Why does Sup Forums hate master pieces?

Why does Sup Forums hate master pieces?

fuck off

I agree all three are masterfully crafted and worth playing. But I'd argue other games desire to be put those spots.

> milennials

chances are you're a millennial too

BOTW does not belong on that list, the combat and healing systems are completely broken.

>TW3
>masterpiece
>shitty combat and mediocre story
TW2 > TW3

prove you're not a newfag

>all the best games came out withing the last 2 years

You know how I know you have complete dogshit taste and you are probably under 14?

>not memeing it up with the "holy trilogy" and then putting 4 games

BOTW deserves a spot before those other two. But I'd nominate a handful of other games over those listed

BOTW is no better than Skyrim and worse in many respects.

Needs more MGS3

But it's cool to be a self hating millennial.

They are all 10/10 to me, wish BB got a Pro patch though

Really nigga?

Yes, sadly the brainless combat and lack of content plus copy pasted 3-4 enemies and shrines really put the game down.
It's a good base concept but way too broken and with near zero challenge thanks to the ability of being able to carry and eat infinite food even during fights. Hopefully they will learn this and will to copy souls healing systems in the next one.

Skyrim is already better exploration game because there's more unique content to find than chests with 5 fire/ice arrows or more seeds. The world is way to big for the amount of unique content it has, by the time you do 2 divine beasts you've seen everything the game has to offer and realize how shallow everything actually is.

wow.

But user that's not donkey Kong country 2, super Mario world or the last of us

Hold up.

>Loved BB
>Loved BOTW
>Hate TW3

Fuck dialog options. Shit's boring and gay.

This, plebs don't understand combat in 2 was better than 3, and the story thats told, can only be done like that in vidya

First time I see under story in the same image as dark souls, this triggers me

Cry me your bitch tears, Nintendies.

Is witcher 3 worth buying? I haven't played any other witcher games.

Shadow of the colossus is too pure for you. Fuck off m8

>Bloodborne is there clear as day

You're fucking embarrassing m8.

As someone who was once in your shoes, I say yes. Get the complete version if you can, the expansions are really good

All 3 of those games fall under the 'pretty good' label. They are not masterpieces by any stretch.

So how much Breath of the Wild have you played? And don't give me that "I don't need to play it to know it's shit!" nonsense.

Haven't played Zelda and witcher 3 was pretty great, but bloodborne isn't even deserving of "greatest Soulsborne game ever created". In fact, I'd go as far as to say it's rivalled only by vanilla dark souls 2 as worst souls title. I'm really unsure why people here like it so much. All the mechanical changes seemed like a step in the wrong direction and the enemy/level design was extremely samey and repetitive.
>Oh great, another giant beast boss that flails its arms around incoherently

I can only conclude that most of the games supporters were early adopters of the ps4 back when it had nothing else and felt the need to justify the purchase to themselves.

That's pretty harsh.

Those aren't even the 3 best games of this generation, and I wouldn't even put them in a top 200.

Replace TW3 with Persona 5 and that is coffect

Only three of these are good games.

Bioshock 2, MGS2, and Undertale are legit good games though.

>Persona 5
>glorified VN and waifu sim with watered down SMT gameplay
>good, let alone masterpiece

>high-school simulator visual novel with garbo plot and shit, undeveloped canvases for characters
no thanks

Dark souls and MSG2 and ???

10/10
10/10
0/10

>Bioshock 2 is more pretentious then Bioshock

None of the listed are good
>MGS2
>game
oi im laffin m8

>no persona 5

trash-tier bait, of course it would be on Sup Forums

Do people not even try anymore?

All of it. Generic Ubisoft clone with even more repetitive content (dungeons, shrines) and terrible itemization (repairs).

7/10 was generous.

You are both correct, but the sum of its parts make it pretty great

You're right, it's not a game, it's a ludo experience no other interactive entetainment medium has ever come close to.

All of those are fantastic games, haven't played undertale and Biishock 2 but I guess I'll give them a try now. Thanks for the recommendations.

>Fallout 4 and Skyrim nowhere on the list

This man doesn't now what he's talking about

>Sup Forums memes
Try harder, pla. This shit won't fly here.

>V says a game is crap. You play it and it's actually great.

>V says a game is great. You play it and it's actually crap.

What are their names?

Bloodborne isn't even the best Souls game, it's tied for being worst with DS3 and DS2. It's a dumbed down action game with none of the intelligent design of the series, just room after room filled with enemies that try to hit you and reduce your HP before you hit them and reduce their HP.

This has never happened desu

Rolling simulator, open empty world and casual combat

most people on Sup Forums like Dark Souls and MGS 1-3, I played all of them and hated them all equally
Dark Souls for being a total bore, MGS games for having terrible controls
>inb4 muh controls as metaphor even though they weren't in 4-5

Wrong for all 3, amazing

You're both completely fucking wrong. MGS2 is an interactive experience of the highest caliber.

>V says a game is crap. You play it and it's actually great.
Undertale

>V says a game is great. You play it and it's actually crap.
Fallout: New Vegas

>MGS4
lolwut

>is about gameplay
>MGS4
Lamao. All 4 hours of gameplay?

>V says a game is crap. You play it and it's actually great.
Yakuza 6
>V says a game is great. You play it and it's actually crap.
Shadow of the Colossus

The witcher is just batman in the woods

>BAIT! THIS IS BAIT!
>reddit spacing
Cool beans, mang

>complaining about reddit spacing
>not the biggest redflag of a newfag trying too hard to fit it

>V
Fuck off, and Sup Forums is not one person.

>reddit spacing is reddit meme I swear you guise!
Yeah, bud. No.

Literally playing Dragon Age 2 right now and the game is pretty fucking good. It obviously has its flaws, dialogue being the biggest of them all, but in general it is a pretty good RPG.

what a faggot

The fuck. TW2 Combat was absolute trash tier. It was impossible to master and Geralt was jumping in random directions.

They´re just a bunch of shitposters trying to be different because TW2 was not mainstream and TW3 is more known by the public.

Just let them go, they´ll still thinking that they are a perfect snowflake.

>ludo
>Sup Forums

Is this fucking bait?

>Hi, we're the 3 most overrated games ever created
FTFY
All three games are 8/10s heralded as 12/10 GOATs by obnoxious fanboys.

Objectively not true. TW2's combat had a lot more depth than TW3's and was much more responsive too. The rolling looks dumb, but you can mod in a piroutte instead that looks a lot better (and is just an animation change, rather than a mechanical one).

Is funny when NintenDrones talk shit about combat, as if Zelda combat was anything special

While I don't agree with Undertale part, F:NV really is super boring after the first couple hours of initial wonder wear off.

*Why does Sup Forums hate videogames?

Sad but true. It has fucking ubisoft towers

I haven't even played botw yet, retard

>F:NV really is super boring after the first couple hours of initial wonder wear off.
I went through that phase once but after a while I got completely obssessed with this game

It's just such a clumsy game, in gameplay and pacing. I dunno why I can't forgive it with Fallouts and Oblivion even though I play a whole lot of abysmal looking and controlling rpg's from early 00's.

Bloodborne is good but overrated. In my opinion it has enough flaws to not be called a "masterpiece", and especially not the greatest game of all time. Chalice dungeons, short length, bad framerate, lack of options, some mechanical downgrades from previous games, weak environmental variety, etc.

Breath of the Wild is the same except replace "good" with "okay". It has some novel ideas but the execution is lacking and it's too big of a departure from previous Zeldas (up to and including the original). The core content is lacking, the progression is non-existent, the pacing is abysmal, exploration is meaningless and repetitive, etc. BotW is what happens when you take "freedom" to an extreme and neglect the actual design of a game.

Haven't played Witcher 3.

Gameplay is a broad term like how people usually mean that the combat is awful because it's taken from Fallout 3 but the roleplay is also part of the gameplay which is one of the reasons why the game is loved
>pacing
I assume you mean how you have to go through the way south to reach New Vegas right? If you're really careful you can just skip it and go through the deathclaw valley without getting noticed

>being this mad

>putting "muh 2 million" on the same tier as Zelda and Witcher
Fuck off, roach