forums like everyday just talking about it.

Then ME3 came out and everyone just shit on it forever.

...

All RPGs are shit excluding Soulsborne. Crap genre with shit gameplay for losers desu. Ass Effect is no different.

>let the council die
>they get replaced by practically identical assholes
>only real difference is that they get in your way a little bit more

ME was good, but not especially great
ME2 was fine but felt like it was a string of filler episodes in a tv series
ME3 had pretty good gameplay, shit ending, which was better when patched but still not satisfying.

I'm still mad.

>we kill you guys because you would otherwise kill yourselves.

First one was decent, 2 and three suck.