Which one is the better game and why?

Which one is the better game and why?

Horizon is boring. its another copy/paste of every popular game trope right now..

Which one had the most corporate fanatics behind it before it even was announced?

what do you think

>ubisoftlike game #38900 game vs zelda game
is easy

also, this towers are the AC towers in this game, revealing every shit and secret in the area

i played both

HZD is nothing new, NOTHING, also the story is stupidly complicated but is all already seen. The combat is the same shit 3rd shooter

BOTW is a fucking fresh air in OW, the story is fucking simple but it works, holy shit it works, characters are deeps like a sheet of paper, they are bidimensional but they works, they are iconic. The vcombat is meh, it has qte, but if you are a imaginative person you can do all the fuck you want for killing people.

The comparison is pitiless.

>Sup Forums is STILL not over Botswana

Who knew

>other developers aren't allowed to rehash the same basic game over and over but it's ok when Nintendo does

>zelda botw
>rehash of ubishit
ehi anons he does'nt play BOTW, he is her only for shitposting, get out you fucking piece of shit.

>tons of souls games
>tons of metal gear games
>tons of cod games
>tons of battlefield games
>tons of (insert prostituted game here) games

B-BUT NINTENDO

>Nintendo actually having a contender against almighty sony
Oh how the giants have fallen

>Which one is the better game
Zelda
>why?
It's not a generic Feminist Action Game

they are both shit

>asscreed clone
>an actual open-world game
Gee, I wonder...

Why does it have to be one another? Why is it so hard to admit that they are both good games?

le cucks XDD amirite poltard

That would be fine if they are both good games.

Which they are, both reviewers and players agree on that. It's only here on fucking Sup Forums where HZD gets shat on.

>Which they are

>Which they are
really, no

both Zelda BOTW and HZD are phenomenal games. Just because some autists are REEEEEEEE'ing over that on a Burmanese horsepegging board does not change that fact.

Why are you posting on Sup Forums then? everyone knows shit on Sup Forums doesnt affect sales or the general public's view on a game.
You're still a faggot with shit taste though.

BotW is the most different Zelda game out there
besides even if it was rehashed it would be forgiven because the games it would be rehashing aren't shit unlike ubisoft games

Because other than the "every game is literally shit"-mentality here, there are a lot of good threads here daily.

HZD is legit forgettable though, gameplay can carry it only so far
And thats mostly against larger robots, humanoid enemies are dumb as hell and uninteresting

I like them both. :3

HZD. Didn,t do them much good tho.

Idk man it's not like other Zelda games, have you played it?
The item system is totally fucking wonky.
Weapons break down and you have to pick up items all the time.
The master sword has a cool down.

HZD, because it doesn't try to wear a false face and say it's "innovative". They took the best elements, refined them, and that was the end of it... MEANWHILE, Zelda BotW has been harkened at this point to be the next messiah when, no, it's just another shitty open world. Worse, in fact, with elements that are just asinine. However, you'll have people in this board automatically jump to its defense when this is stated, call out a shill, when the truth hurts, doesn't it. I guess another way to put it is Nintendo fags are so harmful to the game that HZD wins by default because fuck. You.

>refined them
never ever

Horizon is a boring slog with Ubisoft/EA tier mechanics.

BotW is a glorified tech demo with a phenomenal physics engine and gameplay mechanics.

Having said that, I enjoyed BotW a whole lot more, but it felt unfinished for having such a large overworld. Zeldafags hailing BotW as a 10/10 are fucking delusional. It's an 8.5 at best.

>Weapons break
The best fucking casual filter. You just suck m8. The game throws weapons at you the entire time, what are you complaining about?

Horizon was garbage it had a ton of ubishit elements like climbable towers to reveal the map instead of exploring, pointless collectibles, EZ gimmicky bosses, very very few dungeons, and a simplistic story that wasn't fitting for a video game and characters who had next to no characterization.

Blatantly BotW.
As overrated as BotW is (and it absolutely fucking is), it's a far superior product than HZD.
HZD is the definition of generic.

As much as I have no problem with weapons breaking, the fact that they do is why we fight the same 3 enemies for 99% of the game. Such a let down in the monster department.

fucking dammit

>asking Sup Forums - Nintendo which game between a sony and nintendo game is better
You can even get banned if you say it's not the nintendo one. All hail nintendo, god of rehas...I mean video games.

>nintendo makes good new franchises
LOL DEAD GAEM
>nintendo makes good old franchises
LOL REHASH

It's never okay when Nintendo does it.

You did finish it right?
It doesn't sound like you played it at all.

>BotW
>rehash of Zelda

Shit nigger, a lot of people actually WISH BotW was a rehash. It is vastly different from every previous Zelda title to the point where fanatical fans hate it for being too different.

...

>mfw the only thing that can deny Zelda every GOTY award is Mario

Xenoblade Chronicles 2 will be the true open world game

Zelda was just a tech demo.

>it doesn't try to wear a false face and say it's "innovative".
Yes it did.

>best elements
Not at all.

>refined them
Am I being rused?

and DOS2

DOS2 doesn't count it's a game that's not on consoles and nobody played it.

Anyone else hate the combat/class/move system in XCX?

but it's good like Zelda BOTW

DoS2 isn't given the AAA treatment and advertising so no

it's a fucking C-list game. if it was worth anything it would be on consoles where people actually play games.

lol you must be trolling you fucking peasant
also there are talks of it getting a console release, so calm your 30fps ass down.
I would call it B-List in terms of marketing/industry love. It's A-list in terms of quality.

Horizon has an interesting premise and well developed explanation for its plot, it's actually surprising (of course the execution of it was shoddy). But it's a western game so the artstyle of humans is atrocious, has the shitty over-the-shoulder NPC conversation system where a lot of time is spent on facial animations but it still looks like shit, and the combat aside from big machines is very unappealing (melee moves auto-track, boring stealth elements, etc)

Zelda BotW has neat physics implemented into combat and puzzle-solving, and Dragon'sDogma-like elements with fun and sometimes seemengly random world/enemy interactions that just make a person smile. However outside of that it's a very basic and boring game, almost feels like a beta-test for the next decade of Zelda games. Very little enemy diversity, "Zelda dungeons" as we know them are non-existent and were substituted by shitty shrines and disappointingly small "dungeons" all of which has the same aesthetic and almost copy/paste boss. Word itself is vertical and sometimes interesting but the Ubisoft-like copy/paste same-y enemy camp placement does a big disservice. It's a new era of Zelda but without soul. Hopefuly the next entry will have Majora'sMask-tier side-quests, ACTUAL dungeons, and none of the lazy open-world memes like all the shrines or Korok Seeds as rewards every single time. And if it's asking too much: An actual interesting world (the overall theme is what I mean) and at least a memorable story? Maybe?

TL;DR: Both games are mediocre for different reasons. Both games did a thing really well but everything else surrounding that thing is disappointing.

>Dragon'sDogma-like elements
>Majora'sMask-tier side-quests,
should have proofread the pasta before pasting from notepad user

Horizon Zero Dawn.

It's not pasta and it's also not wrong. Dragon'sDogma has plenty of zany shit you can do to NPCs and enemies that don't seem clear at first, just like BotW.
Majora's Mask has by far the best side-quests of any Zelda game (mostly because they were a focus rather than a secondary element)

Feel free to prove me wrong.