If terraria was 3d, it would of killed minecraft with it's second update

If terraria was 3d, it would of killed minecraft with it's second update.

Fortunately is his own thing

It was already labeled as a clone back then, if it was 3d, not only wouldn't you have a few of the mechanics that seperate it from MC, it'd be bandied as an exact mc clone and lost to the pile

Terraria being 2d was definitely for the best, kept it in it's own niche, where it could grow to be the best.

>would of

You beat me to it

>would of

>It was already labeled as a clone back then
While it's original release was a clone, after the creator dropped it for a year and came back it change alot into something new.

Its another ''we ignore the question because the OP made a spelling mistake'' episode.
fucking twelve year olds.
they will do everything for a epic screencap amirite XD

Terraria would have been just as unsuccessful if it were 3D

3D is far, far more difficult to make as complex as Terraria.

>would of

>3D terraria
>crimson / corruption biome

wud b cool

>XD
fuck off

no we ignore the OP because he's a faggot posting the same shit thread over and over and no one gives a crap kid

if it was 3d it would also be a completely different game and would probably have been killed by minecraft

but your didn't notice he used an apostrophe wrong, did you?

Minecraft was a clone of a clone of a game another guy made.
There were hundreds of people playing multiplayer mc 2 years before it existed.

I just can't remember the name of the game, it's NOT the one that he bought though.

whats the right way of saying it

should of

thank u

Yes, Infinity miner is the name your looking for. He took the code because it was open source.

wud hav

>want a sandbox with quests
>minecraft got fun building in 3D but no quests
>terraria got quests but is 2D shit
>dragon quest builders is a nice middle ground but ps4 exclusive
Goddammit.

Oh that WAS the source? Thought it wasn't.
Thanks for the name. That game was dank. Notch is retarded for taking so long to get multiplayer.
I was excited for the development, alpha creative was literally wonderland, but then children found out.
Game used to be 100% adults, sad to see it so unplayable. Griefing didn't even exist for the first six months.

>>minecraft got fun building in 3D but no quests
there are a bunch of mods that add a questing shit

>2d shit

there's a LOT you can do with 2d shit. You can even go psuedo-3d/metroidvania with teleporters

>terraria got quests
You've never played it have you?

Minecraft wouldn't even be popular if 90% of the world's autistic kids weren't autisticaly obsessed with it

if Terraria was 3d they still to this day wouldn´t have implemented even a quarter of its current content

consider the following, both games are shit and are clones.

also notch is a hack.

I'd rather go back to infinity miner.
Those were peaceful days. Like a warzone, but fun.

Good thing that Terraria is 2D then, we certainly don't need another Minecraft and its fanbase ruining everything.

I think he is talking about "adventures and shit", but Terraria have a quest giver NPC, you know.

Hey cool another Minecraft clone, let's give it a shot...

300 Hours later...must stop, need food argh!

That's some heavy industry right there. Heck, looks like they're even making mobile suits!

Hey cool another reddit post on Sup Forums, let's give it a shot...

One reading later...must stop, have cancer argh!

It would not have been anywhere near the same game if it had been 3D
It might not even have been made

I'm not sure I can think of a single mechanic that couldn't be done in 3D, much less would be hard to do in 3D.

>would of

Dude.

Moving around would suddenly SUCK.

And it would be no fun to build or to explore.

Also combat would be way worse.

No I really doubt that, Minecraft probably would have still crushed it sales wise.

Not related but I actually do quite like Minecraft, but its one of those many games who's monstrous community destroys any casual discussion I want to have about it.

What's yer offer?!

Boss fights would be a bit different. Worm type enemies would be a bit less tellable, though workable.

I think you are right-ish, actually. you could theoretically turn terraria 3d with no real loss, but the game might feel alien from the original and some things like mining/boss fights would need strong reworks to compensate for bosses clipping into the ground needing to be removed.

The combat, a fairly important part of the game, wouldn't have worked nearly as well in 3D.