Find A Flaw: Best Video Games of All Time Edition

1. Halo 3
2. Dark Souls
3. Mass Effect 2
4. Resident Evil 4
5. Dota 2

PRO TIP: YOU CANT

>halo 3
Literally my life in high school

lowest FOV of all the halo games

summer time: Halo ranked/mlg/customs

8pm - 4am. everyday

>only 8 - 4
My mom got mad at me in high school for skyrocketing the electricity bill

1. Mafia
2. Super Mario World
3. RDR
4. Shenmue 2
5. Shadow of the Colossus

>halo 3
>mass effect 2

I agree with the rest and they would be in my top 5 as well

>all this 2000's bullshit

How about some 80's and 90's games you massive underage faggot?

>halo 3
Garbage main campaign
New forms of Flood that were more unfun than the rest
Multiplayer wasn't as fun as Halo 2

>Halo 3
Story
>Dark Souls
Demon Ruins-Izalith sections I liked the 2nd half
>Mass Effect 2
Neutered RPG mechanics
>RE4
No way fag
>Dota 2
Don't play that shit

im 24 retard. those games were good for the times but they don't compare to modern gaming

Halo 3 multiplayer was the best time ive had playing video games.

Nothing compares to Halo 3 customs except maybe warcraft 3 customs

Objectively Halo 3 is the best video game ever made.

The sum of their parts out weighs the few flaws.

>bashing RE4

baka desu

RE

24 with the mindset of an underage shitter.

>le only modern newer games can ever be great
>le old outdated games become shit meme

no way fag as in there are no flaws

nostalgia is a helluva drug

>halo 3
>worse maps than Halo 2

Halo 3
>a pile of shit made by microshit to milk more people into getting the rrodbox 360. awful game play shit story shit online

dark souls
>only good one on this list

mass effect 2
>a blunder with bad sjw bioware story telling, shit game play, shit looking characters, awful gun play, p2w dlc

resident evil 4
>came out on the gamepuke and turned re into "omgs kill teh zombies guys!11!" rather then the awesome slow based game play of the old playstation titles

dota 2
>a p2w pile of shit

Literally every one of those games is absolute shit
You can't be more than 16 years old

>best out of the series and a pinnacle in video games?
yes
>best ever
no
>modern
halo 3 is 10 fucking years old come september you grandpa
holy fuck
it came out when I was a freshman in high school
I still fucking miss it
>10000 custom games played
fucking hell

>sony weeb detected

You clearly never experienced Halo 3.

DOta has no pay to win elements at all.

ME2 was before the SJW came in.

>Halo 3

fuck off CE and H2 are better and only shitters think Halo 3 is the best

this, one of the few games to give me nausea

oddly enough fov is fine in 2-4p splitscreen

hang yourself sonyshill

only underage think Halo 3 was better than 2 or CE

>Garbage main campaign
Explain yourself, the campaign was fucking good to me, lots of variety and tense moments thorought, it felt like an ENDING, which is what should've been before Micro$oft decide to fuck up by milking the franchise.

1. Skyrim
2. Mass Effect 3
3. Super Mario Bros
4. The Last of Us
5. Uncharted 4

fite me

>bad because microsoft
>bad because gamecube
>zero real criticism when those games deserve tons
hmmmm I wonder who could be behind this post

ITT: Neo Sup Forums

Shenmue 2 is for sure one of the right answers

>Halo 3
Halo 2 was better

>Dark Souls
Demon's Souls was better

>Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect was better

>Resident Evil 4
Resident Evil 3 was better

>DotA 2
This is a joke, right?

>no forge
>no theatre
>no H3 level customs
>no 4 player co op

k

Such a great menu. Absolute perfection.

>1
Immense open world filled to the brim with bland NPC's, boring environments, washed-out visuals, pointless dungeons, and an overall disinteresting plot with one-dimensional characters all throughout.
>2.
Lmao
>3.
Litter variety in maps
>4.
Overabundance of dialogue sequences and cutscenes.
>5.
Exhaustingly boring, literally nothing that separates it from Uncharted 2 beyond a few on-rails car sequences, and that ending fight was absolutely pathetic.

>Resident Evil 3 was better
No it's not, 3 is the worst of the first four.

Halo 3 was shit once the fucking Flood were forced into the campaign

Switch is dead on arrival. A worse disaster than the Wii U.

Hello IGN

>Nothing compares to Halo 3 customs except maybe warcraft 3 customs

There was a time, not many years ago, when we made fun out of people like you here.

>skyrim

are you okay?

>the prequel dude

It didn't come to my mind but I would replace DOta 2 with GTA: Vice City right now

Seriously OP? You put a fucking Moba in there instead of a fucking real multiplayer game? Why not fucking GGXXAC or VSav or Garou MBAACC or some other timeless classic like these? The fuck is wrong with you?

Why can't Sup Forums appreciate fightan?

Explain how it is worse than RE1 and RE2.
RE4 is more subjective because it has radically different gameplay.

>1. Halo 3
Snowbound, really couldn't think of anything else
>2. Dark Souls
Bed of chaos
>3. Mass Effect 2
Never played
>4. Resident Evil 4
Can't think of one
>5. Dota 2
The fanbase

halo threads after midnight were always good

called it

>GGXXAC or VSav or Garou MBAACC
Fuck are you even talking about? Only hipsters would know these games.

>Halo 3
Random BR spread because Bungie fucking hated you. Shit weapon balance.

>Dark Souls
Incomplete.

>Mass Effect 2
Repetitive bullshit with literally no main plot outside two missions, crappy design decisions that began the downfall of the series.

>Resident Evil 4

I can't think of anything, that game IS almost perfect.

>Dota 2
MOBAs are a shit genre in general, dumbed down RTS isn't exactly my idea of fun.

>ME2
So many, but let's pick the universal skill cool down.

>Snowbound
every other map in that game was great, what were they thinking?

FUCK YOU

Confirmed to never have played Halo 3

give me your opinion then geezer

1. gmod
2. cod mw2
3. skyrim
4. mario 64
5. dark souls 3

>why can't Sup Forums appreciate fightan

Judging my the rate at which threads appear whining about the skill barrier for entry into the genre, how hard combos are to execute, how hard it is to win online, etc. Sup Forums is just generally bad at fighting games, preferring casual multiplayer genres like FPS and MOBA.

Do you have your Switch preordered? I bet you're really looking forward to another three or four games to play, like with the Wii U.

>4 player co-op
>forge mode
>Halo 3 Customs aka the pinnacle of party gaming for its generation
>Annual

Fuck off. Halo 2 and 1 were great, but Halo 3 was amazing as well

I refuse to believe that the people here can't do a fucking shoryuken motion.

ME 2 had the best mix of story and gameplay.

1. Tetris
2. Pong
Everything else is flawed casual faggotry.

>sony fanboys
>they don't love their system. they just hate yours.
pottery

>5. Dota 2

>MOBAs
end urself my man

It was too hard to narrow it down to five. Here's my list.

1. Demon's Souls
2. Eartbound
3. Silent Hill 2
4. Deadly Premonition
5. Dragon's Dogma: Dark Arisen
6. Catherine
7. Final Fantasy IX
8. OFF
9. Shadow of the Colossus
10. Yume Nikki

>Halo anything
>Souls anything
>Mass Effect 2
>Resident Evil 4
>MOBA anything

Stop sucking nippon's dick, user.

Ok

>not even the best Halo game
>not even the best Mass Effect game
>not even the best RE game

Shit thread is shit.

I didn't like how 90% of the game really was nothing but recruit missions in an pseudo open-ended structure, and the quality of those was really varied. You had some good and some incredibly mediocre ones.

The structure of the missions themselves was fine, but the plot's pacing really suffered thanks to that. ME1 felt like a conscise adventure, ME2 felt like a somewhat disjointed mess.

You'd be surprised.
I've sat flabbergasted trying to teach people how to do it before only to watch them fail time and time again. Some people are really, truly inept.
I mean, fine, consistently performing False Roman Cancels in GG isn't easy, but most people on Sup Forums can't seem to so much as get past Silver on Street Fighter V.

>no flaws
>the quote itself comes from a massive flaw

>Halo anything
>He unironically dislikes Halo
>Even when Halo 5 is the only legitimately good MP shooter this gen

There is no doubt that Mass Effect 1 had an amazing story.

Its just hard to replicate that same sense of adventure and discovery once you found out the reapers were coming

There's a Western game in there!
I'd give honourable mentions to Morrowind and Planescape Torment.

you could make arguments for the first two albeit shitty ones but RE4 is the best resident evil game

I started crying a bit Sup Forums all those high school LAN parties, fucking around online, building maps and making up game modes, fucking zombies. Fuck they don't even LAN anymore because everything is wifi or Bluetooth.

I have too, but these people who can't do a SRK are the same people that would fucking NEVER post in this shithole, Sup Forums is for people who really enjoy videogames, and I don't mean ALL vidya, I mean the concept of videogames, which really begs the question, how come these sad fucks that come here can't fucking do forward, down, diagonal, button? Fucking hell, remember wingdreams? We had tons of threads back then, what the fuck hapened?

Switch is dead on arrival. Yelling about Sony doesn't change this fact.

>Mass effect 2
Pointless story. Retcons. Bioware shitty story telling.

>Best Video Games of All Time
>list shit games

>Surely people wouldn't fall for such obvious ba--
>77 responses

>halo 3
>darksouls
>shit
How the hell can anyone think tha-

>weeaboo pic
Oh, that explains a lot actually.

Not him, but Halo 2 and Halo 5 are better than 3.

just be glad that it happened

I like Halo 3 too but
>best game of all time
You're going to have to justify this. The story already is a flaw.

1. Witcher 3
2. There are other games?

>Annual
>mfw we got all the way to the fucking end, and then someone lagged out
SO MUCH RAGE

Yup

Death of the series and partner to the death of gaming leading the world further down a FPS hellhole.

I guess it takes a specific sort of person to want to play fighting games.
You need to be patient and have becoming better as a long term goal. I've been playing fighting games for over a decade and I'm still far from expert.

Let's contrast an FPS, like Overwatch. It's easy to learn how to play, easy to master, so you can get near instant gratification. If you do lose everyone just blames the team rather than themselves, so the pressure is lessened.

In fighting games, it's about improving as an individual. You have to take losses constructively which I think is hard for some people to do, especially when they get beat twenty times in a row.

They don't have the right mindset for the true test of skill.

>Witcher 3
>Follow the dotted line
>Witcher sense quests
>Statistically broken gameplay
>Shitty menus/UI
>Borked down RPG elements
>Empty open world
>And more

It wasn't amazing but it was more than decent.

Halo 3 shines in the depth of its online matchmaking, especially for a console fps.

...

Replace Dark Souls with Skyrim and it's a perfect list

Yeah, patience is a virtue that is needed with these kind of games, but I've never seen people discuss them as they should in this site, well, most of the time at least, pretty sad really, because Sup Forums's format would really make for good discussion of these games.

As much as I love Halo 3, the campaign was 50% garbage.
>5 hours long at best
>Shit ass proto-QTE final boss fight
>Didn't even use the obvious, appropriate candidate for a "final boss" and the only appropriate use of a "boss" in Halo
>Obnoxious forced segue into 4, a trash Halo game for idiots

The list goes on. The only things they really did right were making it 4-player and adding that arcade mode.

You need to work on the bait a little, that's 'too' unrealistic. It's too easily identifiable as bait.

Rine ends here that's a ding dong bannu

This tbqh.

>He unironically dislikes Halo
Because I'm not underage.

>Even when Halo 5 is the only legitimately good MP shooter this gen
There hasn't been a legitimately good MP shooter since UT2K4.

Skyrim has a great story and amazing environment but the gameplay and enemy AI got so boring.

Dark Souls had a better story, better atmosphere, WAY better enemies and combat gameplay.

Whos the obvious final boss? Gravemind?

>underage

I hope you realize people who played Halo CE during high school are now in their 30s.