P4 > P5 > P3

P4 > P5 > P3

Is it generally agreed that this is the accepted order?

If it is opposite day sure. Otherwise your taste is shit.

P5>P3>>>P4
Makoto easily is better than every post-P3 Personafu

5 > 3 > 2 > 4 > 1

No.

II>III>I>V>IV

P5 > P3 > P2EP > P2IS >>> P4 >>> P1

5 > 4 > 3 > 2 1
Persona is the only series I can think of that somehow got better each time.

P5 is better because its dungeons are actually handcrafted and not procedurally generated trash. Though P5's are still too handholdy. Atlus has zero respect for the Persona audience's intelligence.

This

Persona 4 is better than Persona 3.

Can you blame them for that though?

For protagonists? Yes. None of them is objectively the best otherwise, all have their strong points.

Not really, no. I just hope it doesn't bleed over into SMT. I liked IV for the most part but there were some worrying signs there.

Please stop making P4 fans look stupid thanks

Persona 5 is superior to P4 in every way possible, but I still hold P4 closer to my heart

Correct answers.

Makoto is easily best Personafu. Never mind jsut being post-P3.

5 > 4 > 3 > 2 > 1 >>>>>>>P4/P3 spinoff

This

P5 improved on so much.

she's not even best in her game

Literally the only good things about P4 are Kanji, Adachi, Naoto and Dojima.

>naoto
Opinion discarded, awful character who serves no purpouse.

...

Dojima doesn't even hold a candle to Sojiro though.

>Not liking Funky Student

He's not barabait though.

P5 > P3 = P2 > P1 >> P4

>Awful character
We're not talking about Chie, though.

Yes but that wasn't relevant.

I forgot about Funky Student. My mistake.

I just finished Futaba's palace is Haru joining my party soon?

Persona 4's characters are nowhere as good as 3's. The VAs are even better.

P5 > P1 > P3 > P4

I refuse to rate P2 because while the story stuff is fantastic the gameplay is excruciatingly boring

Yeah in the next dungeon

Haru is so cute!

Is she good as a party member?

>P1
>Above anything
What the fuck

I think she a great boss killer.

she's probably 2nd after MC kun. (if you mean in terms of damage/utility), Makoto won my heart

Does he improve? I'm in May and all the time it's "HURR ILL KICK U OUT IF YOU CAUSE TRUBLE"

One of the best.

Her persona has shooting skills, so basically yea.

He improves.
He even apologizes for treating you like shit in the beginning later on.

You guys need to stop lying about having played P2, it's just embarrassing

P4 > P2 >P3 >P1

I just started P5, but its already looking incredibly promising.

P5>P4>P3
P3 is just pretty shallow desu, the music's great and I like some of the characters but it doesn't do much for me. Maybe if it had actual dungeons I'd put it above 4.

Depends what is getting ranked.
>Waifus
5 >>> 4 >>> 3
>Story
3 > 4 > 5
>Characters/friendships/etc.
4 >>>>>>> 5 > 3
>Gameplay
5 >>>>> 4=3
>Music
3 > 4=5

She's by far the best party member. Her skill set is ridiculous.

Yes he's based as fuck, do his social link and you learn more about him naturally as the story progresses.
Also if you like SP restorative items you better start his confidant.

Yes.
And get out before you get spoiled.

P5>P3>P4
P4 is easily worse of the best

5 > 4 > 3 > 2 >1

P4 has the same randomly generated nonsense.

I really hope they revamp the P4 characters for Persona 5 Arena, all of the P3 characters are fun as fuck but everyone from P4 - aside from Chie and Naoto - are boring as fuck to play.

P1 has better gameplay then P3 though

Not being able to control your party is dumb as fuck. But I dont hate P3 as much as I do P4 since I despised most of the P4 cast.

5 actually has real dungeons that are not randomly generated garbage.

That alone puts it above 3 and 4.

>5 >>>>> 4=3
This is true but I don't understand why they don't just use DDS's Turn Press instead of the Once More system, does anyone actually like that over Turn Press?

this

5 = 3 >>>> 4

5 definitely has the best gameplay though since they actually put some effort into the dungeons.

I enjoyed playing Yu in the first version of the game when he had the easily abused 5D okizeme. It was fucking stupid, but since I played Minazuki and Chie after he lost it I guess fucking stupid is my thing.

>Story
3 > 4 > 5
>Characters/friendships/etc.
4 >>>>>>> 5 > 3

The characters in 4 are horrible what the fuck?

>P4 story
>over anything
kys

>P1 has better gameplay then P3 though

P3 Once More is easily exploited and bad

P4/P5 Once More actually makes sense and works

Don't bother. Sup Forums only judges a game on its waifus, because their understanding of game design and the concept of recreational fun is flimsy.

Is there a proper download for the soundtrack yet?
I grabbed the one from /vg/ but its still unorganized

P2EP>3FES>3>5>4>P2IS>P1SQ>P1

It absolutely does have better gameplay.

Yosuke and Teddie are genuinely two of the worst video game characters ever.

If only Persona 5 combat wouldn't be this weird mix of braindead "assist" combat and random "whoops MC is dead" moments.
the assist feature is really dumb

I thought that too, but then I actually finished it instead of dropping it in the first hour because first person dungeons and grid formations intimidated me when I first tried it, and it was actually pretty good.

>le smug anime girl

Not being able to control your dudes in a jrpg is boring and it doest help that for some reason the animations for using persona skills take forever. So you do a input to use a move then have to wait 10 seconds before another input. It gets boring. Also demon negoations are cool.

Mishima is just like Yosuke(in the dick riding department) except instead of being bffs with him I can tell him to fuck off many times and did.

Are there any other stealth oriented 3D JRPGs out there?

I was half way done with the game before my save got deleted. I was really enjoying it as well its a dam shame.

Story:
P3>P5>>>>>>>>P4
Characters:
P3>P5>>>>>>>>P4
Gameplay:
P5>>>>>>P4>>>P3

Anything is better than the western release of P5. Such a terrible translation shouldn't be tolerated.

In order to compensate for joining late and needing 5 Pro to get her slink started, she gets some ridiculous skills.
The reflects, One Hit Kill and single target/AoE element are the only active skills she needs.

>wasting a day that you could be getting knowledge and charm on 30SP coffee

I'll take assist over the shitty smirk mechanic that Atlus introduced in SMT.

Persona 3 is worse than Persona 4 because it has worse gameplay.

No one more is better, combined with baton pass, and party members swapping.
Overall P5 has the best persona SMT gameplay to date.

>needing 5 Pro to get her slink started
I'm at August and only have on stat above 3, are high stats in one category required to max every single link?

Honestly they should just drop the "MC dead = game over" bullshit, it's not even remotely fun. It technically makes the game harder but in a retarded way, usually it happens in a single turn and you have zero time to react.

I also think being able to switch between party members on the fly should be a standard feature and not something you have to unlock.

I hope P6 isn't green.

Orange or purple seems more palatable.

>Not using best sensei to do that job for free.

The Baton Pass only further trivializes things because of how overpowered it is.
The MC is also far more powerful than anyone else in your party.

Cant you just get Kawakami to make it for you?
Or does making her do things still waste your time?

Yes.
5 Pro for Haru.
5 Kindness for Sojiro
5 Guts for Iwai
5 Int for Hifumi
5 Charm for Makoto

Yes, you'll need everything maxed to max every s.link

I want magenta.

Overall best is P5 and Persona is my least favorite spin off of SMT

P5 > P2IS

P3 and P4 are in a wierd place for me
Cant stand the combat in P3
Cant stand the everything else in P4

i agree, there are too many random factors that can lead to an instant gameover
>instadeath mudo spell
>crits
>your persona is accidently weak

it just happens too often.

P1 plays like rancid shit.

>Smug anime girl
Are you fucking blind? That's a "Confused anime girl".
Don't be a meme-loving-fuck if you don't have eyes.

There are versions of P3 where you can control your party, you know that, right?

Fuse a Persona that has a spell that blocks instant death spells or one that is immune altogether, with how inheritance works in this game there is no excuse to not have stuff like that covered.

Isn't the purpose of one more/press turn the reward of hitting weakness?
How is this in conflict with that?

Of course it's overpowered, that's the goal.

3 > 4 > 5

Prove me wrong
Protip:
You can't

>Gameplay
5 >>> 4 > 3
>Story
3 > 4
Haven't finished P5's story yet, only on October.
>Music
4 > 5 > 3

Elizabeth > Twins > Margaret
Morgana > Koro > Teddie
Joker > Door > Yu
Futaba > Rise = Fuuka

My complaint with Once More is that it's too easy, I'm playing on Hard and outside of the first few hours it's just not challenging. The fact that you can press already pressed turns with the combination of All Out Attacks eliminates any semblance of challenge from non boss encounters and if you can't cover all the weaknesses with one character than the baton pass lets you which once again leads to an All Out Attack.

>Music
>4 > 5 > 3
It's the opposite of that though.

Best persona game coming through

Your are probably not too far in the game if you think this solve everything.

Persona Q has the best combat

I'm at September, 60 or so hours in.

The fact that low power westerners think 4 is the best just proves it's the worst