After 55 hours with BotW, I can honestly say this is still king. Yes yes, well done ocarina....
HOWEVER. BotW is definitely #2 best zelda game of all time and top #5 of all time for sure. the sense of adventure BotW gives is what the devs were trying to do ever since AlltP.
>#1
>Not MM
Opinion discarded
>#1
>not LTTP
Opinion discarded
Ocarina wasn't even the best Zelda game before BOTW
>#1
>Not my favorite zelda game
Opinion discarded
Only if we're talking about the GC port that actually ran at playable framerates la
...
>#1
>Not The Faces of Evil
t.contrarian
So, if I'm reading you correctly you have two Zelda games in your top 5 of all time? What are other games in your top 5.
>#1
>not Wand of Gamelon
Bloodborne, Witcher 3, and Persona 5.
OFFICIAL TIER LIST
Ocarina of Time
Majora's Mask
Link's Awakening
Link to the Past
Oracle of Ages/Seasons
Breath of the Wild
Link Between Worlds
Twilight Princess
Wind Waker
Minish Cap
POWER GAP
Four Swords & Adventures
Spirit Tracks
Skyward Sword
Phantom Hourglass
Zelda 2
Zelda 1
Wand of Gamelon
Faces of Evil
Zelda's Adventure
Good taste, except I've never played Persona
>witcher 3 and bloodborne in top 5 of all time
opinion discarded
...
The only thing that went wrong with BotW is that its too fucking good so all the artists are busy playing and not making more porn of Mipha and Paya.
...
I cannot get past the frame rate dips. It's disgusting, and it completely takes me out of the game. Not to mention the other horrible issues, like the game being too casual, weapons breaking too easily, the master sword being as faulty as a low quality 10 year old duracell battery, some enemies being HP sponges, but not actually being threats, Calamity Ganon being a pathetic pushover compared to his guardians, the boring overworld, and the disgusting sex fanservice.
I wouldn't even put this on a top 50 list, let alone a top 5.
>HOWEVER. BotW is definitely #2 best zelda game of all time
Not even close.
In fact it's so shit, it's not even a real Zelda game. Just some open world sandbox fuckery with a Zelda skin.
It's like saying Hyrule Warriors is a Zelda game.
>zelda is about exploration and wondering while on an adventure
>BotW is the best at this out of all zelda games
>uhhhhhh it's not a zelda game because I say so
Majora's Mask was better.
BotW is a sandbox open world fuckery and that's it. The bosses are re-skins and the final boss is the pig from Twilight Princess. He doesn't move and only shoots a laser at you, but you have to ride Epona. You kill Dark Beast Ganon by shooting light arrows at circles that appear on his body, but the worst part is that he doesn't even move. He's just facing one direction. Super incredibly unsatisfying and disappointing.