THE GREAT DEBATE

THE GREAT DEBATE

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=CtG4E4dKjoE
youtube.com/watch?v=BLK7il1UMf8
youtube.com/watch?v=aC_YSaGZRPU
youtube.com/watch?v=wHrwZv6zfqg
twitter.com/AnonBabble

No debate. Most Wanted is strictly better

This.

Carbon is just "okay" at best. I recently started a new a game of it.

I was going to post this, but he did already.

This i prefer Carbon myself because of the drift races but i wouldnt argue that its better

Porsche 2000

fpbp

Most Wanted is objectively better, but I loved canyon duels

i enjoyed both very much but i have fonder memories of carbon, especially the drifting

Hot pursuit trilogy is the only good Need For Speed games

Carbon was fun for the online cops vs racers but that’s all

I can't think of one single person who thinks Carbon comes even close to Most Wanted

I thought so too then I go and actually look at the gameplay and now I'm not so sure.
Still a killer sountrack though.
youtube.com/watch?v=CtG4E4dKjoE

This
MW is great, specially the cop chases

Better tuning, canyon races,lots of muscle cars and night setting with i personally like better than day, aside from those MW is better in all aspects

Neither, amico mio.

youtube.com/watch?v=BLK7il1UMf8

>better driving
>more diverse car selection
>autosculpting
>actual tracks not just walls around the city
>no drag races
>drift is back
>less pressure on police
>night
>no shitty blurry orange mess
>3 additional mechanics
>gang wars
>better waifu

Has anyone ever said Carbon was better?

I don't think I've played in since like 2000 or 1999 but back then it was so fun, even on a PC with just keyboard, HP2 holds up better I believe but I haven't tried the 2010 version since it seemed so tied up into multiplayer

youtube.com/watch?v=aC_YSaGZRPU

There’s always some contrarians

Midnight Club 3

Aspects of each are subjectively better in one than they are in the others, it's mostly a matter of preference

top tier

This one is the best gameplay-wise. Set it loose into open world and change legal racing to shady, and it's best NFS ever made. Also, killer soundtrack.

I liked Carbon more when I played them. Couldn't even finish most wanted cause those arbitrary challenges to unlock races were annoying.

this, although instead of orange bloom we get S H I N E Y

...

Carbon because of the canyon races alone.

most wanted blows carbon away

>he doesn't like cop chases
The shittiest of tastes.

I wonder how many E46 fanboys MW created, I see tons of recreations of the MW paintjob in FH3.

I didn't really like the map of Carbon. The drifting minigame was kinda fun though

Carbon is deep in my heart.

>Carbon is STILL better then all the Need for Speeds that have come out since

Spiritual successor of nfsu2/carbon when

I liked the Need for Speed Shift games.

Wow, this one was so different but good in it's own way. I didn't have much hope but I ended liking it.

Project CARS is literally based on the SHIFT engine and made by the same people and it can be considered a better version.

no

Most wanted is comfy but the literal touge battles in carbon were fun as fuck, that being said MW is better but carbon is underrated as fuck and a close second

Carbon, MW is too repetitive.

MW is repetitive as a motherfucker, most people i knew dropped it around blacklist 5, police chases are the only thing that's going for it
Carbon is still one of the best in the series

Might be the most clear cut "debate" I've ever seen. Most Wanted is the best arcade street racing game of all time. Even has a moderately compelling villian because you want to beat the piss out of him for taking the best sounding car of all time from you. Carbon is a good game and also the last good NFS

I still prefer U1 over all others.

Carbon solely because of this beauty
Most Wanted probably has the worst city, car selection and sound tracks in the franchise

...

No.
THIS is a great debate.

Also Mia best waifu. I just wish they had budget for more cutscenes after the intro.

why didn't they just mash MW and Carbon together, kept the same arcadey handling model without "press x to drift through a corner at full speed", and just expanded the shit out of it? you literally can't fuck this remake up. how inept is EA?

Carbon easily, after you beat a boss it feels like the game progresses to the next area, in MW, similar to Burnout Paradise, its just rinse and repeat after every single boss

This is him now. Fuck I feel old.

>EA games
>ever

Kinda looks like Edward norton

neither hp2

Most Wanted is overrated and Carbon is underrated. Dem downhill drifts.

youtube.com/watch?v=wHrwZv6zfqg

Most Wanted because any car was championship material.
In Carbon you had to keep changing cars to stay competitive, in MW I took my cheap little Mercedes Benz and turned it into a beast with junkman parts and fuckin' blasted the entire blacklist with it.

>Perceptionists
>ILS
>The Prodigy
>Jamiroquai
>The Roots

>worst soundtracks

Sup Forums seems to forget that MW came from the height of the bloom era. How can anyone defend these graphics?

Just turn it off.

unironically why not both?

Nfsu2 for sure. 2nd best racing game ever made with burnout 3 being the first

>burnout 3
never post in my thread again

The crew member mechanic in Carbon is pure cancer.
I tried to replay it recently and was put off by constantly crashing into my stupid crew member.
Also police rubberbanding is bullshit.
>literally catching up to me during nitro injection with their regular cruisers

>not liking burnout
kys my man

Rubberbanding has been in absolutely every NFS game. If you don't like rubberbanding, don't play NFS.

Not to this degree, there's a line which has been overstepped.

Most Wanted.
No debate.

Underground 1 > Underground 2 > Most Wanted > Carbon

It was way worse in carbon though

Explain to me how Underground 1 is better than 2. without mentioning the soundtrack.

Carbon was garbage and is the reason I haven't played a single Need For Speed game since that release.

Much higher difficulty and less rubberbanded AI, better tracks and no stupid SUV races

if you never drive a SUV the races dont even show up retard.

Oh and also no super long and super boring Underground Racing League races, those things sucked ass, "organic" drift was bad too.
Street X was cool tho.
Underground 1 had more Drag races or at least feels like it and those were the best

I seriously dislike overworlds in racing games
Its the reason I hate Burnout Paradise

It's like you don't even 100% every game you play, you casual

100%ing games is a huge fucking drag in most cases. The last time I did that was in Dirt 2 where it took a reasonable amount of time, and I can't remember what game I 100%ed before that. Also especially in racing games you generally have 99% of the content unlocked by the time you're 66% done with the career.

What's the best class in NFS Carbon?

The true debate

What debate is there? Burnout 3 is objectively better

There's no debate. EA won here.

I played them both a lot at the time. MW for the police chases and Burnout 3 for the online.

Razor vs Darius
Who would win in a fist fight?

undercover on PC played in dashcam has surreal sense of speed, but change it to third person and it's like the game slows down or something. shit game but everyone should give it a try with a 430kph+ car. just play in bumber mode

not 3

Theres no debate because each are a different flavor of racing game and both are pretty much the best at what they do
The only reason I dont say Burnout 3 is my favorite of the series is because I spent way, WAY too much time playing Legends on the PSP

these are the only good games in this thread. fuck your open world shit

That's not Revenge

Hot Pursuit, High Stakes and 2000 are still perfectly playable as long as you don't go into them expecting modern physics and graphics. Fuck, the soundtrack alone makes up for it.

Underground isn't as great as its fans proclaim, MW2005 is pretty good as long as you don't use the Speedbreaker shit every thirty seconds because it's laughably overpowered, Carbon is ehhh.

3 is the apex of the franchise tf

A tough one. NFSU2 had style, but Most Wanted had heart. I have to go with Most Wanted. Getting my police pursuits to last multiple hours was such a blast.

Most Wanted.

>tfw you get Baron's pink slip
>tfw I even remember Baron's name after all these years

What an amazing game it was.

Carbon had better aesthetics

razor, he would sabotage darius' audi and then realize he doesn't have the money to buy a new motor cause fuck logic.

This. It's the comfiest nfs.

i remember my pc was so shit that i couldn't play it for more than 10fps and was showing it to a friend i wonder what the fuck did he thought about my crappy pc at that time. And had to suffer through it till 2008 when i got radeon 4850 it was really shit time.

carbon had some of the most fucked drifting physics ive ever seen in a racing game

How is everyone prefer nfsu2 over nfsu?

riders on the storm

I played the demo of NFS carbon for the ps2 so much, but I never got the game