It's a good game, just not a good X game

>it's a good game, just not a good X game

that's a completely legit thing to say

Whats wrong with that argument?

It can be a good game in the mechanical sense, but have poor storytelling etc.

>What is breath of the wild and Resident Evil 7

What? It's perfectly reasonable to judge a game differently for how well it works as a standalone title and for how well it functions as a part of its series.

Fallout 4

Banjo Kazooie Nuts and Bolts is a good game.
But it's definitely not a good Banjo Kazooie game.

If you're autistic

>[Characteristic that reflects the quality of the game] doesn't matter!

RE7 is a good outlast/Amnesia type of game , not a good RE one
Nuts n Bolts is a good lego game , not a good Banjo one.