Sonic is not made to be nade in 3D

So with the last reviews I find something interesting most of the reviews of sonic forces didnt like the 3D section of the games but they really liked the 2D and with mania having great reviews I kinda think Sonic wasnt made to be made in 3D.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=L-sTKZO8f_k
youtube.com/watch?v=559Q1jNToRY
twitter.com/AnonBabble

your style of posting screams "i am a child"

The 2D sections and levels are shit too

I'd play the 2D ones if the camera wasn't so damn fucking close.
I find them absolutely unplayable.

However, I'm not a "fan" of the 3D ones either. I think only Generations is a genuinly great game. Didn't give Colors much of a chance, though.
SA 2, Boom, Unleashed and 2006 are all just varying degrees of shit, with some so bad they're entertaining.

I think i've figured it out

Good 3D Sonic has downwards vertical level design

What are the best 3D Sonic levels?
Windy Valley, Final Rush, Egg Fleet, in Forces we have Motor Cannon.

All these levels are about rushing downwards, making big jumps and landing on platforms.

Sonic 1- Star Light Zone
Sonic 2- Aquatic Ruin
Sonic 3- Ice Cap Zone
& Knuckles- Death Egg
CD- Quartz Quadrant
Adventure- Twinkle Park
Adventure 2- Final Rush
Heroes- Hang Castle/Mystic Mansion
06- Wave Ocean
Unleashed- Chun-Nan
Colors- Aquarium Park

All the best designed stages in Sonic games.
Source: My Generations hype list

What if we get Christian Whitehead to do the 2D parts and Takashi Iizuka to do the 3D parts and we tell them to make a game together...Profit?

Listen kid, take the extra minute to reread what you type before you post it, alright? This is illegible

Someone post that list of people who worked on each 3D sonic game.

>Well, even when I was making 2D games, I always think in terms of a 3D world. It was the same back in the Sonic days.
-Hirokazu Yasuhara, Chief Level Designer of Sonic 1, director of S3&K.

It's stupid to assume that because incompetent retards have been failing at it for a decade, means that it can't be done.

>So with the last reviews I find something interesting most of the reviews of sonic 4 didnt like the game but they really liked Generations and with Generations having great reviews I kinda think Sonic wasnt made to be made Classic

Put 3D Sonic in the hands of anyone who gives a shit and suddently "OMG Sonic is good in 3D". Most 3D Sonic games suck but recently until Mania, everyone was screaming "OMG Sonic was NEVER good".

>made to be nade
Was this written on some jarhead's helmet in 'nam?
awful thread

I rather have Iizuka fuck off desu lad

youtube.com/watch?v=L-sTKZO8f_k

So what if we give it to nintendo they already made a good "3D sonic" level in mario Oddisey.

everyone agrees the classic sonic stages are the worst

it being 3d isn't why forces is shit

how about no 2d sections. we have 2d sonic games for that

I doubt Nintendo would want to make a Sonic game.

Sonic was made to be made by good developers like Mario. Problem is he has shit developers who don't know what to do, unlike Mario.

Mario Odyssey's incline based rolling/running/jumping is a slower 2D version of how Sonic was intended to be.

Sonic's fundamentals have been proven to work in 3D time and time again, as has Sonic Team's incompetence.

hey. see this thing right here? this thing at the end of each of these sentences? it's called punctuation. learn how to use it.

Actually, that's a question mark at the end of those sentences. He shouldn't be using those to make a statement.

>Not capitalizing the first word on your sentence
>Not using proper punctuation

Speak for yourself, kid.

I've liked almost every 3D sonic i've played.

Even with its flawed, I can't think of another game that gives a similar experience to this franchise. The closest one can get is, oddly enough Mario Kart.

The only game I couldn't get myself to like is Shadow the Hedgeheg, and I even liked SOnic 06 though that's probably because it was the first game I played.

Ironically, Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing is a better kart racing game than Mario Kart too.

youtube.com/watch?v=559Q1jNToRY

Can't wait to see all the glitches with the game.