Why does Sup Forums praise this game...

Why does Sup Forums praise this game? I see it praised for being a story-focused game that allows you to make your own choices, but those choices never actually lead anywhere. The story and the ending is always the same, the only thing that changes is which characters survive. Heavy Rain did this thing, fucking 10 years ago, where the actual plot, the identity of the killer and the ending actually changed based on your choices.

If you're gonna make an interactive movie with barebones gameplay, why would you make your choices so restrictive? You might as well not have any choices in the first place and just let us watch the movie without interruption. If you're gonna make this kind of game, then make as many branching paths and endings as you can, so the player always has a different experience every time he goes back to replay the game.

The difference between Heavy Rain and Until Dawn is that Heavy Rain was written by a complete buffoon.

>Heavy Rain did this thing, fucking 10 years ago, where the actual plot, the identity of the killer and the ending actually changed based on your choices.
No? The killer is always the same. The "endings" were just
>so and so lived happily ever after
or
>so and so killed themselves
Which is no deeper than Until Dawn.

David Cage has never made a bad game

Can't play this game because ps4 fan goes full retard breaking any immersion.

>David Cage has never made a game.
ftfy

>Heavy Rain did this thing, fucking 10 years ago, where the actual plot, the identity of the killer and the ending actually changed based on your choices.
Wait, in which branch Shelby dindu nottin? thats news to me.

What gets me most is that the "fast walk" button is just slightly faster than the regular walk. I know that it's for muh atmosphere, but I'm dead certain that anyone in that situation wouldn't walk around like htey have shit in their pants.

OPs a delusional faggot, Shelby's the killer regardless of choices

>Why does Sup Forums praise this game?
It had the greatest madlad prankster ever written

>BOO
>HAHAHAHAHHAAAAAHAAAAAAAA
>GREAT PRANK BRO

>game
that's the problem, isn't it

>t.Never played the game

I played it multiple times, I was just commenting on all the shitty "pranks" people played on each other throughout

>Ohhhh a sleepover. Can we order some pizza?
>All right, I'll hold still for a second. TIMES UP WOOBAWOOBAWOOBA
I fell in love with Josh during that scene.

because based Grant Ward is based in this game

Sup Forums isn't one person and I've seen my fair share of other anons ragging on this game.

We all know who the real star is

It's pretty obvious you've never actually played Heavy Rain. Until Dawn isn't great, but compared to the other "games" in its genre it's a masterpiece.

>mfw it was all just a prank

Sounds like you went in with the wrong expectations, OP. It's an interactive B-horror movie, full stop. If you're a fan of B-horror (or anything involving Fessenden), interactive movie games, or just plain entertainment it's top-tier.

>Heavy Rain did this thing, fucking 10 years ago, where the actual plot, the identity of the killer and the ending actually changed based on your choices.

I don't have an image to help convey just how stupid you are.

Until Dawn 2 where all the cast from Until Dawn 1 is back but playing different characters and the main bad guys are Skinwalkers with the order they replace the characters being randomized every new game FUCKING WHEN!?!?!?

Until Dawn 2 is "The Inpatient"

he really was.

hmm so what is it telling the story of the original miners or something? It's set in the same sanatorium right? Damn I was hoping for different monsters than Wendigos again.

More like Until Ward

>Matt and Jess show up for the last 10 minutes of the game after being shelfed forever.

Mike's the only one who proactively got shit done

Will he be ok?

So on the PS+ info page it says you need 38Gb space, here it says I have 63Gb but I can't install it.

I've found that PS4 typically needs the full amount of space to download AND the full amount to install, so 38*2

Holy fuck they didn't fix that shit from the PS3?
It was easily the most annoying shit ever, particularly for big games

>Friends do prank
>gets 2 sisters killed
>He does prank
>gets no one killed
>WHAT THE FUCK JOSH YOURE AN ASSHOLE!
What did they mean by this

They were pissed that his prank was so much better

Hidden Agenda looks ok, but I want a real Until Dawn 2.

welp, guess I'll try to find it cheap in a store on disc.

>Hidden Agenda
I have a group of friends that all liked Until Dawn so I'm personally super psyched for Hidden Agenda

>Josh organizes a prank to get revenge on the prank done to Hannah
>Mainly targets Chris, the one person who had no involvement in the prank whatsoever
Honestly, what did he even do the others? He fucked with Sam a bit but Chris and Ashley got the brunt of it. Seems like it was more about getting the two of them to fuck than revenge.

What was his plan with Emily and Matt?

What a bro

Yeah it's weird, Josh didn't prank Mike at all even though the original prank all centered around him. "Why don't we start with a little making out..."

Presumably he had something planned for Mike and Jessica up in the guest cabin, but the wendigo kidnapping Jess and Mike running off to the sanatorium ruined that plan.

Throw them off the cliff to their deaths.
Quite the funny prank, a true classic.

It's not a good game imo, it's fun because it's so bad.

>Hidden Agenda
I hadn't heard about this until just now it look bloody great.

Pays homage to the original prank too!

Yeah they cured him and he lived happily ever after the end.

Is he alright

>Heavy Rain did this thing, fucking 10 years ago, where the actual plot, the identity of the killer and the ending actually changed based on your choices.

OP got the secret ending where Ethan was the killer and Shelby brought him down and was a hero.

user most people like movies. Some of those people are in Sup Forums, therefor some people in Sup Forums like this movie.