Nier Replicant or Nier Gestalt?

Nier Replicant or Nier Gestalt?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=V6f0GuWnFZY
youtube.com/watch?v=jRjYGR9gtfY
youtu.be/lgq0O2kC18E?t=4m45s
twitter.com/AnonBabble

gestalt

Gestalt

Gestalt for the main story, Replicant for the gay porn with Emil

Some points come across more natural as RepliCant and vice versa but overall I prefer Gestalt.

Replicant is objectively better

Ending C and D make no sense in Gestalt

Gestalt with glorious dub
youtube.com/watch?v=V6f0GuWnFZY

Gestalt.

>I never played Replicant because I don't read nip so I'll just say Gestalt is better because its the one I played

:^)

Replicant because it actually makes more sense with him later growing up into father.

Yes. That's exactly what I did, actually

What was the point of this post

there is an english patched version of replicant for ps3

A father protecting his daughter is better than a fuckboi that sold his boypussi to pay for his sister medicines.

Good thing Replicant has both.

explain how ending c doesn't make sense for father nier because i feel thats the choice he would have made.

and all that it is is the english text from gestalt slapped onto relicant which doesn't really work.

Gestalt is the better idea but the dialogue was all mostly made for RepliCant and sound fucking stupid coming from Father Nier.

>wanting to play with 15 years old father
wut

OP was obviously asking which one is better. Fuck off.

All they did was take the english script from Gestalt.

Father>Brother
But Father gets goofy as fuck scenes because Taro is a hack and didn't change them
"We are friends now!"

Gestalt

Gestalt does what RepliCant

Replicant is the canon version but Father love for daughter is more convincing than brother love for sister

I'm both confused and aroused.

>Njer
>RepliCant

fucking nips

>A father protecting his daughter is better than a fuckboi that sold his boypussi to pay for his sister medicines.

Agreed. youtube.com/watch?v=jRjYGR9gtfY

Gestalt. I respect bro Nier but he looks like Kaine with a different hair-do.

Replicant was a mistake

What am I looking at here and why is it arousing.

Where's the difference?

>Replicant is the canon version
Both are canon.

>NieR is almost a fucking decade old
>This.Cannot.Continue.jpg

fatherly love vs incest

Are you a Repli-Can? Or a Repli-Cant?

You're looking at a powerful alpha dominating beta sissy boys. Further proof Gestalt is better

It's not gay if you're the one putting the dick in.

Replicant is not that much better besides Brother's having Guts similarities (raped then killed the rapist when he was young, likes big long swords, bit of a cunt) and Emil being uber gay for him.
I don't buy it that Kaine would fall in love with a fuccboi instead of Manly HugeMuscles

>Nier Replicant or Nier Gestalt?
?
When did he ask which was better? And why are you so mad about my opinion?

What does 9S rhyme with again?

generic whitehaired teen who spread his asscheeks for money vs a father without a regular job

Fine ass?

going to need a basic gestalt over repli

Replicant makes a bit more of sense in the beginning, as in
>parents dead, time to get random jobs from people, including prostitution
vs
>wife dead, I didn't have some kind of job because reasons?

>Nier can't be a stay at home husband while wife has item stand/prostitute

Gestalt is more canon to the overall series than DoD2.

Maybe his job needed his wife like he sold shit she made or something like that

Dad protecting his daughter > Little shit barely caring about his sister
Kaine falling for a slab of man meat > Kaine falling for a whiny child

Wise words user, wise words.

Was it Replicant Nier or Gestalt Nier who whored himself out in Nier Replicant?

DoD 2 is canon enough to its DoD ending.
Gestalt is kinda irrelevant because fuccboi wrapped up things for real.

RepliCant is canon

Gestalt is canon in America, Replicant is canon in Japan. They both are canon, stop trying to argue it.

>DoD 2 is canon enough to its DoD ending.
it doesn't have a DoD ending

>Replicant is the canon version but Father love for daughter is more convincing than brother love for sister

Difference of culture, which is part of the reason they changed it. I have that kind of relationship with my sister, though. Would lay down my life for her if it came to that.

Murder.

Replicant to play as intended. Gestalt to be catered to as a westerner

Murder

Name a more tragic character in the NieR series than Emil.

Pro tip: You can't.

>NO PS3
>NO PS3
>NO PS3

They both work for very different reasons. Both are canon anyway.

Wasn't it explained that Father was a Nomad that the sisters found and gave him a home and oddjobs to support him and his daughter? and totally not for sinister reasons
It's been too many years since i last played to remember correctly

...

The Iron Pipe's weapon story in Nier Automata is with Papa.

Gestalt Shadowlord

In the english version, what about in the Japanese one?

>Emil being uber gay for him.
Okay, we have found the only way in which Replicant is superior to Gestalt.

There is someone else but I can't quite remember...

Gestalt

>implying

I think most normal, functioning big brothers would die for their younger sister sibling in a heart-beat no matter what culture you belong to.

Script making more sense is the biggest way.
Dad Nier still acts like a teenager most of the time for no reason.

It is not. Do you have a sister?

Yeah, but that kind of mindset is more heavily enforced in Japanese culture, with siblings forming much tighter bonds with each other than their parents.

Actually yeah Shadowlord is pretty damn tragic, up there with Emil easily.

Furiae

>Dad Nier still acts like a teenager most of the time for no reason.
source?

Yes, I do have a younger sister. Like the othera non said, I would lay down my life in an instant for her.

Are you saying you wouldn't risk your life for your sister?

Her cuck of a not-husband is worse.

Brother is way more suitable: physical changes after time skip, unlocking spears and 2 hand swords after time skip makes more sense, appropriate ages to be hanging around with a teenager and a little kid, and his older design looks pretty good unlike his younger design and Papa Nier.

Also where does this idea that siblings don't care about each other that much come from? Is this an American thing?

I got you, my man.

You keep saying that, but I can't think of a single instance.

Gestalt is canon to Automata if you compare the year the first game takes place and the date in the last Gestalt Report.

The game, read it, he acts and says stuff all the fucking time that doesn't fit a grown ass man with a daughter.

KAINE DON'T DIE
WE ARE FRIENDS NOW!!

Based papa Nier is far better than fuckboy Nier anyway.

Isn't it changed to Nii-san in the Japanese version? Also both of them are referenced in the virtuous/cruel spears so they're both recognized regardless of version

Yes, and?

>KAINE DON'T DIE
>WE ARE FRIENDS NOW!!
I don't see a problem here. Should he say WE ARE LOVERS NOW?

>Not understanding why someone might need to work

I'm guessing you are a NEET shut-in?

more

I'm really glad we got Father Nier instead of Brother. It was a nice change from most JRPGs. He was ugly as shit, but it was endearing.

There's only two real parts where nier starts talking about friendship like a generic shonen teenage mc. and when weiss is called a little bitch. Besides that, most of the dialouge fits father nier.

This is Japan tho they have adults doing retard shit all the time.

Just look at MGS

The artist deleted his pixiv so I don't know if there is more

where's the difference?

it was rather refreshing having an fugly grown-ass dude for a JRPG protagonist than your regular bishie

Since Papa is the only one dubbed i guess i have to go for it, i wouldn't want to miss these kind of gems.
youtu.be/lgq0O2kC18E?t=4m45s

Fuck, I just got back from checking saucenao and I can't seem to find it on the boorus.

Project Gestalt failed in 3361, Replicant takes place in 3465

Both Weiss and Kaine voice performance was so great. Easiliy the best of their respective actors games. And those 2 are in alot of shit. Too bad weebs refuse to play it.

Emil's line here is so good Nier 1 was fantastic

Who is the #1 dad?
Nier or Asura?