Mario RPG

put them in order from best to worst

Tier 1: PM, TTYD, BIS, SSS, SMRPG
Tier 2: SPM, DT, PJ, PiT
Tier 3: SS, CS

Thread is over

>PM, TTYD, BIS, SSS, SMRPG
Now put these in order

But they are in order

FUCK YOU

Uh. I'd say SMRPG>TTYD>SSS>PM>BIS.
Though BIS and PM are the only two I haven't played in years.

make a list like this

Actually the Paper Mario side is about right.

Personally for me it's:
PM>TTYD>SSS=/>SMRPG>>>BIS

Put BIS into Tier 2
It was kinda boring

...

Put Super in both it being exaggerated how good it is & how bad it is since you get split opinions on that game when it's generally just a fine game. But yeah, good image otherwise.

SMRPG=TTYD>SSS=PM1>BIS>PiT>SPM>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Sticker Star and Color Splash

...

...

This is right. However I did love the fuck out of TYD.

>God Tier
PM64

>Top Tier
SMRPG

>Great Tier
M&L SS

>Good Tier
TTYD

>Low Tier
BIS
SPM
PiT

>Shit Tier
DT
PJ
PMSS
CS

>SPM
>RPG

surpringly accurate

>Super Metroid is the game that all other Metroid games have drawn from
So Metroid and Metroid II drew from Super Metroid despite coming out years prior. Really makes me think.

>retards putting PM64 above TTYD

>64 only has you backtrack repeatedly in one chapter like an idiot
>TTYD does it for more than three

aside from chapter 4 you'd have to try pretty hard to be bothered by it

>Chapter 3 has you repeat the ranks
>Chapter 5 has you running around for Bobbery
>Chapter 6 has you repeatedly revisiting rooms on the train
>Chapter 7 and everything with General White

Shit taste

And?

>retards putting TTYD above PM64

>Chapter 3 has you repeat the ranks

it's fun as fuck and there is extra content

>Chapter 5 has you running around for Bobbery

my memories are a bit hazy but is it the part in Rogueport? it's really, really short desu

>Chapter 6 has you repeatedly revisiting rooms on the train

it's fun as fuck and there is extra content

>Chapter 7 and everything with General White

annoying part, I'll have to agree but imo the moon compensates for it

>Chapter 3
>it's fun as fuck
Not on repeat playthroughs.

>Chapter 6
>it's fun as fuck
No it isn't. It's a rehash of the 5 minute murder mystery from PM64 and none of the added padding is worth it.

>Not on repeat playthroughs.

but you're most likely playing with a new colour of Yoshi, isn't that enough

>No it isn't. It's a rehash of the 5 minute murder mystery from PM64 and none of the added padding is worth it.

rehash or not the atmosphere is pretty dope

>my memories are a bit hazy but is it the part in Rogueport? it's really, really short desu
No, he's talking about being on the island where you need to get the Chuckola for Bobbery since he thinks he's dying, but in order to do that need the coconut and then afterwards you need Flavio to open the Pirate's Grotto.